EUR-Lex Access to European Union law

Back to EUR-Lex homepage

This document is an excerpt from the EUR-Lex website

Document C2005/085E/02

MINUTES
Tuesday 4 May 2004

OJ C 85E, 7.4.2005, p. 16–25 (ES, CS, DA, DE, ET, EL, EN, FR, IT, LV, LT, HU, MT, NL, PL, PT, SK, SL, FI, SV)

7.4.2005   

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

CE 85/16


MINUTES

(2005/C 85 E/02)

PROCEEDINGS OF THE SITTING

IN THE CHAIR: Pat COX

President

1.   Opening of sitting

The sitting opened at 10.10.

2.   Documents received

The following document had been received from the Committee on Budgetary Control:

Recommendation to the Council on the appointment of ten Members of the European Court of Auditors [C5-0197-0206/2004 — 2004/0809A-I(CNS)] — Committee on Budgetary Control.

Rapporteur: Diemut R. Theato (A5-0283/2004).

3.   Tribute to Jean Monnet and commemoration of the 20th anniversary of the draft Treaty establishing the European Union (1984 — Rapporteur: Altiero Spinelli) (debate)

The President made a statement in which he paid tribute to Jean Monnet and Altiero Spinelli and commemorated the 20th anniversary of the draft Treaty establishing the European Union.

The following spoke: Dick Roche (President-in-Office of the Council) and Loyola de Palacio (Vice-President of the Commission).

The following spoke: Giorgio Napolitano (chairman of the AFCO Committee), Íñigo Méndez de Vigo, on behalf of the PPE-DE Group, Richard Corbett, on behalf of the PSE Group, Willy C.E.H. De Clercq, on behalf of the ELDR Group, Sylvia-Yvonne Kaufmann, on behalf of the GUE/NGL Group, Johannes Voggenhuber, on behalf of the Verts/ALE Group, Gerard Collins, on behalf of the UEN Group, Jens-Peter Bonde, on behalf of the EDD Group, Marco Pannella, Non-attached Member, and John Hume.

The debate closed.

IN THE CHAIR: David W. MARTIN

Vice-President

4.   The future of the enlarged Union (general debate)

Council and Commission statements: Towards a European constitution

Council and Commission statements: Enlarged Europe and its neighbours

Commission statement: European economic and social model

Commission statement: Freedom and security for Union citizens

Dick Roche (President-in-Office of the Council) and António Vitorino (Member of the Commission) made the statements: Towards a European constitution

The following spoke: Hans-Gert Poettering, on behalf of the PPE-DE Group, Enrique Barón Crespo, on behalf of the PSE Group, Andrew Nicholas Duff, on behalf of the ELDR Group, Francis Wurtz, on behalf of the GUE/NGL Group, Monica Frassoni, on behalf of the Verts/ALE Group, and Rudolf Ziak, on behalf of the UEN Group.

IN THE CHAIR: Giorgos DIMITRAKOPOULOS

Vice-President

The following spoke: William Abitbol, on behalf of the EDD Group, Georges Berthu, Non-attached Member, Timothy Kirkhope, Klaus Hänsch, Cecilia Malmström, Sylvia-Yvonne Kaufmann, Nelly Maes (as a number of Members were waving regional flags, the President asked them to desist, which they did), Aleksander Marek Szczygło, Nigel Paul Farage, Adam Biela, Jozsef Szajer, Genowefa Grabowska, Claude Turmes, Hans-Peter Martin, Elmar Brok, Proinsias De Rossa, Bruno Gollnisch, Zbigniew Chrzanowski, Pál Vastagh, José María Gil-Robles Gil-Delgado, Carlos Carnero González, Alojz Peterle, Franc Horvat, Antonio Tajani, Panayiotis Demetriou, Thierry Cornillet and Jason Azzopardi.

The debate was suspended at that point for voting time.

It would be resumed at 15.00 (Item 13).

IN THE CHAIR: Pat COX

President

5.   Official welcome

On behalf of Parliament, the President welcomed Princess Victoria of Sweden to the official gallery.

6.   Written declarations and pending written and oral questions

The President announced that, in accordance with Rule 185, written declarations which had not received the signatures of the majority of the Members of Parliament, written questions which had not received an answer and oral questions with debate which had not been dealt with as at 5 May 2004 would be deemed to have lapsed.

7.   Decision on urgent procedure (Rule 112) (procedure)

Request for urgent procedure:

on the proposal for a Council decision on the conclusion of an Agreement between the European Community and the United States of America on the processing and transfer of PNR data by Air Carriers to the United States Department of Homeland Security, Bureau of Customs and Border Protection [COM(2004) 190 — C5-0162/2004 — 2004/0064(CNS)] — Committee on Citizens' Freedoms and Rights, Justice and Home Affairs.

The President announced that, in accordance with the formal legal advice he had sought on the point raised by Sarah Ludford (Minutes of 03.05.2004, Item 15), all Members present, including those from the new Member States, would be able to take part in the decision on urgent procedure.

The following spoke on the request for urgent procedure: Johanna L.A. Boogerd-Quaak (rapporteur), who pointed out that not all the language versions of the proposal for a decision were available, and Hubert Pirker, on behalf of the PPE-DE Group.

The President announced that whatever the outcome of the vote, it would not alter the fact that the matter had been referred to the Court of Justice of the European Communities.

The request for urgent procedure was rejected by EV (301 for, 343 against, 18 absentions).

The President pointed out, in reply to Johanna L.A. Boogerd-Quaak (rapporteur), that transitional arrangements existed to cope with such a situation (Rule 117a).

8.   Voting time

Details of voting (amendments, separate and split votes, etc.) appear in Annex I to the Minutes.

8.1.   Motion of censure on the Commission (vote)

Motion of censure B5-0189/2004

The debate had been held on 21 April 2004(Minutes of 21.04.2004, Item 23)

(Qualified majority)

(Voting record: Annex I)

MOTION OF CENSURE B5-0189/2004

Rejected

Olivier Duhamel spoke.

IN THE CHAIR: Alejo VIDAL-QUADRAS ROCA

Vice-President

Bruno Gollnisch spoke on Olivier Duhamel's remarks.

9.   Explanations of vote

Written explanations of vote:

Explanations of vote submitted in writing under Rule 137(3) appear in the verbatim report of proceedings for this sitting.

Oral explanations of vote:

Motion of censure B5-0189/2004

Daniel J. Hannan, Christopher Heaton-Harris, Robert Goodwill, Theresa Villiers, Roger Helmer, Martin Callanan, Bruno Gollnisch.

10.   Corrections to votes

Corrections to votes were submitted by the following Members:

Motion of censure on the Commission — B5-0189/2004

for: Alexandre Varaut

against: Fernando Pérez Royo

(The sitting, suspended at 13.45, resumed at 15.00.)

IN THE CHAIR: Renzo IMBENI

Vice-President

11.   Approval of Minutes of previous sitting

The Minutes of the previous sitting were approved.

12.   One-minute speeches on matters of political importance

Pursuant to Rule 121a, the following Members who wished to draw the attention of Parliament to matters of political importance spoke for one minute:

Marie-Françoise Duthu, Monica Frassoni, Marios Matsakis, who spoke on the previous speaker's remarks.

13.   General debate — The future of the enlarged Union (continuation of debate)

Poul Nielson (Member of the Commission) and Dick Roche (President-in-Office of the Council) made the statements on Enlarged Europe and its neighbours.

The following spoke: James E.M. Elles, on behalf of the PPE-DE Group, Gary Titley, on behalf of the PSE Group, Cecilia Malmström, on behalf of the ELDR Group, Eleni Mavrou, on behalf of the GUE/NGL Group, Monica Frassoni, on behalf of the Verts/ALE Group, Bastiaan Belder, on behalf of the EDD Group, Philip Claeys, Non-attached Member, Eiki Berg, Andrzej Karol Gawłowski, Marios Matsakis, Hans Modrow, Juris Sokolovskis, Witold Tomczak who, on concluding his speech, carried two Christian crosses to the Presidential bench, and Markus Ferber.

IN THE CHAIR: Charlotte CEDERSCHIÖLD

Vice-President

The following spoke: Pervenche Berès, who protested at Witold Tomczak's gesture, Pasqualina Napoletano, Andrew Nicholas Duff, Arlette Laguiller, Joost Lagendijk, Wacław Klukowski, Per Stenmarck, Libor Rouček, Toomas Savi, Nikolaos Chountis, Antoni Macierewicz, Nelly Maes, József Ékes, Margrietus J. van den Berg, Inger Schörling, Arie M. Oostlander, George Varnava, Elisabeth Schroedter, Lefteris Christoforou, Jacques F. Poos, Philippe Morillon, Birutė Vėsaitė, Aleksandrs Kiršteins, Ioannis Souladakis, Vilém Holėň and Toomas Hendrik Ilves.

IN THE CHAIR: Catherine LALUMIÈRE

Vice-President

The following spoke: Ursula Stenzel, Mario de Marco and Poul Nielson.

Stavros Dimas (Member of the Commission) made the statement on the European economic and social model.

The following spoke: Françoise Grossetête, on behalf of the PPE-DE Group, Robert Goebbels, PSE Group, Anne Elisabet Jensen, on behalf of the ELDR Group, Sylviane H. Ainardi, on behalf of the GUE/NGL Group, Reinhold Messner, on behalf of the Verts/ALE Group, Guntars Krasts, UEN Group, Johannes (Hans) Blokland, on behalf of the EDD Group, Andrzej Zbigniew Lepper, Non-attached Member, and Mart Laar.

IN THE CHAIR: Ingo FRIEDRICH

Vice-President

The following spoke: Grażyna Jolanta Ciemniak, Jacqueline Rousseaux, Camilo Nogueira Román, Adam Jerzy Bielan, Sergej Kozlík, Marianne L.P. Thyssen, Giorgos Katiforis, Janno Reiljan, Janez Podobnik, Zoltán Szabó, Marcin Libicki, Csaba Őry, Pervenche Berès, Czesław Adam Siekierski, Richard Falbr, Franco Marini, Riitta Myller, Josef Bonnici, George William Vella, Jenő Manninger, Jan Andersson and Inese Šlesere.

IN THE CHAIR: Alonso José PUERTA

Vice-President

The following spoke: Róbert Fico, Sérgio Ribeiro, Georg Jarzembowski, Eugeniusz Kłopotek, Daniel Kroupa, Astrid Lulling and Stavros Dimas.

António Vitorino (Member of the Commission) made the statement on freedom and security for Union citizens.

The following spoke: Jorge Salvador Hernández Mollar, on behalf of the PPE-DE Group, Robert J.E. Evans, on behalf of the PSE Group, István Szent-Iványi, on behalf of the ELDR Group, Enric Morera Català, on behalf of the Verts/ALE Group, Jan Zahradil, Ágnes Vadai, Sarah Ludford, Patricia McKenna, Ian R.K. Paisley, Christian Ulrik von Boetticher, Anna Karamanou, Astrid Thors, Liene Liepiņa, Boriss Cilevičs, Bill Newton Dunn, Edmund Kazimierz Wittbrodt, Giacomo Santini, Carlos Coelho, Jacek Protasiewicz, Mihael Brejc and António Vitorino.

The debate closed.

14.   Agenda for next sitting

The President referred Members to the document ‘Agenda’ PE 344.780/OJME.

15.   Closure of sitting

The sitting closed at 20.30.

Julian Priestley

Secretary-General

Pat Cox

President


ATTENDANCE REGISTER

The following signed:

Aaltonen, Abitbol, Adam, Aguiriano Nalda, Nuala Ahern, Ainardi, Almeida Garrett, Alyssandrakis, A. Nagy, Andersen, Andersson, Andreasen, André-Léonard, Andrews, Aparicio Sánchez, Arvidsson, Atkins, Attard-Montalto, Attwooll, Auroi, Averoff, Avilés Perea, Ayuso González, Azzopardi, Bagó, Bakopoulos, Balfe, Balsai, Baltas, Banotti, Barón Crespo, Bartolozzi, Bastos, Bastys, Bauer, Bayona de Perogordo, Beazley, Bébéar, Belder, Beneš, Beňová, Berend, Berenguer Fuster, Berès, van den Berg, Berg, Bergaz Conesa, Berger, Berlato, Bernié, Berthu, Bertinotti, Beysen, Biela, Bielan, Bigliardo, Blak, Blokland, Kazys Jaunutis Bobelis, Bodrato, Böge, Bösch, von Boetticher, Bonde, Bonino, Bonnici, Boogerd-Quaak, Bordes, Borghezio, van den Bos, Boumediene-Thiery, Bowis, Bradbourn, Mihael Brejc, Bremmer, Breyer, Brie, Brocka, Brok, Buitenweg, Bullmann, Bushill-Matthews, Busk, Butel, Callanan, Camisón Asensio, Camre, Cardoso, Carlotti, Carnero González, Carraro, Carrilho, Casaca, Cashman, Caudron, Caullery, Cauquil, Cederschiöld, Celli, Cercas, Cerdeira Morterero, Ceyhun, Chichester, Chountis, Christoforou, Chronowski, Zbigniew Chrzanowski, Ciborowska, Ciemniak, Cilevičs, Claeys, Clegg, Cocilovo, Coelho, Collins, Corbett, Corbey, Cornillet, Corrie, Paolo Costa, Coûteaux, Cox, Crowley, Cushnahan, Cybulski, Czinege, van Dam, Darras, Daul, Davies, De Clercq, Dehousse, De Keyser, Dell'Alba, de Marco, Demetriou, Deprez, De Rossa, De Sarnez, Descamps, Désir, Deva, De Veyrac, Dhaene, Didžiokas, Díez González, Di Lello Finuoli, Dillen, Dimitrakopoulos, Doorn, Dover, Drzęźla, Dührkop Dührkop, Duff, Duhamel, Duin, Dupuis, Duthu, Dybkjær, Ebner, Echerer, Ekert, Ékes, El Khadraoui, Elles, Eörsi, Eriksson, Esclopé, Ettl, Jillian Evans, Jonathan Evans, Robert J.E. Evans, Färm, Falbr, Farage, Fatuzzo, Fava, Fazakas, Ferber, Fernández Martín, Ferrández Lezaun, Ferreira, Ferrer, Fico, Fiebiger, Figueiredo, Filipek, Fiori, Fitzsimons, Flemming, Flesch, Florenz, Formentini, Foster, Fourtou, Fraisse, Frassoni, Friedrich, Fruteau, Gadzinowski, Gahler, Gahrton, Gaľa, Gałażewski, Galbavý, Garaud, García-Margallo y Marfil, García-Orcoyen Tormo, Gargani, Garot, Garriga Polledo, Gawłowski, Gebhardt, Germič, Ghilardotti, Giertych, Gill, Gillig, Gil-Robles Gil-Delgado, Glante, Glase, Goebbels, Goepel, Görlach, Golde, Gollnisch, Gomolka, Goodwill, Gorostiaga Atxalandabaso, Gouveia, Genowefa Grabowska, Graefe zu Baringdorf, Graça Moura, Gröner, Grönfeldt Bergman, Grosch, Grossetête, Gruber, Grzebisz-Nowicka, Grzyb, Gurmai, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Guy-Quint, Gyürk, Hänsch, Hager, Hannan, Hansenne, Harbour, Hatzidakis, Haug, Hazan, Heaton-Harris, Hedkvist Petersen, Hegyi, Helmer, Heriban, Hermange, Hernández Mollar, Herranz García, Herzog, Hieronymi, Hoff, Holáň, Honeyball, Hortefeux, Horvat, Howitt, Hudghton, Hughes, Huhne, van Hulten, Hume, Hyland, Iivari, Ilves, Imbeni, Inglewood, Isler Béguin, Iwiński, Izquierdo Collado, Izquierdo Rojo, Jackson, Jakič, Jarzembowski, Jerzy Jaskiernia, Jean-Pierre, Jeggle, Jensen, Jöns, Jové Peres, Kaldi, Kamiński, Kāposts, Karamanou, Karas, Karlsson, Kastler, Katiforis, Kaufmann, Kauppi, Kelemen, Keppelhoff-Wiechert, Keßler, Khanbhai, Kindermann, Glenys Kinnock, Kirkhope, Kiršteins, Klamt, Klaß, Kļaviņš, Klich, Kłopotek, Klukowski, Knolle, Koch, Konečná, Konrad, Korakas, Korhola, Kósáné Kovács, Koukiadis, Koulourianos, Kowalska, Kozlík, Krarup, Krasts, Kratsa-Tsagaropoulou, Krehl, Kreissl-Dörfler, Kriščiūnas, Krivine, Kronberger, Daniel Kroupa, Kubica, Kubovič, Kuckelkorn, Kuhne, Kuntz, Kuzmickas, Kvietkauskas, Laar, Lachnit, Lage, Lagendijk, Laguiller, Lalumière, Lamassoure, Lambert, Landsbergis, Lang, Lange, Langen, de La Perriere, Laschet, Laštůvka, Lavarra, Lechner, Lehne, Leinen, Lepper, Janusz Lewandowski, Liberadzki, Libicki, Liepiņa, Liese, Linkohr, Lisak, Litwiniec, Lobkowicz, Lucas, Ludford, Lulling, Lund, Lydeka, Lynne, Łyżwiński, Maat, Maaten, McAvan, McCarthy, McCartin, MacCormick, Macierewicz, McKenna, McMillan-Scott, McNally, Maes, Maldeikis, Malliori, Mallotová, Malmström, Manders, Manisco, Erika Mann, Manninger, Thomas Mann, Marinho, Marini, Marinos, Markov, Marques, Marset Campos, David W. Martin, Hans-Peter Martin, Hugues Martin, Martinez, Martínez Martínez, Maštálka, Mastorakis, Mathieu, Matikainen-Kallström, Matsakis, Mavrou, Hans-Peter Mayer, Xaver Mayer, Mayol i Raynal, Medina Ortega, Meijer, Méndez de Vigo, Mendiluce Pereiro, Menéndez del Valle, Menrad, Messner, Miguélez Ramos, Miller, Miranda de Lage, Modrow, Mombaur, Monsonís Domingo, Montfort, Moraes, Morera Català, Morgan, Morgantini, Morillon, Müller, Mulder, Muscardini, Musumeci, Myller, Naïr, Napoletano, Napolitano, Naranjo Escobar, Nassauer, Németh, Newton Dunn, Nicholson, Nicholson of Winterbourne, Niebler, Nisticò, Nobilia, Nogueira Román, Nordmann, Obiols i Germà, Ojeda Sanz, Olsson, Ó Neachtain, Onesta, Oomen-Ruijten, Oostlander, Oreja Arburúa, Ortuondo Larrea, Őry, O'Toole, Ouzký, Oviir, Paasilinna, Pacheco Pereira, Paciotti, Pack, Paisley, Palečková, Pannella, Papayannakis, Parish, Pasqua, Pasternak, Pastorelli, Patakis, Patrie, Paulsen, Pęczak, Pérez Álvarez, Pérez Royo, Perry, Pesälä, Alojz Peterle, Pex, Piecyk, Pieniążek, Pirker, Piscarreta, Pittella, Plokšto, Plooij-van Gorsel, Podestà, Podgórski, Podobnik, Poettering, Pohjamo, Poignant, Pomés Ruiz, Poos, Pospíšil, Prets, Procacci, Pronk, Protasiewicz, Provan, Puerta, Purvis, Pusz, Queiró, Quisthoudt-Rowohl, Rack, Radwan, Randzio-Plath, Ransdorf, Rapkay, Raschhofer, Read, Redondo Jiménez, Janno Reiljan, Ribeiro, Ribeiro e Castro, Riis-Jørgensen, Rocard, Rod, Rögnerová, de Roo, Roth-Behrendt, Rothe, Rothley, Rouček, Roure, Rousseaux, Rovsing, Rübig, Rühle, Ruffolo, Rutelli, Rutkowski, Sacrédeus, Saint-Josse, Sakellariou, Sandberg-Fries, Sandbæk, Sanders-ten Holte, Santer, Santini, dos Santos, Sauquillo Pérez del Arco, Savary, Savi, Sbarbati, Scallon, Scarbonchi, Schaffner, Scheele, Schierhuber, Schleicher, Gerhard Schmid, Herman Schmid, Olle Schmidt, Schmitt, Schnellhardt, Schörling, Ilka Schröder, Jürgen Schröder, Schroedter, Schulz, Schwaiger, Sedlickas, Sefzig, Seppänen, Ševc, Sichrovsky, Siekierski, Simpson, Širca, Sjöstedt, Skinner, Šlesere, Smet, Smoleń, Smorawiński, Sörensen, Sokolovskis, Sommer, Soriano Gil, Sornosa Martínez, Souchet, Souladakis, Sousa Pinto, Speroni, Staes, Stauner, Stenmarck, Stenzel, Sterckx, Stevenson, Stihler, Stirbois, Stockmann, Stockton, Sturdy, Sudre, Šulák, Suominen, Surján, Svoboda, Swiebel, Swoboda, Szabó, Szájer, Szczygło, Szent-Iványi, Sørensen, Tabajdi, Tajani, Tannock, Terrón i Cusí, Theato, Theorin, Thomas-Mauro, Thorning-Schmidt, Thors, Thyssen, Titford, Titley, Tomaka, Tomczak, Torres Marques, Trakatellis, Trentin, Twinn, Uca, Vachetta, Vaculík, Vadai, Väyrynen, Vairinhos, Valenciano Martínez-Orozco, Vallvé, Valys, Van Hecke, Van Lancker, Van Orden, Varaut, Varela Suanzes-Carpegna, Vári, George Varnava, Vastagh, Vatanen, Vattimo, Vella, van Velzen, Vėsaitė, de Veyrinas, Vidal-Quadras Roca, Vila Abelló, Villiers, Vinci, Virrankoski, Vlasto, Voggenhuber, Volcic, Wachtmeister, Wallis, Walter, Watson, Watts, Weiler, Wenderlich, Wenzel-Perillo, Whitehead, Widuch, Wieland, Wiersma, Wijkman, Wikiński, Winiarczyk-Kossakowska, Wiśniowska, Wittbrodt, von Wogau, Janusz Czeskaw Wojciechowski, Wuermeling, Wuori, Wurtz, Wyn, Wynn, Xarchakos, Zabell, Záborská, Zacharakis, Zahradil, Zappalà, Żenkiewicz, Žiak, Zimmerling, Zissener, Zorba, Zrihen


ANNEX I

RESULTS OF VOTES

Abbreviations and symbols

+

adopted

-

rejected

lapsed

W

withdrawn

RCV (…, …, …)

roll-call vote (for, against, abstentions)

EV (…, …, …)

electronic vote (for, against, abstentions)

split

split vote

sep

separate vote

am

amendment

CA

compromise amendment

CP

corresponding part

D

deleting amendment

=

identical amendments

§

paragraph

art

article

rec

recital

MOT

motion for a resolution

JT MOT

joint motion for a resolution

SEC

secret ballot

1.   Motion of censure on the Commission

Motion of censure (B5-0189/2004)

Subject

Amendment No

Author

RCV, etc.

Vote

RCV/EV — remarks

vote: motion of censure (whole text)

RCV

-

88, 515, 63

Majority required: two-thirds of the votes cast, representing a majority of Parliament's component Members (Rule 34(7)).


ANNEX II

RESULT OF ROLL-CALL VOTES

1.   B5-0189/2004 — Motion of censure on the Commission

For: 88

EDD: Abitbol, Andersen, Belder, Bernié, Blokland, Bonde, Butel, Coûteaux, van Dam, Esclopé, Farage, Kuntz, Saint-Josse, Sandbæk, Titford

GUE/NGL: Alyssandrakis, Blak, Bordes, Cauquil, Eriksson, Korakas, Krarup, Krivine, Laguiller, Meijer, Patakis, Ransdorf, Schmid Herman, Schröder Ilka, Seppänen, Sjöstedt, Vachetta

NI: Berthu, Biela, Borghezio, Claeys, Dillen, Filipek, Giertych, Gollnisch, Hager, Klukowski, Kronberger, Lang, de La Perriere, Lepper, Łyżwiński, Macierewicz, Martin Hans-Peter, Martinez, Paisley, Sichrovsky, Souchet, Speroni, Stirbois, Tomczak, Varaut, Wiśniowska

PPE-DE: Callanan, Goodwill, Hannan, Heaton-Harris, Helmer, Nicholson, Sacrédeus, Scallon, Schleicher, Stauner, Villiers

PSE: Dehousse

UEN: Bielan, Bigliardo, Camre, Caullery, Kamiński, Libicki, Pasqua, Reiljan, Szczygło, Thomas-Mauro, Žiak

Verts/ALE: Duthu, Gahrton, Hudghton, MacCormick, McKenna, Mayol i Raynal, Schörling

Against: 515

EDD: Mathieu

ELDR: Andreasen, André-Léonard, Attwooll, Boogerd-Quaak, van den Bos, Busk, Clegg, Costa Paolo, Davies, De Clercq, Duff, Dybkjær, Eörsi, Flesch, Formentini, Germič, Heriban, Huhne, Jakič, Jensen, Kuzmickas, Kvietkauskas, Ludford, Lydeka, Maaten, Malmström, Manders, Matsakis, Monsonís Domingo, Mulder, Newton Dunn, Nicholson of Winterbourne, Nordmann, Olsson, Oviir, Paulsen, Pesälä, Plooij-van Gorsel, Pohjamo, Procacci, Riis-Jørgensen, Rögnerová, Rousseaux, Rutelli, Sanders-ten Holte, Sbarbati, Schmidt, Sedlickas, Širca, Sterckx, Szent-Iványi, Sørensen, Thors, Väyrynen, Vallvé, Van Hecke, Virrankoski, Watson

GUE/NGL: Ainardi, Bakopoulos, Bergaz Conesa, Bertinotti, Caudron, Di Lello Finuoli, Fraisse, Jové Peres, Kaufmann, Koulourianos, Manisco, Markov, Marset Campos, Morgantini, Naïr, Papayannakis, Puerta, Scarbonchi, Ševc, Vinci

NI: Beysen, Dell'Alba, Della Vedova, Dupuis, Kozlík, Pannella

PPE-DE: Almeida Garrett, A. Nagy, Arvidsson, Averoff, Avilés Perea, Ayuso González, Azzopardi, Bagó, Balsai, Banotti, Bauer, Bayona de Perogordo, Beneš, Berend, Bodrato, von Boetticher, Bonnici, Bourlanges, Brejc, Bremmer, Brocka, Brok, Camisón Asensio, Cardoso, Cederschiöld, Chronowski, Chrzanowski, Cornillet, Cushnahan, Daul, de Marco, Deprez, De Sarnez, Descamps, De Veyrac, Didžiokas, Dimitrakopoulos, Doorn, Ebner, Ékes, Fatuzzo, Ferber, Fernández Martín, Flemming, Florenz, Fourtou, Friedrich, Gahler, Gaľa, Gałażewski, Galbavý, García-Margallo y Marfil, García-Orcoyen Tormo, Garriga Polledo, Gil-Robles Gil-Delgado, Glase, Goepel, Golde, Gomolka, Gouveia, Grönfeldt Bergman, Grosch, Grossetête, Gruber, Gutiérrez-Cortines, Gyürk, Hansenne, Hatzidakis, Hermange, Hernández Mollar, Herranz García, Hieronymi, Holáň, Jarzembowski, Jeggle, Kaldi, Karas, Kastler, Kauppi, Kelemen, Keppelhoff-Wiechert, Kiršteins, Klamt, Klaß, Kļaviņš, Klich, Kłopotek, Knolle, Koch, Kratsa-Tsagaropoulou, Kroupa, Kubovič, Lamassoure, Langen, Laschet, Lechner, Lehne, Lewandowski, Liepiņa, Liese, Lobkowicz, Lulling, Maat, McCartin, Mallotová, Manninger, Mann, Marini, Marinos, Marques, Martin Hugues, Matikainen-Kallström, Mayer Hans-Peter, Mayer Xaver, Méndez de Vigo, Menrad, Mombaur, Montfort, Morillon, Naranjo Escobar, Nassauer, Németh, Niebler, Ojeda Sanz, Oomen-Ruijten, Oostlander, Oreja Arburúa, Őry, Pack, Palečková, Pérez Álvarez, Peterle, Pex, Pirker, Piscarreta, Podobnik, Poettering, Pomés Ruiz, Posselt, Pronk, Protasiewicz, Quisthoudt-Rowohl, Rack, Radwan, Redondo Jiménez, Rovsing, Rübig, Salafranca Sánchez-Neyra, Santer, Schaffner, Schierhuber, Schmitt, Schnellhardt, Schröder Jürgen, Schwaiger, Siekierski, Šlesere, Smet, Smorawiński, Sommer, Stenmarck, Stenzel, Sudre, Suominen, Surján, Svoboda, Szájer, Theato, Thyssen, Tomaka, Trakatellis, Vaculík, Varela Suanzes-Carpegna, Vatanen, van Velzen, de Veyrinas, Vidal-Quadras Roca, Vila Abelló, Vlasto, Wachtmeister, Wenzel-Perillo, Wieland, Wijkman, Wittbrodt, von Wogau, Xarchakos, Zabell, Záborská, Zacharakis, Zahradil, Zimmerling, Zissener]

PSE: Adam, Aguiriano Nalda, Andersson, Aparicio Sánchez, Attard-Montalto, Baltas, Barón Crespo, Bastys, Beňová, Berenguer Fuster, van den Berg, Berger, Bösch, Bullmann, Carlotti, Carnero González, Carraro, Carrilho, Casaca, Cashman, Cercas, Cerdeira Morterero, Ceyhun, Ciborowska, Ciemniak, Cilevičs, Corbett, Corbey, Cybulski, Czinege, Darras, De Keyser, De Rossa, Désir, Dhaene, Díez González, Drzęźla, Duhamel, Duin, Ekert, El Khadraoui, Ettl, Evans Robert J.E., Färm, Falbr, Fava, Fazakas, Ferreira, Fico, Fruteau, Gadzinowski, Garot, Gawłowski, Gebhardt, Ghilardotti, Gill, Gillig, Glante, Goebbels, Görlach, Grabowska, Gröner, Grzebisz-Nowicka, Gurmai, Guy-Quint, Hänsch, Haug, Hedkvist Petersen, Hegyi, Hoff, Honeyball, Horvat, Howitt, Hughes, van Hulten, Hume, Iivari, Ilves, Imbeni, Iwiński, Izquierdo Collado, Jaskiernia, Jöns, Karamanou, Karlsson, Katiforis, Keßler, Kindermann, Kinnock, Kósáné Kovács, Koukiadis, Kowalska, Krehl, Kreissl-Dörfler, Kriščiūnas, Kubica, Kuckelkorn, Kuhne, Lage, Lalumière, Lange, Laštůvka, Lavarra, Leinen, Liberadzki, Linkohr, Lisak, Litwiniec, McAvan, McCarthy, McNally, Malliori, Mann, Marinho, Martin David W., Martínez Martínez, Mastorakis, Medina Ortega, Mendiluce Pereiro, Menéndez del Valle, Miguélez Ramos, Miller, Miranda de Lage, Moraes, Müller, Myller, Napoletano, Napolitano, Obiols i Germà, O'Toole, Paasilinna, Paciotti, Pasternak, Patrie, Pęczak, Piecyk, Pieniążek, Pittella, Plokšto, Podgórski, Poignant, Poos, Prets, Pusz, Randzio-Plath, Rapkay, Read, Rocard, Roth-Behrendt, Rothe, Rothley, Rouček, Roure, Ruffolo, Sakellariou, Sandberg-Fries, dos Santos, Sauquillo Pérez del Arco, Savary, Scheele, Schmid Gerhard, Schulz, Simpson, Skinner, Smoleń, Soriano Gil, Souladakis, Stihler, Stockmann, Šulák, Swiebel, Swoboda, Szabó, Tabajdi, Terrón i Cusí, Theorin, Thorning-Schmidt, Titley, Torres Marques, Trentin, Vadai, Vairinhos, Valenciano Martínez-Orozco, Valys, Van Lancker, Vári, Vastagh, Vella, Vėsaitė, Volcic, Walter, Watts, Weiler, Wenderlich, Whitehead, Widuch, Wiersma, Wikiński, Winiarczyk-Kossakowska, Wynn, Żenkiewicz, Zorba, Zrihen

UEN: Andrews, Crowley, Hyland, Krasts, Queiró, Ribeiro e Castro

Verts/ALE: Aaltonen, Ahern, Auroi, Breyer, Buitenweg, Celli, Echerer, Evans Jillian, Frassoni, Graefe zu Baringdorf, Isler Béguin, Kāposts, Lagendijk, Lambert, Maes, Messner, Morera Català, Nogueira Román, Onesta, Ortuondo Larrea, de Roo, Rühle, Schroedter, Sörensen, Sokolovskis, Staes, Turmes, Voggenhuber, Wyn

Abstention: 63

ELDR: Lynne, Maldeikis

GUE/NGL: Brie, Chountis, Fiebiger, Konečná, Maštálka, Modrow, Ribeiro, Uca

NI: Garaud, Gorostiaga Atxalandabaso

PPE-DE: Atkins, Balfe, Beazley, Berg, Bobelis, Bowis, Bradbourn, Bushill-Matthews, Chichester, Corrie, Deva, Dover, Elles, Evans Jonathan, Foster, Harbour, Inglewood, Jackson, Khanbhai, Kirkhope, Konrad, Korhola, Laar, McMillan-Scott, Nisticò, Parish, Pastorelli, Perry, Podestà, Pospíšil, Provan, Purvis, Santini, Stevenson, Stockton, Sturdy, Tajani, Tannock, Twinn, Van Orden, Wojciechowski, Zappalà

PSE: Lund

UEN: Collins, Fitzsimons, Muscardini, Musumeci, Nobilia

Verts/ALE: Boumediene-Thiery, Rod, Wuori


Top