This document is an excerpt from the EUR-Lex website
Document 62011CO0167
Order of the Court (Seventh Chamber) of 22 March 2012. # Cantiere navale De Poli SpA v European Commission. # Appeal - Article 119 of the Rules of Procedure - State aid - Incompatibility with the common market - Commission Decision - Alteration to existing aid - Regulation (EC) No 794/2004 - Regulation (EC) No 1177/2002 - Temporary defensive mechanism for shipbuilding. # Case C-167/11 P.
Order of the Court (Seventh Chamber) of 22 March 2012.
Cantiere navale De Poli SpA v European Commission.
Appeal - Article 119 of the Rules of Procedure - State aid - Incompatibility with the common market - Commission Decision - Alteration to existing aid - Regulation (EC) No 794/2004 - Regulation (EC) No 1177/2002 - Temporary defensive mechanism for shipbuilding.
Case C-167/11 P.
Order of the Court (Seventh Chamber) of 22 March 2012.
Cantiere navale De Poli SpA v European Commission.
Appeal - Article 119 of the Rules of Procedure - State aid - Incompatibility with the common market - Commission Decision - Alteration to existing aid - Regulation (EC) No 794/2004 - Regulation (EC) No 1177/2002 - Temporary defensive mechanism for shipbuilding.
Case C-167/11 P.
Court reports – general – 'Information on unpublished decisions' section
ECLI identifier: ECLI:EU:C:2012:164
- Date of document:
- 22/03/2012
- Date lodged:
- 05/04/2011
- Author:
- An Chúirt Bhreithiúnais
- Country or organisation from which the request originates:
- An Iodáil
- Form:
- Ordú
- Authentic language:
- Iodáilis
- Type of procedure:
- Achomharc - gan bhunús, Caingean le haghaidh neamhniú, Achomharc - neamh-inghlactha
- Judge-Rapporteur:
- von Danwitz
- Advocate General:
- Bot
- Treaty:
- An Conradh ar Fheidhmiú an Aontais Eorpaigh
- Link
- Select all documents mentioning this document
- Case affecting:
-
- Confirms 62008TJ0584
- Instruments cited in case law:
-
- 11997E087-P2: N 113
- 11997E087-P3: N 113
- 11997E088-P3: N 113
- 12008E/PRO/03-A58L1: N 99
- 12008E256: N 99
- 31999R0659-A01LC: N 97 99
- 32002R1177: N 31 37 45 47 57 58 62 63 65 69 72 75 79 81 86 98
- 32002R1177-A05: N 32 50 52 56 60
- 32002R1177-A02P4: N 46 48 55
- 32002R1177-A04: N 59 61
- 32002R1177-A02P1: N 91
- 32004R0794-A04P1: N 97 99
- 32010CD0038: N 1
- 32012Q0929(01)-A119: N 22
- 32012Q0929(01)-A112P1LC: N 99
- 61998CJ0352: N 99
- 62000CJ0041: N 99
- 62003CJ0131: N 99
- 62003CJ0397: N 88
- 62006CJ0003: N 88
- 62007CJ0127: N 74
- 62007CJ0334: N 51
- 62007CJ0514: N 90
- 62008TJ0584: N 1 - 122
- 62009CJ0067: N 74 76 82 92
- 62009CJ0071: N 37 43 111
- Notes relating to the decision:
-
- 1. Reich, Dietmar O.: Illegal State Aid for Shipbuilding in Italy - Life Punishes Those Who Delay, European State Aid Law Quarterly 2013 p.737-743 (EN)
- Subject matter:
- Case law directory code:
-
Order of the Court (Seventh Chamber) of 22 March 2012 —
Cantiere navale De Poli v Commission
(Case C‑167/11 P)
Appeal — Article 119 of the Rules of Procedure — State aid — Incompatibility with the common market — Commission decision — Alteration to existing aid — Regulation (EC) No 794/2004 — Regulation (EC) No 1177/2002 — Temporary defensive mechanism for shipbuilding
1. State aid — Planned aid — Notifying the Commission — Member States’ discretion concerning the date of notification — In the case of a temporary defensive mechanism, notification necessary before the regulation authorising the grant of aid expires (Art. 88(3) EC; Council Regulation No 1177/2002, Art. 5) (see paras 31, 32)
2. Appeals — Pleas in law — Plea raised against a ground of the judgment not necessary to support the operative part — Plea ineffective (see para. 43)
3. State aid — Planned aid — Examination by the Commission — Application of the rules of substantive law in force when the Commission took its decision (Art. 88(3) EC; Council Regulation No 1177/2002, Art. 5) (see paras 51-53)
4. Union law — Principles — Equal treatment — Meaning — Unequal treatment as a result of the temporal limitation of authorisation to grant State aid in a given sector of the market — Whether objectively justified (Council Regulation No 1177/2002, Art. 5) (see paras 74-76)
5. State aid — Commission decision finding a national measure compatible with Article 87(1) EC — No legitimate expectations in the case of alteration to the aid scheme going beyond the bounds of the authorisation decision (Art. 87(1) EC) (see paras 85-87)
6. Appeals — Setting out in the application of the pleas in law and legal arguments — Plea plainly not intended to challenge the judgment — Inadmissibility (Art. 256 TFEU; Statute of the Court of Justice, Art. 58, first para.; Rules of Procedure of the Court of Justice, Art. 112(1)(c)) (see paras 99, 100, 115)
Re:
| Appeal brought against the judgment of the General Court (Eighth Chamber) of 3 February 2011 in Case T‑584/08 | Cantieri Navale De Poli | v | Commission | , by which the Court dismissed the action for annulment of Commission Decision 2010/38/EC of 21 October 2008 on State aid C‑20/08 (ex N 62/08) which Italy is planning to implement through a modification of scheme N 59/04 concerning a temporary defensive mechanism for shipbuilding (OJ 2010 L 17, p. 50). |
Operative part
|
1. |
The appeal is dismissed. |
|
2. |
Cantiere navale De Poli SpA is ordered to pay the costs. |
|
3. |
The Italian Republic is ordered to bear its own costs. |
