This document is an excerpt from the EUR-Lex website
Document 62023TJ0001
Judgment of the General Court (First Chamber) of 6 September 2023.#Enmacc GmbH v European Commission.#Public supply contracts – Procurement procedure – Organisation of demand aggregation and tendering of gas under the EU Energy Platform – Negotiated procedure without prior publication of a contract notice – Refusal of a request to participate in the procedure – Obligation to state reasons – Article 164(5)(f) of, and point 11.1(c) of Annex I to, Regulation (EU, Euratom) 2018/1046 – Transparency – Equal treatment.#Case T-1/23.
Presuda Općeg suda (prvo vijeće) od 6. rujna 2023.
Enmacc GmbH protiv Europske komisije.
Ugovori o javnoj nabavi usluga – Postupak nadmetanja – Organizacija objedinjavanja zahtjeva i javne nabave plina u okviru Unijine energetske platforme – Pregovarački postupak bez prethodne objave poziva na nadmetanje – Odbijanje zahtjeva za sudjelovanje u postupku – Obveza obrazlaganja – Članak 164. stavak 5. točka (f) i točka 11.1. drugi podstavak podtočka (c) Priloga I. Uredbi (EU, Euratom) 2018/1046 – Transparentnost – Jednako postupanje.
Predmet T-1/23.
Presuda Općeg suda (prvo vijeće) od 6. rujna 2023.
Enmacc GmbH protiv Europske komisije.
Ugovori o javnoj nabavi usluga – Postupak nadmetanja – Organizacija objedinjavanja zahtjeva i javne nabave plina u okviru Unijine energetske platforme – Pregovarački postupak bez prethodne objave poziva na nadmetanje – Odbijanje zahtjeva za sudjelovanje u postupku – Obveza obrazlaganja – Članak 164. stavak 5. točka (f) i točka 11.1. drugi podstavak podtočka (c) Priloga I. Uredbi (EU, Euratom) 2018/1046 – Transparentnost – Jednako postupanje.
Predmet T-1/23.
ECLI identifier: ECLI:EU:T:2023:506
- Date of document:
- 06/09/2023
- Date lodged:
- 04/01/2023
- Author:
- Opći sud
- Country or organisation from which the request originates:
- Njemačka
- Form:
- Presuda
- Authentic language:
- engleski
- Type of procedure:
- Tužba za poništenje - odbijanje zbog neosnovanosti
- Applicant:
- Građanin
- Defendant:
- Institucije i tijela EU-a, Europska komisija
- Judge-Rapporteur:
- Brkan
- Link
- Select all documents mentioning this document
- Affected by case:
-
- Related judicial information 62023TA0001
- Instruments cited in case law:
-
- 12008E122-P1: N 4 94
- 12008E122: N 52
- 12008E263-L4: N 24
- 31971L0305: N 105
- 32015Q0423(01)-A157P2: N 18
- 32015Q0423(01)-A130: N 24
- 32018R1046-N1PT25.3LB: N 100
- 32018R1046-A160: N 115
- 32018R1046-A166: N 117
- 32018R1046-N1PT11.1L2LC: N 28 31 36 38 40 49 55 64 90 104 110 114 124
- 32018R1046-A170P2: N 33
- 32018R1046-A170P3LA: N 33
- 32018R1046-N1: N 33
- 32018R1046: N 34 51
- 32018R1046-A160P1: N 39
- 32018R1046-A160P2: N 39
- 32018R1046-A164P1LD: N 39 40
- 32018R1046-N1PT24: N 40 64
- 32018R1046-N1PT26: N 40 64
- 32018R1046-N1PT41: N 40 64
- 32018R1046-A164P1: N 58
- 32018R1046-N1PT26.1LA: N 59 60 69 - 71 73 83
- 32018R1046-N1PT24.2: N 70
- 32018R1046-A175P2: N 71
- 32018R1046-A175P3: N 71
- 32018R1046-N1PT35.1LA: N 71
- 32018R1046-N1PT35.2: N 71
- 32018R1046-N1PT11.1L2LD: N 73
- 32018R1046-N1PT28.1: N 73
- 32018R1046-N1PT11.1L2LG: N 73 124
- 32018R1046-A175P1: N 73 74
- 32018R1046-N1PT24.3: N 84
- 32018R1046-N1PT24.4: N 84
- 32018R1046-N1PT26.1: N 84
- 32018R1046-N1PT11.1LC: N 9
- 32018R1046-A164P5LF: N 9 28 38 114
- 32022R2576: N 4 15 47 94 100
- 32022R2576-C11: N 5 54
- 32022R2576-C12: N 54
- 32022R2576-C9: N 54
- 32022R2576-A05: N 6
- 32022R2576-A06: N 7 11 97
- 32022R2576-A07: N 7 97 117
- 32022R2576-A07P1LC: N 99
- 52022DC0108: N 45 86 95
- 52022PC0549: N 4 36 45 87 100 101
- 61992CJ0107-N13: N 105
- 61992CJ0328: N 112
- 61994CJ0318-N14: N 41
- 61998CJ0016: N 123
- 62000CJ0023-N51: N 26
- 62000CJ0023-N52: N 26
- 62002CJ0394-N42: N 103
- 62002CJ0394-N43: N 103
- 62006TJ0258-N141: N 119
- 62007CJ0199: N 123
- 62007CJ0250-N34: N 42
- 62008CJ0275-N9: N 106
- 62008CJ0275-N56: N 42
- 62008CJ0275-N72: N 91
- 62008TJ0554-N127: N 51
- 62010TJ0447-N71: N 33
- 62012CO0352-N50: N 41
- 62012CO0352-N51: N 42
- 62013TJ0695-N96: N 41
- 62014TJ0099-N69: N 119
- 62015TJ0726: N 122
- 62021TJ0054-N41: N 33
- Notes relating to the decision:
-
- 1. Simovart, Mari Ann: Rules governing the negotiated procedure without prior publication: the case of Enmacc v Commission (T-1/23), Public Procurement Law Review 2024, Issue 2, NA35-NA41 (EN)
- Subject matter:
- Case law directory code:
-
