EUR-Lex Access to European Union law
This document is an excerpt from the EUR-Lex website
Document 61983CJ0071
Summary of the Judgment
Summary of the Judgment
CONVENTION ON JURISDICTION AND THE ENFORCEMENT OF JUDGMENTS - JURISDICTION AGREEMENT - JURISDICTION CLAUSE IN A BILL OF LADING - VALIDITY - CONDITIONS
( CONVENTION OF 27 SEPTEMBER 1968 , ART . 17 )
A JURISDICTION CLAUSE CONTAINED IN THE PRINTED CONDITIONS ON A BILL OF LADING SATISFIES THE CONDITIONS LAID DOWN BY ARTICLE 17 OF THE CONVENTION :
IF THE AGREEMENT OF BOTH PARTIES TO THE CONDITIONS CONTAINING THAT CLAUSE HAS BEEN EXPRESSED IN WRITING ; OR
IF THE JURISDICTION CLAUSE HAS BEEN THE SUBJECT-MATTER OF A PRIOR ORAL AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE PARTIES EXPRESSLY RELATING TO THAT CLAUSE , IN WHICH CASE THE BILL OF LADING , SIGNED BY THE CARRIER , MUST BE REGARDED AS CONFIRMATION IN WRITING OF THE ORAL AGREEMENT ; OR
IF THE BILL OF LADING COMES WITHIN THE FRAMEWORK OF A CONTINUING BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE PARTIES , IN SO FAR AS IT IS THEREBY ESTABLISHED THAT THE RELATIONSHIP IS GOVERNED BY GENERAL CONDITIONS CONTAINING THE JURISDICTION CLAUSE .
AS REGARDS THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE CARRIER AND A THIRD PARTY HOLDING THE BILL OF LADING , THE CONDITIONS LAID DOWN BY ARTICLE 17 OF THE CONVENTION ARE SATISFIED IF THE JURISDICTION CLAUSE HAS BEEN ADJUDGED VALID AS BETWEEN THE CARRIER AND THE SHIPPER AND IF , BY VIRTUE OF THE RELEVANT NATIONAL LAW , THE THIRD PARTY , UPON ACQUIRING THE BILL OF LADING , SUCCEEDED TO THE SHIPPER ' S RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS .