Table of contents

1.Introduction

1.1.Purpose and scope

2.Background to the intervention

2.1.Description of the intervention and its objectives

2.2.Baseline and points of comparison

3.Implementation / state of Play

3.1.Description of the current situation

3.2.How has the implementation and application of INSPIRE evolved from 2014 to 2020 and how it has affected different stakeholders?

3.3.To what extent have the recommendations from the 2016 INSPIRE REFIT evaluation been implemented?

3.3.1.Follow-Up on 2016 REFIT evaluation recommendations by the Commission

3.3.2.Follow-Up on 2016 REFIT evaluation recommendations by Member States

3.4.Compliance promotion and assurance

4.Method

4.1.Short description of methodology

4.2.Limitations and robustness of findings

4.3.Comparison of implementation results across the reporting years

4.4.Measuring impacts of the INSPIRE Directive

4.5.Quantification of costs and benefits

4.6.Representativeness of consultation results

4.7.Difficulty in distinguishing INSPIRE from other spatial data

5.Analysis and answers to the evaluation questions

5.1.Relevance

5.1.1.To what extent does INSPIRE still match current needs and do they continue to require action at EU level?

5.1.2.Is INSPIRE still relevant to the issues (obstacles) it addresses?

5.1.3.To what extent is INSPIRE future-proof?

5.1.4.Are the Articles 7 and 8 of the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive still relevant in view of the current state of the INSPIRE infrastructures?

5.2.Effectiveness

5.2.1.What progress has been made over time towards achieving the objectives and targets set out in INSPIRE in various Member States?

5.2.2.Is the progress made in line with the initial expectations and the INSPIRE implementation roadmap?

5.2.3.Is the geographical coverage of implementation consistent with the Directive's objectives?

5.2.4.To what extent does the implementation of the INSPIRE Directive in the Member States build further on the obligations of Public Access to Environmental Information Directive (specifically the provisions under Articles 7 and 8 under the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive)?

5.2.5.Which main factors have contributed to – respectively stood in the way of achieving these objectives?

5.2.6.To what extent is INSPIRE used for reporting under the environmental acquis?

5.2.7.What are the qualitative and quantitative effects of INSPIRE on the policymaking users in the field of environment in Member States?

5.2.8.What are the qualitative and quantitative effects of INSPIRE on users active in economic sectors influencing environment?

5.2.9.What are the effects of INSPIRE on small businesses using spatial data?

5.3.Efficiency

5.3.1.To what extent, and how has the intervention lead to improvements in the quality or efficiency of work of concerned stakeholders?

5.3.2.Can any specific provisions in INSPIRE be identified that make cost-efficient implementation more difficult?

5.3.3.Can the INSPIRE Directive and implementing rules be made more cost-efficient? What is the simplification potential?

5.3.4.Are results achieved so far commensurate with the resources put forward and in line with the ones expected from the ex-ante evaluation of INSPIRE?

5.3.5.How proportionate were the costs of the intervention for different stakeholder groups (enterprises including SMEs, citizens …)?

5.3.6.Have the resources needed to implement INSPIRE been available?

5.3.7.How has the use of INSPIRE for environmental reporting affected the reporting burden?

5.3.8.How would further streamlining of the provisions in Articles 7 and 8 of the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive with the active dissemination provisions of the INSPIRE Directive impact the administrative burden on the Member States.

5.4.Coherence

5.4.1.To what extent is INSPIRE coherent internally?

5.4.2.To what extent is INSPIRE coherent with environmental legislation with geospatial reporting obligations?

5.4.3.To what extent is INSPIRE coherent with other relevant areas of EU policy with geospatial reporting obligations (transport, agriculture, maritime, space, health, disaster management, research)?

5.4.4.To what extent is INSPIRE coherent with the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive and the objectives of the Common European Green Deal data space?

5.4.5.To what extent is INSPIRE coherent with Directive (EU) 2019/1024 on open data and the re-use of public sector information and what are the implications of Directive 2019/1024/EU?

5.5.EU Added Value

5.5.1.What is the EU-added value of INSPIRE in comparison to what could be achieved at Member States national and/or regional level activities?

5.5.2.To what extent do the issues addressed by INSPIRE continue to require action at EU level?

6.Conclusions

6.1.Conclusions in details

6.2.Relevance

6.3.Effectiveness

6.4.Efficiency

6.5.Coherence

6.6.EU added value

6.7.Lessons Learned

Glossary

Term or acronym

Meaning or definition

AAQD

Ambient Air Quality Directive

BRG

Better Regulation guidelines

CAP

Common Agricultural Policy

CKAN

Comprehensive Knowledge Archive Network

EAP

Environment Action Programme

EEA

European Environmental Agency

EFTA/EEA

European Free Trade Association/ European Economic Area

EGNOS

European Geostationary Navigation Overlay Service

EIA

Environmental Impact Assessment

EIS

Environmental Information Systems

EMODnet

European Marine Observation and Data Network

E-PRTR

European Pollutant Release and Transfer Register

GIS

Geographic Information System

GML

Geography Markup Language. The Geography Markup Language (GML) is the XML grammar defined by the Open Geospatial Consortium (OGC) to express geographical features. GML serves as a modeling language for geographic systems as well as an open interchange format for geographic transactions on the Internet.

GSAA

Geo-Spatial Aid Application

HELCOM

The Baltic Marine Environment Protection Commission (Helsinki Commission - HELCOM) is an intergovernmental organization governing the Convention on the Protection of the Marine Environment of the Baltic Sea Area (Helsinki Convention).

HILUCS

Land Use Classification System

IACS

European Union countries are responsible for the administration and control of payments to farmers in their country under a principle known as 'shared management'. The main building block of the management of payments system is the integrated administration and control system (IACS).

IED

Industrial Emissions Directive

INSPIRE Directive

Directive 2007/2/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 14 March 2007 establishing an Infrastructure for Spatial Information in the European Community (INSPIRE)

ISO

International Organisation for Standardisation

IR

Implementing Rules

ITS

Intelligent Transport Systems

JRC

Joint Research Centre

LPIS

Land Parcel Identification System

MIG

Maintenance and Implementation Group

MSFD

Marine Strategy Framework Directive

MSP

Maritime Spatial Planning

NCP

National Contact Point for the INSPIRE Directive

NSDI

National Spatial Data Infrastructure

OAI-PMH

Open Archives Initiative Protocol for Metadata Harvesting

OGC

Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC-CSW

Open Geospatial Consortium - Catalogue Service for the Web

POP

Persistent Organic Pollutant

PSI

Reuse of Public Sector Information Directive

REFIT

Regulatory Fitness and Performance Programme

SDI

Spatial Data Infrastructure

SEANSE

Strategic Environmental Assessment North Sea Energy

SEA

Strategic Environmental Assessment

SEIS

Shared Environmental Information System

TEN-T

Trans-European Transport Network

UWWT

Urban Waste Water Treatment Directive

WFD

Water Framework Directive

WMS

A Web Map Service (WMS) is a standard protocol developed by the Open Geospatial Consortium for serving georeferenced map images over the Internet.

WMTS

A Web Map Tile Service (WMTS) is a standard protocol for serving pre-rendered or run-time computed georeferenced map tiles over the Internet. The specification was developed and first published by the Open Geospatial Consortium.

1.Introduction

The present evaluation presents the results of the Commission’s evaluation of Directive 2007/2/EC on Infrastructure for Spatial Information in the European Community (hereinafter INSPIRE). It was included in the Commission Work Programme 2021 as part of the ‘GreenData4All’ initiative. The evaluation findings will be used in follow-up actions under the European Strategy for Data (COM (2020) 66 final) and as a digital enabler for the European Green Deal initiative (COM (2019) 640 final) including initiatives announced in the Commission Work programme for 2022.

1.1.Purpose and scope

The Commission is obliged to evaluate the INSPIRE Directive every five years (starting at the latest in 2022) pursuant to Article 23 of Regulation 2019/1010 1 on the alignment of reporting obligations in the field of legislation related to the environment that amended the INSPIRE Directive.

The evaluation has analysed the underlying mechanisms that have either contributed to or hindered the attainment of the initially defined objectives of the INSPIRE Directive (i.e. ‘the intervention’). The evaluation also builds on the mid-term evaluation published in 2016 2 and on studies prepared in 2019, in particular, the study on the promotion of good practices for national environmental information systems and tools for data harvesting at EU level, the 2019 Communication on Environmental Implementation Review and the study on Article 17 of the INSPIRE Directive on data- sharing. Furthermore, the evaluation gathered views from users to assess whether the appropriate data is available in a user-friendly format and in sufficient quantity to meet their needs.

The INSPIRE Directive obliges Member States to share existing geospatial data 3 to support European Union (EU) environmental policies and policies or activities which may have impact on the environment. INSPIRE should build on existing infrastructures for spatial information 4  already established and operated by the Member States. Within this infrastructure, existing information systems of different authorities are connected in order to share, find and use spatial data more easily while relying on common high quality data standards. As a result, data should be comparable and useable in a cross-border and cross-sector context allowing e.g. to avoid damage to the environment and human health. This approach to sharing of governmental data was extended through the EU's 2015 Digital Single Market strategy 5 . Building on similar principles, the EU's 2016 eGovernment Action Plan 6 identified the establishment of a European Spatial Data Infrastructure through the implementation of INSPIRE as an important action that would help modernise public administrations, connect services across borders and engage citizens through digital interactions with governments across the EU.

Directive 2003/4/EC on public access to environmental information Public Access to Environmental Information Directive) implements parts of the Aarhus Convention 7 relating to environmental information that authorities must make available to the public. The provisions in the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive date almost 20 years back. The rapid development in digital technologies and emergence of new data sources such as citizen science 8 and environmental sensors justify an evaluation of the data sharing and data access provisions embodied in Articles 7 and 8 of the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive. These provisions are therefore part of this evaluation’s scope.

These two legal instruments are the backbone of the environmental information management covering the whole of EU environmental policy. The instruments require Member States to provide public access to environmental information in an easily understandable, user-friendly manner. The framework facilitates public access to spatial information, with a view to involving members of the public further in decision-making.

Recently, the EU has embarked on a green and digital transition. The two dimensions are closely interrelated, and the Commission has taken the lead to drive these transitions and to focus investments on recovery and resilience in these areas. The 2019 European Green Deal 9 recognises the potential of digitalisation to achieve environment and climate aims and the necessity to explore sustainable digital technologies as essential enablers of the changes needed for a just green transition.

In February 2020, the Commission adopted its new digital strategy titled ‘Shaping Europe’s Digital Future’ 10 along with its first two pillars: the European Strategy for Data 11 and a White Paper on Artificial Intelligence 12 . The European Strategy for Data sets a vision for mutually supporting transitions to a healthy planet and a new digital world. The Strategy also recognises the necessity of data for the public good. Among other uses, the European Strategy for Data indicates that data can serve to address societal challenges, combat environmental emergencies and tackle environmental degradation and climate change. The European Strategy for Data specifically supports the Green Deal through the development of a common European Green Deal data space. The main legislative pillar for bringing data from public administrations into this Green Deal data space is the INSPIRE Directive together with the Directive on public access to environmental information. Both Directives respond to the need for better information and data that are more accessible to support policy development and better implementation. It is therefore important that they deliver as intended and keep pace with emerging technological developments. The European Strategy for Data has recognised the importance of this existing data sharing framework and has announced a ‘GreenData4All’ initiative that includes, as a starting point, the assessment of the interaction between INSPIRE Directive 2007/2/EC and Public Access to Environmental Information Directive. The overall objective of the ‘GreenData4all’ is to:

·modernise both the INSPIRE and the Public Access to Environmental Information Directives to align them with the contemporary state of technology;

·promote active dissemination and sharing of public- and private-held public data in support of the environmental acquis and the Green Deal objectives; and

·define and implement interoperable building blocks for sharing public data in the Green Deal data space and in alignment with the respective activities of the Destination Earth initiative, as a main contributing action in the context of the Green Deal Data Space.

This evaluation covers the implementation and application of the INSPIRE Directive and its implementing rules in all EU Member States and the EEA/EFTA countries 13 and has followed better regulation guidelines 14 . External consultants have in addition supported the assessment of the information collected 15 . The general public, representatives of public administrations and industry stakeholders have participated in this process.

For the effectiveness criterion, the present evaluation looks into how the INSPIRE Directive delivered on its objectives, in particular how it has contributed to different use-cases, such as sharing of data between Member State authorities, public access to spatially enabled environmental information (active dissemination) and regulatory reporting.

Under the efficiency criterion, the evaluation looks into cost-efficiency of the intervention and identified potential unnecessary administrative burden of the Directive and its Implementing Rules.

For assessment of coherence, the following policy areas, policy initiatives and legislative acts have been considered:

·the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive (in particular Articles 7 and 8 of the latter), how these provisions complement the INSPIRE Directive in terms of actively disseminating environmental information to the public;

·The European Green Deal;

·The European Strategy for Data;

·Directive 2019/1024/EC on open data (the ‘Open Data Directive’) and the re-use of public sector information, including the implementing act on High Value Datasets that is under preparation;

·EU environment legislation;

·EU laws that contain a reference to Inspire.

Under the relevance criterion, the evaluation also considered if the INSPIRE Directive and articles 7 and 8 of the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive are still sound in light of the current state of technology.

2.Background to the intervention

2.1.Description of the intervention and its objectives

Developing and implementing EU environment policy requires a solid scientific knowledge and evidence base on environmental pressures, state and impacts for a large number of areas, not only in air, water or nature but also in all economic sectors which have an impact on the environment.

Since 2002, the EU Sustainable Development Strategies 16 , 17  and the Environmental Action Programmes 18 addressed these issues and identified the need for better information to support the integrated 19 knowledge-base for environmental policies. The Commission came forward with a proposal for the INSPIRE Directive in 2004 20 focussing mainly on 'spatial data', i.e. information related to a location or area on Earth 21 . This issue has been also underlined in the European Green Deal.

Textbox 1 - What are spatial data?

What are spatial data and why do we need to share them across borders?

Spatial data are everywhere and we use them on a daily basis. Spatial data are data that are linked to a specific location, e.g. an address, the location of a building, a road, a river, an industrial or commercial facility, a monitoring station or a cadastral parcel. For thousands of years, we used maps or an atlas for this purpose. With digitalisation, it has become much easier to manage and use spatial data. Nowadays, we take it for granted to navigate using satellite navigation or to check the location of anything on the Internet using our electronic devices. The modern world needs increasingly up-to-date spatial data and the use of spatial date is constantly on the rise. We want to know where things are and what is happening there (e.g. the weather forecast or bathing water quality at our holiday destination).

Consider the example of the volcano eruption in Iceland in 2010. Immediately, data on air pollution and visibility were needed across Europe. This was urgent for services such as air traffic control but also for understanding the impacts the eruption was having on air quality and hence the health of citizens. The easier and quicker such data could be shared across borders, the better decisions could be taken.

The data infrastructure set by the INSPIRE Directive specifically serves these kind of situations and purposes. It applies in many other environmental issues which have a cross-border effect, be it flooding, pollution or the tracing of migratory birds 22 . In order to use such spatial data across administrative levels or borders, they need to be standardised and easy to use, view, search or download. The main challenge is when data are used across borders, standardisation is often missing. In the past, we could find different terms, definitions, attributes or scale levels and all of this in different languages. Drawing from this experience, INSPIRE ensures that spatial data can be accessed and compared across borders and also to use them for electronic services.

A wide range of environmental, geographical, social and economic spatial data exists and is being collected. Such location-based information is relevant for environmental policies, covering many thematic areas (water, air, biodiversity, waste, emissions, impact assessments, natural and technological hazards, public access to environmental information, etc.). Also in the context of policies having an impact on the environment (such as transport, agriculture, energy, land-use planning, regional development, etc.) spatial data is systematically collected. This is valuable in the context of environmental policy development and implementation. The INSPIRE Directive was designed to address the spatial data needs of thematic environmental policies by removing the four main categories of obstacles to the availability of such data:

1.A wide variety of organisational, cultural, institutional, financial and legal obstacles 23 hampered the sharing and re-use of spatial data by public authorities and public stakeholders;

2.Spatial data were difficult to find on the Internet and poorly documented; 

3.Many public authorities did not have online services in place allowing consultation and use of their spatial data; 

4.Spatial data was often organised in incompatible formats making it difficult to combine different spatial data sets in the absence of a common vocabulary.

The INSPIRE Directive does not require the collection of new data, or establish requirements on the scale or the quality of spatial data. The Directive promotes the sharing of existing spatial data relevant to environmental policies through the spatial data infrastructures that are operated by the Member States.

The intervention logic for the INSPIRE Directive is described in Annex 4, part B. It sets out the different measures of the Directive and how they were expected to interact. The intervention logic used in the evaluation in 2016 has been revised to provide a solid foundation illustrating the causal chains and the underlying assumptions that guide the current evaluation of the INSPIRE Directive and its implementation. The intervention logic is relevant at two levels: (a) to establish an overall understanding of the whole intervention (‘big picture view’ of the implementation of the INSPIRE Directive) and the interlinkages between the different provisions; (b) to establish an in-depth understanding of the causal pathways and assumptions for each type of activity.

The general objective 24  of the INSPIRE Directive remains the establishment of an EU-wide infrastructure for spatial information based on compatible Member States infrastructures and that is useable in a trans-boundary context within the EU for the purposes of EU environmental policies and policies or activities which may have an impact on the environment.

Textbox 2 - What is a spatial data infrastructure?

What is a European spatial data infrastructure (as promoted by the INSPIRE Directive)?

A European Spatial Data Infrastructure (ESDI) is about making it easier to find, use and share the available data from administrations and governments, in particular across border and throughout the whole of the European Union. The idea is to develop an approach which follows a number of common principles:

-    Data should be collected only once and kept where it can be maintained most effectively.

-    It should be possible to combine seamless spatial information from different sources across Europe and share it with many users and applications.

-    It should be possible for information collected at one level/scale to be shared with all levels/scales (from local to regional, to national to the EU level).

-    Geographic information needed for good governance at all levels should be readily and transparently available.

-    Available geographic information should be easy to find and it should be clear how it can be used to meet a particular need, and under which conditions it can be acquired and used.

INSPIRE has translated these principles into legislation. Building on already existing national Spatial Data Infrastructures in the Member States, it sets the foundation for the creation of a European Spatial Data Infrastructure for the European Union. It establishes requirements for the governance of the organisational (coordination amongst public administrations, identification of spatial data) and technical components (quality of data, metadata, interoperable services supporting view, search and download) of the Spatial Data Infrastructure. These requirements enable the sharing of environmental spatial information among public sector organisations and better facilitate public access to spatial information across Europe.

The development of such a European spatial data infrastructure should create, amongst other benefits, the reduction of administrative burdens and the creation of new business opportunities. Businesses are now using such administrative data to provide better services to the public (such as combining predictions on weather and air quality or integrating real-time traffic information in business processes such as providing information about road construction sites through satellite navigations) 25 . The insurance sector is increasingly using geographical data to improve profitability by improving their understanding of risks at locations and verifying the content of claims. Moreover, real estate companies are increasingly factoring in environmental information, e.g. when determining house prices (e.g. whether they are situated in a flood risk area) 26 and utility network operators are leveraging spatial data to avoid excavation damage 27 . 

Therefore, INSPIRE sets a coherent legal framework for:

·Sharing spatial data across the EU;

·Coordination structures on spatial information at Member States and EU level;

·Identification of spatial data needed 28 ;

·Documentation of identified spatial data through metadata 29 ;

·Ensuring that the documented spatial data is accessible online through data services allowing its discovery, view and download and, where needed transformation;

·Organising the documented spatial data in interoperable data models with a common vocabulary and online accessible through the IT services;

·Allow data access and reuse over administrative and national borders through data sharing.

This framework is implemented through 14 'actions' as explained below. These actions are the specific provisions of the INSPIRE Directive imposing obligations mainly on Member States but also on EU institutions. Those actions should be implemented according to an agreed timetable, in several ‘steps’ as laid down in the INSPIRE Directive and its implementing rules 30 . Overall, the actions can be grouped into five distinctive steps (see also Figure 1, a more detailed overview is provided in Annex 4, Part A):

·Step 1 concerns transposition, the establishment of coordination structures and a data policy.

·Steps 2-5 relate to a sequential set of actions all related to ‘spatial data’. They have to be identified (step 2) and documented (step 3). Thereafter, online services (step 4) have to be established and finally the spatial data should be transformed (step 5) in accordance with agreed data models in order to facilitate the re-use of the data.

At the time of this evaluation, most of the obligations under the five steps had to be completed 31 .

Figure 1: INSPIRE Implementation major milestones and outputs

Who will benefit from the Directive’s implementation?

Two different sorts of benefits are identified: (a) benefits in terms of cost savings i.e. efficiency gains, enabling existing needs to be met more cheaply (these benefits accrue to both data producers and data users); and (b) benefits in terms of the ability of users to access and to use data in new and innovative ways increasing productive potential or improving the efficiency and effectiveness of policy responses.

The INSPIRE Directive will ensure overall coherence and ease of use of the spatial data underpinning the information made available to citizens. The resulting better information to the public will lead to increased confidence in the accuracy and relevance of public sector information, leading to more engagement in the democratic process of environmental protection and, eventually, in other areas of government action. The INSPIRE Directive will also enable public sector information to be exploited by the private sector, thereby stimulating the creation of added value services useful to the public. INSPIRE will furthermore allow the private sector to publish their data along with the public sector data, provide to public and private organisations a wider choice of data to underpin their activities.

National authorities and data providers will be beneficiaries in terms of gains in efficiency and in terms of the potential for improvements in policy performance. They will however also have to attribute the necessary resources for the implementation if the INSPIRE Directive. Whether authorities or providers are net contributors or beneficiaries will depend on a number of factors, e.g. the extent to which the organisation is both user and producer, the degree of standardisation already achieved etc.

Citizens, private sector data users, research institutes are mainly beneficiaries of the INSPIRE Directive. The benefits for these organisations arise from having (potential) access to existing data. Private sector data users and research institutes will reduce their search costs and reduce costs of data collection.

The European Commission, international bodies and academic institutions are possible beneficiaries since INSPIRE will reduce the costs of analysing pan-European information for policy making and policy implementation purposes.

2.2.Baseline and points of comparison

The state-of-play summary report 32 of December 2007 was used to establish a baseline for the status of national spatial data infrastructures as it reflects the situation at the time of entry into force of the Directive.

In 2014, the Commission presented a report on the implementation of INSPIRE to the European Parliament and to the Council 33 assessing whether the INSPIRE Directive was still fit-for-purpose at the half way mark of its implementation. The midterm evaluation, that looked at the progress made between 2007 and 2014 including the transposition of the Directive into national law. It showed that many of the barriers identified in the original Impact Assessment 34 were still relevant. Despite the progress made by some Member States, the implementation gaps in most Member States were significant and underlined the differences in speed and quality of implementation. The findings in relation to the different implementation steps were summed up as follows: 

·All Member States had coordination structures in place, but their effectiveness was variable;

·National data policies for sharing data were highly variable and heterogeneous;

·Progress was made as regards the spatial datasets identified and reported. However, for many Member States, the numbers remained low (less than 150) and with limited thematic coverage;

·Implementation of the documentation obligations was advanced, yet only 12 Member States had documented 80 to 100 % of their reported spatial data in line with the INSPIRE Directive by 2014;

·Member States made progress on the online discovery services available for their identified and documented datasets. These services give users access to the documentation. The overall availability of digital services for viewing and downloading spatial data for further use was less advanced;

·The interoperability of the spatial datasets had not advanced much mainly because the main implementation deadlines were still in the future (2017, 2020).

The 2014 evaluation marks an interim implementation milestone. The end date for the period covered by the evaluation is January 2021. This evaluation assesses the further implementation progress between 2014 and 2021 building on the evidence gathered for the midterm evaluation and provides an understanding on how the situation during this period has changed, also compared to the situation prevalent at the time of the adoption of the Directive in 2007. Such consideration allows to evaluate progress against the initial objectives set for the intervention and to conclude whether and to what extent it has still been relevant over the last seven years (2014-2021).

The baseline for quantitative and qualitative indicators to measure and compare progress is based on the monitoring and reporting provisions in the INSPIRE Directive that require Member States to monitor and report on the implementation status on an annual basis. Until 2018, Commission Decision 2009/442/EC 35 regulated monitoring and reporting. In 2019, this Decision was repealed and replaced by Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2019/1372 36 , which introduced the automated calculation of 19 new indicators through the direct use of the INSPIRE Geoportal and the INSPIRE Reference Validator 37 to process the metadata harvested from Member States discovery services. 38 These indicators are grouped into five categories: availability of spatial data and services, conformity of metadata, conformity of spatial data sets, accessibility of spatial data sets through view and download services, and conformity of network services. Most indicators are calculated as a percentage, thus providing a direct measure of performance and allowing country-by-country comparisons. The scoring methodology for monitoring indicators used for this evaluation is mimicking the JRC Summary Report on Status of implementation of the INSPIRE Directive in EU (the 2016 country fiches) 39 . 

3.Implementation / state of Play

3.1.Description of the current situation 

This section describes the implementation status of the INSPIRE Directive in each of the 27 Member States 40 and the 4 EEA/EFTA countries at the beginning of 2021, including a reflection to which extent the 2016 INSPIRE midterm evaluation recommendations have been followed up and implemented. 

The simplified intervention logic described in  Figure 1 is the basis for the evaluation. A detailed intervention logic is provided in Annex 1, Part B. Before assessing these elements, the status of implementation in relation to the actions which were already required by end 2020 is described on the basis of country summary reports, yearly monitoring data, country fiches 41 and data and services available in the EU geoportal 42 .

3.2.How has the implementation and application of INSPIRE evolved from 2014 to 2020 and how it has affected different stakeholders?

All Member States have installed a coordination structure and governance for their INSPIRE implementation. Since 2014 we see a continuous positive trend in ensuring an effective coordination of the implementation of the INSPIRE Directive in the Member States. This is mainly demonstrated by a more comprehensive and complete representation of public administrations responsible for maintaining and publishing spatial data in scope of the INSPIRE Directive (national mapping agencies, cadastres, environmental administrations, statistical administrations, …). The coordination structure reflects the administrative culture and the constitutional setup of the Member State (federated vs centralized, involvement of local authorities). In some cases, the INSPIRE Directive implementation was initially setup purely from a national mapping and cadastral agencies (NMCA) perspective, resulting in a strong focus on Annex I and II data sets following the implementation roadmap timeline and showing gaps on the availability of Annex III data sets and the coordination with the environmental domain. Awareness has been raised and most Member States have started to remediate this deficiency.

The documentation of spatial data sets and services through metadata has proven to raise the awareness about the availability of spatial data in the public administration and as such has improved spatial data sharing and use. Usage of discovery services is limited mostly to professional users thus making spatial data and services not discoverable for wider user community. In Member States where the service offering is limited or of low quality, usage of the infrastructure tends to be limited. In some Member States, the Open Data Directive is higher on the political agenda and more importance is given to making data available as open data. This does not necessarily conflict with the ambitions of the INSPIRE Directive. On the contrary, in information-mature Member States where Open Data and INSPIRE ambitions are implemented in a complementary way the use of spatial data and the INSPIRE infrastructure is prevalent. In Member States where the only driver for the implementation of the INSPIRE Directive is its legal obligation and where no use cases are being developed or where INSPIRE implementation is done in isolation, the use of the infrastructure is limited.

There is a growing demand for uniform European information products within the INSPIRE infrastructure that can support and facilitate EU-level use cases. It is expected that these products will also gradually enhance the use of the infrastructure. Following the midterm evaluation recommendations, the Commission has selected monitoring and reporting under the environmental acquis as a priority use case for the development of a first set of pan-European information products. Based on the evaluation of reporting obligations under the environmental legislation a priority list of eReporting data sets 43 related to environmental reporting obligations was prepared by the Commission in collaboration with the Commission expert group working on the maintenance and implementation of INSPIRE (MIG). This list of datasets is a rolling list that will be further extended in view of tangible information needs to adequately evaluate the effects on the environment of EU environmental legislation and its effectiveness, efficiency and coherence with other pieces of EU legislation.

Data policies that ensure effective data sharing without obstacles remain a point of attention in at least five Member States. Member States strongly advocate the benefits of the Directive but quantification of direct costs and benefits remains difficult.

The monitoring data and country fiches over the years show that, overall, there has been a partial implementation of the INSPIRE Directive across Europe. Fewer data sets were available in 2020 than in the previous years. In some cases, this is a result of the data cleaning processes at national level, aggregating local and regional datasets and deleting irrelevant data sets for users and/or duplicates of data sets. Another reason for removing data sets may also be that Member States consider this data cleaning process as an opportunity to improve their overall monitoring indicators by removing those data sets that do not pass compliance testing.

The INSPIRE monitoring indicators 44 show that the status of the implementation is heterogeneous, with at least twelve countries lagging behind. It is important to consider that the new reporting and monitoring method introduced by Commission Decision (EU) 2019/1372 caused considerable breaks in the trend, lowering the values of INSPIRE indicators in the reference years 2019 and 2020. The new automated approach based on the processing of all metadata harvested from countries' discovery services entails a stricter and more reliable validation method than previous self-declared country assessments. Measured against the INSPIRE roadmap, the monitoring results in 2020 for the 27 EU Member States and 4 EFTA/ EEA countries are in general below expectations.

A snapshot 45 of the current implementation status for 27 Member States and the four EFTA/ EEA countries combined is provided in the table below. The overview is based on the regulatory reporting and monitoring obligations stipulated in Article 21 of the INSPIRE Directive and the INSPIRE monitoring indicators introduced by the Commission Decision in 2019 46 .

Envisaged outputs according the intervention logic

Coordination structures on spatial information at Member States

Measures of data sharing are that allow data access and reuse over administrative and national borders.Measures of data sharing are that allow data access and reuse over administrative and national borders.

Average performance

Effective coordination

Data sharing arrangements and usage of the infrastructure

Identification of spatial data needed

Total amount

DSi1.1: The number of spatial data sets for which metadata exist

83,805

DSi1.2: The number of spatial data services for which metadata exist

95,381

DSi1.3: The number of spatial data sets for which the metadata contains one or more keywords from a register provided by the Commission indicating that the spatial data set is used for reporting under the environmental legislation

2,068

DSi1.4: The number of spatial data sets for which the metadata contains a keyword from a register provided by the Commission indicating that the spatial data set covers regional territory

12,917

DSi1.5: The number of spatial data sets for which the metadata contains a keyword from a register provided by the Commission indicating that the spatial data set covers the national territory

4,456

Documentation of identified spatial data through metadata

Average performance

MDi1.1: Percentage of metadata for spatial data sets conformant with Commission Regulation (EC) No 1205/2008 as regards metadata

59%

MDi1.2: Percentage of metadata for spatial data services conformant with Commission Regulation (EC) No 1205/2008 as regards metadata

55%

Organise the documented spatial data in interoperable data models with a common vocabulary and online accessible through the IT services.

Average performance

DSi2: Percentage of spatial data sets that are in conformity with Commission Regulation (EU) No 1089/2010 as regards interoperability of spatial data sets

50%

DSi2.1: Percentage of spatial data sets, corresponding to the themes listed in Annex I, that are in conformity with Commission Regulation (EU) No 1089/2010 as regards interoperability of spatial data sets

65%

DSi2.2: Percentage of spatial data sets, corresponding to the themes listed in Annex II, that are in conformity with Commission Regulation (EU) No 1089/2010 as regards interoperability of spatial data sets

52%

DSi2.3: Percentage of spatial data sets, corresponding to the themes listed in Annex III, that are in conformity with Commission Regulation (EU) No 1089/2010 as regards interoperability of spatial data sets

50%

NSi2: The percentage of spatial data sets that are accessible through view and download services

42%

NSi2.1: The percentage of spatial data sets that are accessible through view services

50%

NSi2.2: The percentage of spatial data sets that are accessible through download services

50%

Ensure that the documented spatial data is accessible online through data services allowing its discovery, view and download and, where needed transformation.

Average performance

NSi4: The percentage of the network services that are in conformity with Commission Regulation (EC) No 976/2009 as regards the network services

63%

NSi4.1: The percentage of the discovery services that are in conformity with Commission Regulation (EC) No 976/2009 as regards the network services

65%

NSi4.2: The percentage of the view services that are in conformity with Commission Regulation (EC) No 976/2009 as regards the network services

65%

NSi4.3: The percentage of the download services that are in conformity with Commission Regulation (EC) No 976/2009 as regards the network services

62%

NSi4.4: The percentage of the transformation services that are in conformity with Commission Regulation (EC) No 976/2009 as regards the network services

25%

 

A direct comparison of the country monitoring indicators across different years is not possible due to the legislative and technical changes in 2019 that included a partial redefinition of the monitoring indicators and promoted automated calculation of the monitoring indicators to minimise the reporting burden on the countries. It is important to note that the scoring must be therefore interpreted in the way that progress trends cannot be established based solely on these summarized results and without detailed understanding of the national contexts.

3.3.To what extent have the recommendations from the 2016 INSPIRE REFIT evaluation been implemented?

The midterm evaluation refers to the situation of implementation in 2013-14. It found that INSPIRE was largely fit-for-purpose, but that further efforts are needed at EU and Member State level to close the remaining implementation gaps and to harvest the full benefits of the Directive. Moreover, specific issues needing attention concern the data policy provisions in the Directive (Article 17) and requirements and use of some of the technical specifications in the implementing rules (including the streamlining of reporting). Consequently, the Commission had issued a number of recommendations and actions, which are now being implemented in close collaboration with the Member States as part of an updated Maintenance and Implementation Work Programme 2016-2020 47 .

The Member States increased the overall availability of environmental priority data sets according to one of the recommendations in the midterm evaluation. In terms of coordination between the national INSPIRE implementation and eGovernment, open data and other relevant processes at national level, there are limited linkages in terms of logistical work and cooperation. Nevertheless, it is mostly considered that these initiatives are coherent with the INSPIRE Directive, and that in some cases, the national data policies benefit from its implementation by facilitating an environment of free and open data.

The gathered evidence further shows that most of the recommendations addressed to the European Commission have been implemented through several initiatives and actions summarized in the MIG Work Programme 2016-2020. Initiatives include the evaluation study on data sharing between public authorities and public access and use provisions; proposal for a regulation streamlining reporting obligations in the field of environmental policy; new monitoring and reporting decision; list of common datasets related to environmental reporting obligations; technical cooperation and coordination.

3.3.1.Follow-Up on 2016 REFIT evaluation recommendations by the Commission

First recommendation: Evaluate the shortcomings of the national data policies in relation to Article 17 of the Directive in more detail.

The Commission assessed the maturity of data sharing between public authorities in 2019 and found that implementation was on-going and that further harmonisation of data policies and licenses for data reuse in the Member States was necessary. Other remaining obstacles limiting data sharing were the availability of the data, broken links and missing services to provide access to the data. This can be improved by further promoting the use of INSPIRE data in practice and demonstrating their benefit.

The environmental e-Reporting use case and the list of priority data for e-reporting are considered good practices to stimulate implementation. Benefits can also be expected from further aligning Article 17 on data sharing of the INSPIRE Directive with the reviewed Directive on Open Data and on the re-use of public sector information. Moreover, the selected data categories in the foreseen implementing act on High Value Datasets 48 have a clear overlap with the data scope of the INSPIRE Directive and could benefit from reusing already available spatial data in the INSPIRE infrastructure.

Second recommendation: Review, and possibly revise, the INSPIRE rules, in particular on spatial data harmonisation, to take into account the implementing risks and complexities with a view to reducing them (simplifying requirements).

Experience from the midterm evaluation and the Fitness Check on reporting and monitoring have shown the need to simplify and streamline monitoring and reporting, support better comparison of the progress in the implementation across Member States and allow for national and EU-wide overviews while reducing administrative monitoring and reporting burden. Monitoring and reporting have been aligned and streamlined by simplifying the legal provisions and amending the related Implementing Decision to make it more meaningful and effective.

The Regulation on alignment of reporting obligations in the field of environment policy 49  entered into force on 26 June 2019. The proposal for a review of the reporting Decision 50 was adopted by the INSPIRE Committee on 27 November 2018 and published on 19 August 2019. Reporting under the new regime took effect from 15 December 2019 and the JRC has developed a reporting tool, which makes the whole monitoring and reporting process much more effective and efficient.

Furthermore, the Commission has gathered evidence in 2017-2018 on possible issues/improvements to the INSPIRE framework. The findings have been discussed with Member States’ experts, which will be reflected in the review of the interoperability regulation 51 . This will make the application of the data specifications easier and less burdensome without losing the benefits of standardisation and interoperability. The intention is to adopt the revised Regulation in 2022.

Third recommendation: Assist the Member States in applying and implementing the INSPIRE Directive (simplification of use), e.g. by the use of common tools, and promote priority setting together with the Member States.

The Commission has selected monitoring and reporting under the environmental acquis as a priority use case for the development of a first set of pan-European information products. Based on the evaluation of reporting obligations under the environmental legislation, a preliminary list of common datasets related to environmental reporting obligations was prepared 52 and the number of environmental priority datasets in the INSPIRE catalogue made accessible by Member States is gradually increasing 53 . 

Fourth recommendation: Work closely with Member States to explore opportunities arising from the use of existing EU-level funding programmes to help capacity building and close the INSPIRE implementation gaps (e.g. through the Interoperability Solutions Administrations).

The Commission has informed the Member States about funding opportunities.

3.3.2.Follow-Up on 2016 REFIT evaluation recommendations by Member States

Member States should step up their efforts in implementing (e.g. on their coordination activities) and critically reviewing the effectiveness of their data policies. This applies in particular to those Member States lagging most behind if they are to meet future implementation deadlines. In addition, Member States, in consultation with the Commission, are recommended to:

·give priority to environmental spatial datasets, in particular those linked to monitoring and reporting, and those identified in relevant global processes;

·improve coordination between the national INSPIRE implementation and eGovernment, open data and other relevant processes at national level.

The (quantified and qualified) progress made by the Member States vis-à-vis the follow-up actions identified in the midterm evaluation is documented in country fiches 54 and a comparative EU overview fiche 55 .

Moreover, the reengineered INSPIRE Geoportal 56 , that was released in September 2018, provides an online dashboard that allows for assessing the actual state of implementation in the Member States.

The actions put forward in the Maintenance and Implementation Work Programme for 2017-2020 and continued under the new Maintenance and Implementation Work Programme (WP) for 2021-2024 are continuously monitored and several of them have been completed. 57 The new programme has three main area of work: 1) digital ecosystem for the environment and sustainability, 2) Towards a common implementation landing zone, 3) GreenData4All.

3.4.Compliance promotion and assurance 

EU pilot letters were sent to five Member States who failed to connect their discovery services to the INSPIRE Geoportal and bilateral technical implementation meetings (20) or written exchanges (2) with the Member States were held during the period September 2015 - April 2016. As a follow-up, Member States were invited to draw up an action plan for improving the implementation of the INSPIRE Directive in conjunction with the next national tri-annual report, which was due on 15 May 2016. The bilateral meetings proved very effective and were appreciated by the Commission services and the Member States. Most Member States critically reviewed their INSPIRE implementation and provided an action plan in 2016 for the period 2016-2020 to remedy existing implementation issues and further improve the overall conformity of the implementation. This resulted in a further increase of transparency of environmental information, also improving the implementation of the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive, in terms of improving public access to environmental information and the quality of the data. The action plans showed a common understanding and awareness of remaining implementation challenges and demonstrated the goodwill of Member States to address these. In addition, the Commission launched a two-yearly review of implementation of EU law with the Environmental Implementation Review (EIR) 58 . The EIR country reports on Member States implementation status included in section V on "Effective governance and knowledge" the evaluation of the INSPIRE evidence-base available to the Commission also building on the bilateral meetings and the INSPIRE country reports. The EIR reports also assessed the status of Member States’ data policies and related practices on sharing information, as supported by both the INSPIRE and the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive.

In order to establish a pragmatic way of dealing with INSPIRE implementation, it was agreed with the Member States to give higher importance to selected environmental reporting data to ensure better usability, comparability and access. An initial priority list of data sets was prepared to serve environmental reporting needs covering a number of areas such as water, waste, air, nature, etc.

In the period December 2017 - January 2018, the five bad application EU Pilots’ procedures were closed and Member States were requested to prioritise the publication and accessibility of priority data sets for reporting.

Those Member States which did not engage in this exercise were found in breach of the INSPIRE Directive and after several reminders, a first wave of infringements (against Bulgaria, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland) was initiated with a letter of formal notice on 8 March 2019.

4.Method

4.1.Short description of methodology

The evaluation was carried out in line with the Better Regulation Guidelines 59 and the assessment was guided by a set of 30 evaluation questions (see Annex 3) 60 , which have been operationalised in an evaluation questions matrix. This formed the basis for the data collection activities and analytical work. The evaluation questions were structured around the current implementation status of the INSPIRE Directive and the five evaluation criteria.

Country forms were prepared based on the desk review of country summary reports, yearly monitoring data and other relevant materials. Country forms, developed for 27 Member States and 4 EEA/EFTA countries, were shared with the respective National Contact Points (NCPs) before being finalised.

The development of country forms to assess the current implementation status was tightly intertwined with a broader review and analysis of relevant available information and evidence in a desk study. In this desk study, quantitative and qualitative data from reports, scientific articles, evaluations and other data sources on the implementation of the INSPIRE Directive were collected and reviewed. Furthermore, as part of the stakeholder consultations several data collection activities were conducted to complete the evidence, including scoping interviews and Focus Group interviews with various Member States authorities and stakeholders. On 19 April 2021, the public consultation was launched for the duration of 12 weeks and four targeted surveys were launched at the end of April targeting the environmental, agricultural, marine and spatial data sectors.

Each of the five evaluation criteria was analysed in relation to specific elements of INSPIRE Directive following the causal pathways in the updated intervention logic (see Annex 4, Part B). The evaluation matrix linked the evaluation questions to indicators/success criteria and used information sources. The evaluation framework was critical in guiding the data collection and the subsequent use of data for the analysis. It ensured that all aspects of the evaluation questions were answered in a systematic and traceable manner.

The main analytical method used for most questions was content analysis, based on the aggregation and analysis of information collected with the literature review, desk study, targeted questionnaires, interviews, public consultation and validation workshop. Data were analysed according to the principles of triangulation of evidence 61 from different perspectives (stakeholder categories) and different sources. Finally, focus was placed on assessing the reliability of information used.

4.2.Limitations and robustness of findings

Although the analysis encompassed a wide range of data, information and views of stakeholders and Member States, some methodological limitations remained. For each evaluation criterion it was assessed what the key limitations are and what a proposed mitigation measure could be, e.g. using alternative sources or types of data. The main limitations and gaps identified during this evaluation are described in the following paragraphs.

4.3.Comparison of implementation results across the reporting years 

There is a significant shift in the trend observed, between the year 2018 and 2019, due to the change of the INSPIRE monitoring and reporting process following the adoption of a new reporting Decision 62 in 2019. Since 2019, the process has been managed by the JRC and is fully automated using the INSPIRE Geoportal and the INSPIRE Reference Validator software tools to process the metadata harvested from the Member States' discovery services. The new automated approach based on the processing of all metadata harvested from countries' discovery services entails a stricter and more reliable validation method than previous self-declared country assessments. As a result of this change in data, the implementation results cannot be directly compared across the reporting years. In order to mitigate this limitation, the Member States and the four EFTA/EEA countries were given the opportunity to provide additional explanations in the country forms regarding their internal challenges and other reasons for the drop in their performance over the years. These explanations have been taken into consideration in the assessment of the implementation progress.

4.4.Measuring impacts of the INSPIRE Directive 

It is difficult to measure the impacts, as users of spatial information data in different applications based on INSPIRE are not always aware where the data comes from. Users often do not know whether data they use/would like to use result from the implementation of INSPIRE or from something else (e.g. national legislation). One such example is the application making publicly accessible real time air quality data. Because of this challenge, it is sometimes difficult to trace a real driver for many important initiatives such e-Government and national open data strategies. For this reason, this evaluation aims to provide a transparent overview of where data comes from and how it is interpreted by different stakeholders. In addition, the evaluation conclusions are carefully drawn, acknowledging the limitations of results of different collection tools.

4.5.Quantification of costs and benefits 

In the efficiency analysis, the main data gaps relate to assessment of costs and benefits in quantitative terms. Due to the limited data in this regard (from the country fiches), there are challenges related to the cost and benefit assessment as well as with the comparability of data across the Member States. As there are also several objectives, such as data sharing between administrations and making information available to the public, it is not possible to precisely define the quantitative benefits of making information available to the public. This is for several reasons, for example, it is difficult to quantify what is the value of information actively disseminated to the public, in terms of facilitating informed decision-making, how this might impact the health of citizens, etc.

In addition, national data providers often do not have a separate budget line for the implementation of the INSPIRE Directive. Further, available estimates and estimates provided by stakeholders are not comparable, e.g. they may include different cost items, they may not rest on the same methodologies and often, INSPIRE costs have not been clearly separated from other costs. For example, costs of developing national SDIs are often included in the estimates. In order to mitigate this, available studies on cost and benefits have been collected and used as well as dedicated cost-benefit analysis. In addition, qualitative data has been collected through the interviews, targeted surveys and public consultation.

4.6.Representativeness of consultation results 

Reaching a representative number of respondents in each targeted survey and each stakeholder group and a balance between Member States proved difficult. In particular, the targeted surveys of the marine and agriculture communities experienced low response rates, and results from the targeted survey of the environmental community did not provide a very comprehensive picture across the EU on how INSPIRE is used for environmental reporting (see also Annex 4 of the supporting Study). The Focus Group interviews with Member States generally provided a satisfactory range of stakeholders involved in the implementation of the INSPIRE Directive at national level. However, in several Focus Groups, environmental stakeholders (institutions responsible for sectoral environmental policies and therefore sectoral environmental datasets) were not represented, also because these organisations play a limited role in the governance structure in some Member States. As a result, some information was gathered on the relations between INSPIRE and environmental reporting, on the use of INSPIRE for environmental policy-making and the coherence of INSPIRE with the implementation of the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive. The Focus Groups was also given the opportunity to provide written answers.

4.7.Difficulty in distinguishing INSPIRE from other spatial data 

During Focus Group interviews, it became apparent that some stakeholders make the distinction between INSPIRE datasets and the data included in the overall national SDI. Some Member States have developed two different spatial data infrastructures: one for national use and one for the implementation of the INSPIRE Directive. As a result, it is difficult to assess the effects of the INSPIRE Directive, especially when it comes to costs and benefits. Therefore, this evaluation considers the statements provided during the Focus Group in a transparent and objective manner allowing for clear conclusions whether they concern INSPIRE datasets only or a wider set of national spatial data.

5.Analysis and answers to the evaluation questions 

This chapter replies to the evaluation questions and sets out the supporting arguments to underpin the findings based on information and assessment carried out in the context of the supporting study (in particular, chapters 5 and 6).

5.1.Relevance

5.1.1.To what extent does INSPIRE still match current needs and do they continue to require action at EU level?

From a policy perspective, the relevance of the INSPIRE Directive’s objectives in view of the twin challenge of a green and digital transformation has even increased. The INSPIRE Directive together with the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive has been identified as the main pillar for bringing data from public administrations into the Green Deal data space. This ambition has been articulated in the Commission Communication ’A European strategy for data’ 63 under the ‘GreenData4All’ initiative.

The European Strategy for Data indicates, amongst other uses, that data can serve to address societal challenges, combat environmental emergencies and tackle environmental degradation and climate change. To do so, the European Strategy for Data specifically supports the Green Deal ambitions through the development of a common European Green Deal data space 64 .

The evaluation demonstrates that the national and public authorities have a need for spatial data for the different phases of their policymaking (design of policy, monitoring of policy, reporting and assessment of results and effects) and put great emphasis to sharing this spatial data with the public. This spatial data need remains the main challenge and justifies EU action. The INSPIRE Directive addresses these needs. For other actors (companies, NGOs, researchers, citizens), limited information has been gathered on their actual information needs.

Table 1  gives an indication of the availability of spatial data using the existing national portals for spatial data in the Member States as a proxy. Twenty-one Member States have more than one geoportal. Most of these portals are in national languages and do not indicate whether these are making use of INPIRE conformant datasets. For most of these geoportals there is limited data gathered of concrete use (either number and type of users and frequency of use or use-case). Member States that offer data, services and targeted end-user applications through their geoportal(s) and do gather metrics on the usage show positive effects of making spatial (not necessarily INSPIRE) data available e.g. for Luxembourg it is explicitly mentioned that ‘independently of the special geoportal dedicated to INSPIRE, the national geoportal of Luxembourg has been a great success and is widely used by the general public. It counts more than 50,000 visitors per day, through its different viewers, web services and APIs’. Indeed, the INSPIRE portal is an independent subsection of the Luxembourgish SDI and only offers a subset of the rich spatial data offering in the national geoportal.

Table 1 Examples of spatial data portals provided by Member States

 Member State

Number of examples of geoportals

 Member State

Number of examples of geoportals

Latvia

10

Slovakia

5

Sweden

9

Italy

4

Croatia

8

Netherlands

4

Cyprus

8

Slovenia

4

Finland

7

Spain

4

Belgium

7

France

3

Greece

7

Hungary

3

Austria

6

Ireland

2

Bulgaria

6

Portugal

1

Denmark

6

Estonia

1

Czechia

5

Lithuania

1

Germany

5

Luxembourg

1

Romania

5

Malta

1

Source: Current status country forms for 27 Member States.

Furthermore, several examples are provided in the current status country forms of Member States where INSPIRE has been instrumental in developing access and use of the spatial data e.g. Latvia, Belgium and Portugal.

5.1.2. Is INSPIRE still relevant to the issues (obstacles) it addresses?

The main finding indicates that many of the obstacles considered when the Directive entered into force persist and that further action is required at the EU level to address these obstacles. There has also been evolution of technology and information requirements which point to a need for improvement of the INSPIRE Directive.

The 2004 Impact Assessment 65 identified several obstacles justifying an EU action:

·difficulties of access to information (insufficient metadata at all levels);

·different projections and scales, making existing information difficult to integrate;

·unclear status of the information as to its currency;

·prohibitive cost of geographical data;

·lack of interoperability between data sets, and among web-enabled services;

·lack of harmonisation in the codes used to represent the objects described;

·varying data quality from one country to another within the same layer of geographical information;

·lack of long-term solutions (instead: supply of snapshots, absence of information on changes), resulting in information that became quickly outdated and hence the need for duplication of data collection efforts.

Under the state of implementation section above (See 3.1, 3.2) and the analysis of effectiveness (See 5.2.1, 5.2.2) the evaluation showed that the Directive has not permitted to fully overcome all of these obstacles which therefore remain (at least partially) valid. The midterm evaluation also identified this and reiterated the relevance of the Directive to address the still persisting obstacles by issuing recommendations. These recommendations have not been fully implemented by the Member States (See 3.2.2).

The relevance was also confirmed by the public consultation 66  as respondents overall consider that action is required at the EU level to address obstacles and needs related to sharing and disseminating spatial data as addressed by the INSPIRE Directive. So in short, there remains wide support to overcome the obstacles to data access, however the Directive needs to take into account evolution in technology and information management to be more fit for purpose to deliver on its objectives.

5.1.3.To what extent is INSPIRE future-proof?

The evaluation identified some of the technical specifications for the INSPIRE framework as a barrier to current and future implementation as well as use. The legal framework is considered too prescriptive and rigid to respond to fast evolving technology and information needs with the necessary agility.

The implementing rules (on metadata, network services and interoperability) and associated technical guidelines have been developed to support the development of interoperable data sets and services under the scope of the INSPIRE framework, which have been considered by stakeholders as useful and essential for high quality data management.

However, one of the main barriers to implementation identified by Member States (see 5.2.5) relates to the complexity of implementing INSPIRE in the light of various technical issues. The technical over-specification of the Directive was identified as a burden for its full implementation. It impacts on the resources and competences needed for implementation in Member States and limits the relevance of the Directive for potential users (outside of EU authorities and data providers) that would need more flexibility in the use, and in particular in the standards and formats.

Moreover, in the conceptualisation of INSPIRE, it was assumed in multiple cases that requirements which were during the scoping stage not supported by software tools and libraries would be implemented once proposed and endorsed by INSPIRE. Unfortunately, this rarely happened. Typical examples in this respect are lack of support for complex GML attributes in desktop GIS clients and extended capabilities of INSPIRE OGC network services. In both cases, those requirements have been to a large extent difficult to implement, but also not very well supported by clients and servers. That is why, it would be important to align technical requirements as much as possible to functionalities that are already supported (out-of-the-box) by existing tools. 67

In that sense, even though the ambition of accessibility and interoperability of environmental spatial data remain and continue to be relevant for the Member States, the technical provisions of the Directive do not seem to be future-proof, which could benefit from further simplification and streamlining.

5.1.4.Are the Articles 7 and 8 of the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive still relevant in view of the current state of the INSPIRE infrastructures?

The evaluation found that the objectives of both Directives are highly relevant in the context of the European Green Deal . They respond to the need for better information and data that are more accessible to the public and public authorities to support policy development and better implementation.

The evaluation did not find major inconsistencies between the INSPIRE Directive and the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive. There is some difference in data scope of Articles 7 and 8 of the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive and the scope of the INSPIRE Directive. The INSPIRE Directive has been designed to be consistent with the EU legal framework on data sharing and dissemination – Public Access to Environmental Information Directive and the Open Data Directive (see also 5.4.4).

The objective of the INSPIRE Directive is to set up a European infrastructure for spatial data, promote sharing of public spatial data between public administrations and with the public, and improve availability and accessibility of spatial data relevant to environmental policies and activities. The INSPIRE Directive already governs active dissemination in particular in its Articles 13 and 14. Despite differences in scope to some extent, these requirements are overlapping with the active dissemination provisions in Articles 7 and 8 of the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive.

The active dissemination provisions in the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive date almost twenty years back and as a result lack some key technical terms, crucial for making available high quality data sets. There is also no reference to the INSPIRE Directive as the common instrument to implement the requirement on public authorities to actively disseminate environmental information to the public in a coherent way across Europe. This lack of synergy between the two Directives results in different approaches to make environmental data available impacting the effectiveness of both instruments.

Table 2     Summary of the findings on relevance

Although the objectives behind the INSPIRE Directive are still very relevant and further action is required at the EU level to address the identified obstacles, the legal framework can be improved in terms of effectiveness.

To remain relevant and support the Green Deal ambitions by bringing environmental data into the Green Deal data space, the INSPIRE Directive and relevant provisions of the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive need to better consider evolving technology and information requirements.

5.2.Effectiveness

5.2.1.What progress has been made over time towards achieving the objectives and targets set out in INSPIRE in various Member States?

There has been progress towards achieving the objectives set out in the INSPIRE Directive, even though a full implementation has not been yet achieved.

Most progress was made on national coordination and removing obstacles for data sharing (with some Member States however lagging behind). Implementation difficulties persist as regards the following aspects:

·While overall, the quality of the documentation (metadata) of the identified spatial data is acceptable,there is room for further improvement to reach higher levels of conformity with the full metadata specification.

·Access to the spatial data for viewing and downloading is lagging behind with around half of the documented data sets were not yet accessible.

·Cross-border and pan-European usage of available spatial data is still difficult and time-consuming due to the heterogeneity of data offerings across countries and lack of data harmonisation.

In 2017, the JRC report on the implementation of the INSPIRE Directive indicated that ‘the state of implementation still shows different levels of maturity across Member States’. 68 The current status shows a similar picture (see Section 3).

Although the change in the monitoring system introduced in 2019 makes full comparison of progress for each Member State over the years impossible, the following conclusions can be drawn from the latest monitoring cycle for reference year 2020:

·No Member State has yet achieved full implementation according to the implementation roadmap.

·On average, in 2020, 42% of datasets were available through both view and download services (NSi2), 50% were viewable (NSi2.1) and 50% were downloadable (NSi2.2). This means that around half of available data sets were not yet accessible across the EU Member States and EEA/EFTA countries.

·The analysis also shows low conformity of metadata. Average values of 59% and 55% of conformant metadata for spatial data sets and spatial data services, respectively, are low and suggest that data providers have not extensively used the INSPIRE Reference Validator before the monitoring and reporting process.

·Conformity of spatial data sets is also heterogeneous and low on average, with some countries providing few interoperable data sets. Overall, 50% of all listed data sets are in conformity with Commission Regulation (EU) No 1089/2010 as regards interoperability of spatial data sets. The interpretation of the results must, however, take into consideration that these indicators will in many cases never reach 100%, since majority of countries provide their national data sets (as-is data) in addition to the INSPIRE harmonised data sets because both data sets serve different purposes.

·The conformity of network services has quite improved since 2019, and at least in half of the countries it is relatively high. On the other hand, several countries still offer only a few interoperable network services. The overall average percentage of conformant network services (NSi4) amounted to 63%.

Table 3  summarises the number of Member States falling under different implementation groups, in 2016 and 2020, for each implementation category: conformity of metadata; conformity of spatial datasets; accessibility of spatial datasets through view and download services; and conformity of network services. Depending on the performance results, the countries have been divided into four implementation groups, from Group I (top implementation) to Group IV (lowest level of implementation). Although this overview does not allow for strict conclusions 69 , it gives a rough indication of the implementation progress. In all categories, except the conformity of metadata, the number of countries in the highest performance implementation group (i.e. Group I) increased in 2020 compared to the 2016 data, suggesting a positive progress towards achieving the objectives of the INSPIRE Directive.

Table 3 Number of Member States falling under the four implementation groups based on their INSPIRE performance indicators' results in four implementation categories

Conformity of metadata

Conformity of spatial data sets

Accessibility of spatial datasets through view and download services

Conformity of network services

2016

2020

2016

2020

2016

2020

2016

2020

Group I: 80-100%

20

11

0

6

4

6

8

15

Group II: 55-79%

5

5

2

11

7

8

4

3

Group III: 30-54%

1

6

7

4

8

6

6

3

Group IV: 0-29%

1

5

18

6

8

7

9

6

Source: Country forms.

When considering the self-declared results based on qualitative indicators measuring the progress in terms of coordination structures, data sharing arrangements and usage of the infrastructure, there has been certain progress recorded for some Member States ( Table 4 ). More countries recorded an improvement in terms of data sharing arrangements and usage of the infrastructure than effective coordination structures. No concrete progress in establishing effective governance structures, data sharing arrangements and usage of the infrastructure were recorded in a handful of Member States.

The analysis indicates an overall positive trend; however, several Member States still need to step up their implementation efforts. It is important to consider that this qualitative analysis is based on Member State's self-assessments and is not supported by strict criteria or validation methods.

Table 4 Synthesis of the implementation status in 2020 across the Member States regarding coordination structures, data sharing arrangements and usage of the infrastructure compared to the reference year 2016

Number of Member States

Effective coordination

Data sharing arrangements and usage of the infrastructure

Improvement of the implementation status

3

8

No improvement of the implementation status

6

5

Fair level of implementation: Implementation of this provision is well advanced or (nearly) completed. Outstanding issues are minor and can be addressed easily.

18

14

Total 70  

27

27

Source: Country forms.

5.2.2.Is the progress made in line with the initial expectations and the INSPIRE implementation roadmap?

The implementation of the INSPIRE Directive still shows implementation gaps. As of 2021, most of the implementation deadlines according to the INSPIRE implementation roadmap are in the past. The level of implementation is uneven across the European Union, with many Member States lagging behind. There are still challenges related to governance structures and coordination of implementation. The results also stems from different institutional and political set ups (federal vs. centralised State, larger vs. smaller Member States, etc.). Overall, the progress made so far as regards the provision of INSPIRE-compliant metadata, data and data services is not in line with the initial expectations and the INSPIRE implementation roadmap.

A detailed overview of the INSPIRE implementation milestones is provided in the INSPIRE roadmap (see Annex 4, Part A). The major implementations steps of the INSPIRE Directive implementation are the following: 71  

(1)set up coordination structures and adopt and implement legal measures to remove procedural obstacles to the sharing of spatial data;

(2)identify their spatial data relevant to environmental policies and policies and actions with an environmental impact according to themes listed in the annexes of the Directive;

(3)document the spatial data so that they can be accessed on the internet together with information on aspects such as their source, geographical coverage, quality and conditions of use, in line with the metadata specifications;

(4)implement interoperable online services allowing the discovery, visualisation and download of spatial data;

(5)gradually organise and publish the spatial data according to common data models for greater interoperability and improved productivity.

The implementation progress as regards the steps 2, 3, 4 and 5 is covered in the overview of the current situation (See chapter 3) and identifies four implementation groups of countries based on the INSPIRE indicator results in 2020, from the least to the best performing.

When it comes to the availability of spatial data sets and services, the progress cannot be measured as no quantitative objectives have been set for this indicator. The evaluation demonstrated that Member States do not have the same number of data sets and services at national or regional level (see 5.2.3). Furthermore, several Member States reduced the number of spatial data sets in the recent years, for example, by combining several local and regional data sets into national ones. Thus, the total number of data sets and services available cannot be considered as an evidence on implementation maturity.

The progress can however be more effectively measured for other INSPIRE indicators, expressed in percentages. The main finding when comparing the current state of play and the initial implementation roadmap is that implementation for all Member States is still lagging behind the initial implementation schedule. Most of the actions in the roadmap should have been achieved by the end of 2020, however, the monitoring data shows that this is not the case (see 5.2.1). The barriers to the full implementation are described in more detail under 5.2.5.

5.2.3.Is the geographical coverage of implementation consistent with the Directive's objectives?

The evaluation showed that conclusions in terms of the geographical coverage of the implementation of the INSPIRE Directive are difficult to draw as the datasets could not be verified individually in the framework of this evaluation. When considering the interoperability requirements stemming from the INSPIRE Directive, the current geographical coverage is not deemed optimal as there are significant discrepancies in the number of datasets across Member States, their geographical scope (national, regional, local) and their content.

When looking at the number of metadata records, downloadable datasets and viewable datasets available on the INSPIRE Geoportal at national level and regional level, and their geographical distribution ( Table 5 ) it can be observed that Member States offer a varying amount of INSPIRE-relevant datasets. For instance, while Germany, Italy (and France in the past) have offered several thousands of datasets, other Member States have only made less than 100 datasets available. France reduced drastically the number of datasets available in the recent years. Since 2016, France has rationalised its offering with a focus on making datasets available that have a national coverage and were listed as environmental data priorities. In 2016, France offered 29,700 spatial datasets for which metadata existed and has reduced the number to 214 data sets in 2020.

Table 5 INSPIRE Geoportal data set statistics: number of data sets available

Number of Member States

Number of datasets available

Meta data records

Downloadable data Sets

Viewable Data Sets

below 100

5

15

17

between 100 and 299

14

7

5

between 300 and 699

6

4

4

above 10,000

2

1

1

TOTAL

27

27

27

Source: Based on the data from INSPIRE Geoportal, July 2020

There are more than twice as many regional metadata records available on the INSPIRE Geoportal than national metadata records ( Table 6 ). Under the assumption made that regional data are more heterogeneous than the national data, it is unlikely that the current geographical coverage allows yet for a good pan-European interoperability as there is too much heterogeneity in the number and content of spatial datasets made available by different Member States.

Table 6 INSPIRE Geoportal data set statistics: regional and national coverage

Data sets

National spatial scope coverage

Regional spatial scope coverage

Total number of metadata records

5,459

13,747

Downloadable datasets

2,131

1,948

Viewable datasets

2,308

2,828

Source: Based on the data from INSPIRE Geoportal, July 2020

It is important to note when considering the above observations that INSPIRE does not set the requirement to collect new data, nor sets specific requirements on the scale or the quality of the spatial data provided. This means that INSPIRE was intended to operate with a legacy of heterogeneous datasets that have been produced for the purpose of different national and regional contexts. Full interoperability can therefore not be expected based on the current framework.

5.2.4.To what extent does the implementation of the INSPIRE Directive in the Member States build further on the obligations of Public Access to Environmental Information Directive (specifically the provisions under Articles 7 and 8 under the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive)?

The evaluation could not identify with precision to what extent the implementation of the INSPIRE Directive in the Member States is effectively building on the obligations under the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive (specifically the provisions under Articles 7 on the dissemination of environmental information and 8 on the quality of environmental information). The two Directives have overlapping scopes to a certain extent, stemming from the requirements of the Aarhus Convention, Article 5 (see 5.4.4) and are often implemented in parallel, especially because of the common requirements of active dissemination.

In many countries, different public organisations are legally responsible for providing the environmental information, for providing (geo)data and for implementing INSPIRE. This might result in several separate portals to provide the environmental information, the legal base, the national implementation of that legislation and spatial data under INSPIRE. These portals are not always interlinked 72  which may result in additional administrative burden and could show a lack of coordination between the different actors managing the two instruments. 

5.2.5.Which main factors have contributed to – respectively stood in the way of achieving these objectives?

The evaluation found no new barriers to the implementation and the use of INSPIRE compared to the ones identified in previous evaluations. The table below lists the common types of obstacles already identified by Member States in the midterm evaluation. 73 From the most identified barriers to the least identified barriers were: 1) technical barriers, 2) licencing and sharing barriers, 3) knowledge barriers, 4) legal barriers, 5) financial and organisational barriers to the same extent.

The technical requirements of the INSPIRE Directive result in different levels of complexity and some specifications no longer correspond to the current technical standards and user needs. One example is the default use of the GML 74 format that is considered cumbersome and not fit for purpose. Technical complexity and over-specification have a negative impact on resources needed to implement the spatial data infrastructure and its possible use and is considered a barrier to its full deployment.

However, in other areas lack of specifications have also given rise to problems. The INSPIRE Directive leaves it up to the Member States to decide on the licensing conditions for data access. This has resulted in heterogeneous licensing schemes, terminology and reuse conditions throughout the Member States, which makes it difficult for users to assess to what extent data can be reused for cross-border and pan-European use cases.

Several Member States provide INSPIRE datasets and services as a standalone activity that is only marginally linked to the national infrastructure, often supplying access to only a subset of the rich spatial data available in national catalogues 75 . This is to minimise the burden of setting up network services and making the data interoperable according to INSPIRE rules that are not always supported by off the shelf software solutions, or not aligned with requirements adopted at the national level.

Cross-border implementation is also hampered by the different ways Member States describe the same data. Differences in description and quality are a challenge to creating a uniform picture across Member States resulting in a patchwork of data available in the INSPIRE infrastructure making it difficult to achieve pan-European coverage for specific themes. This can be remediated through extra efforts by the community involved to specify and agree more precisely the common data models. This has been done, for instance, by the marine community whereby over 100 institutions have agreed common standards for distributing geospatial data according to INSPIRE-based FAIR (findable, accessible, interoperable, reusable) principles through the EMODnet 76 initiative. Some discretion in application of data specifications should be allowed to support these community initiatives.

The evaluation further showed ( Figure 2 ) that the main barriers to the use of spatial data from the point of view of the users are firstly the technical access to data (63%), then the level of data (47%), the format (43%) and the quality of data (38%) available. Cost of access (19%), technical access to metadata (18%) and quality of metadata (9%) are less considered as barriers.

Figure 2 Barriers to the use of spatial data from the point of view of the users (N=131)

Source: All respondents, Targeted surveys (combined) April-May 2021, Question 15.

According to the public consultation ( Figure 3 ) finding data is experienced as easy by more than half of the respondents, while access and reuse of data and services is still experienced difficult by two-third of respondents.

Figure 3 Ease to find data, assess relevance, access data, combine data, re-use or republish data, reuse services or use data from a technical point of view (N=76-77)

Source: All respondents, public consultation May-July 2021, Questions 11-17.

5.2.6.To what extent is INSPIRE used for reporting under the environmental acquis?

The evaluation shows that even though challenges remained for Member States, in particular considering the harmonisation process, there has been progress in the use of INSPIRE for reporting under the environmental acquis.

INSPIRE was indeed designed to optimise data transfer and processing through the harmonisation requirements, as Member States rely on many different networks of thematic and regional data providers for environmental reporting. The midterm evaluation provided an example from the MDI-DE 77 (Marine Dateninfrastruktur Deutschland) project, as example of an infrastructure dedicated to that purpose 78 .

The JRC has undertaken several pilot initiatives together with Member States to foster the streamlining of regulatory reporting requirement and INSPIRE provisions e.g. Air Quality e-Reporting where real-time air quality data is made available by the Member States. 79  The different projects experienced difficulties linked to the disciplinary nature of the endeavour. In many cases, the communities responsible for reporting under the environmental acquis do not have the technical expertise required to implement INSPIRE provisions, and the INSPIRE experts lack knowledge of the thematic domain. The key factors identified for successful projects were a ‘balanced set of experts with good domain knowledge and where either the complexity of the topic was feasible to address or where the data work had a long tradition’. 80

In more operational terms, the 2019 report on environmental information systems (EIS) indicated that in the question ‘Is there a link between the EIS and the national INSPIRE portal, is the monitoring data found via the EIS and provided through INSPIRE?’ 81 Only in 15% of the evaluated Member States and regions declared that the link between the EIS and INSPIRE was properly provided. In 38% of the cases, reference to INSPIRE was made within the EIS, but no links were found, in 47% of the evaluated Member States and regions there is no reference and no links between the EIS and INSPIRE were found. This suggest a lack of connection between the environmental information platforms and INSPIRE and an incomplete integration resulting in different incompatible platforms and approaches for sharing environmental data.

Overall, Member States are satisfied with ongoing efforts in aligning INSPIRE and reporting requirements in EU environmental legislation and they are positive about the added value of INSPIRE for reporting when it will be fully implemented. Directives such as the Air Quality Directive, Water Framework Directive, the Industrial Emissions Directive and Bathing Water Directive are examples where the alignment process has already been achieved and has led to better reuse of spatial data for policy implementation 82 , and decreased implementation burden 83 .

National environment authorities, which are in many cases responsible for the reporting, find that spatial data made available by INSPIRE is used in the reporting under the environmental acquis especially the priority datasets identified for INSPIRE reporting. However, there are still some challenges experienced, as data cannot always be fully used by reporting authorities because it does not meet the reporting requirements (not recent enough, different content).

5.2.7.What are the qualitative and quantitative effects of INSPIRE on the policymaking users in the field of environment in Member States?

A general remark is that the evaluation gathered some examples and relevant information about use of INSPIRE and the evidence-base is considered as not robust enough. It is therefore difficult to conclude firmly on this important aspect of the Directive and the presented results are likely under-estimating the actual use as a result. Positive side effects like better organisation of the governance in particular between regional and national levels may also be under-estimated.

The above also apply to policymaking users as the information contained in the current status form is not specific and mostly quantitative (e.g. examples and numbers of geoportals in use in the Member State). The main finding is that outside some examples of use by policy makers, which are also data providers, it was difficult to quantify the use and effect on policy making in general, while in some specific areas there was a good uptake of the INSPIRE Directive.

Interviews with Member States revealed a mixed picture when it comes to measuring the effect of the Directive on policy making in the field of environment. Spatial data is considered an important source of information for the implementation of environmental policy, but Member States are not always able to provide precise information about the use or users of data. The reason behind is that it is not specifically monitored or because users are also the data providers for their own needs (mainly at local, regional, national level) and do not need to use the datasets in INSPIRE formats. It was also raised that the INSPIRE Directive is not yet fully implemented and as such, the effects cannot be observed yet.

Furthermore, it was observed that in many Member States more and richer non-harmonised data sets, that better serve the needs of national and regional policy makers, are being made available through the national infrastructure 84 . In addition, when these Member States are providing separate INSPIRE datasets and services, they usually pay less attention to their usability. For example, INSPIRE services may be set up to serve huge amounts of datasets or layers, or the services may not be actively quality-controlled or monitored. This makes them difficult to use in any practical application. 85

To increase the usefulness of the INSPIRE Directive for policymakers active in sectors or policies that are relevant for the environment (transport, energy marine etc.) further alignment with sectoral requirements would be needed. Pilot projects over the last 5 years 86 report that alignment is a long process and technical difficulties arise in relation to data quality (for instance, frequency of data collection: annual data versus real-time data for traffic information or spatial accuracy).

However, it is also important to emphasize that the INSPIRE Directive was reported by Member States to be a driver for a better organisation of the governance in particular between regional and national levels. INSPIRE has driven the development of portals and centralised access to the datasets in most Member States.

In the surveys for targeted sectors (agriculture, marine, spatial data, environment) 42% of respondents considered that the INSPIRE Directive contributed to a large extent to access, exchange and reuse of geospatial data across public sector organisations. Another third (32%) considered that it contributed to this to some extent ( Figure 4 ).

Figure 4 Contribution of INSPIRE to access, exchange and reuse of geospatial data across public sector organisations (N=139)

Source: All respondents, Targeted surveys (combined) April-May 2021, Question 5

5.2.8.What are the qualitative and quantitative effects of INSPIRE on users active in economic sectors influencing environment?

The main finding on qualitative and quantitative effects of INSPIRE on users active in economic sectors influencing environment is that information on use and users is too scarce to provide a clear view of the effects of INSPIRE for these. Studies and stakeholders involved in the INSPIRE implementation (at European Union and Member States levels) seem to be focused on making data available, without identifying upstream the precise effects on each type of users or monitoring how data are used, by whom and what for.

As far as uses are concerned, reporting and planning purposes rank first. This is coherent with the fact that the first users of spatial data are national / local authorities or agencies.

The availability of data and the way data are, or could be used have often been assessed but there is no precise or comprehensive information on effects of availability of the data on the users in different sectors. The JRC carried out two projects in the past years to assess how geospatial data made available by the Member States, as a result of INSPIRE, can be used to tackle energy efficiency 87 or mobility issues 88 . The two projects start from a very specific need from a final user to identify information needs for policy implementation. INSPIRE data are seen as a means to achieve high-level objectives but it is not indicated what effects can be identified. It is therefore challenging to establish a direct link between the availability of data as a result of the implementation of INSPIRE and the positive effects on users in economic sectors. 

18 Member States and EFTA/EEA countries indicated in their country forms that better overview, discoverability, availability, accessibility of data were among the main direct benefits of INSPIRE (see 5.3.1).

Targeted surveys showed that respondents think that spatial data made available because of INSPIRE are:

·Mainly used by public administrations: national governments / ministries (36%) followed by regional and local authorities (29%) and national and regional agencies (36%). 89  

·Used (to a very large, large or some extent) by 25% of the marine/maritime sector, 38% of the transport/mobility sector, 36% of the agricultural sector and by 24% of other sectors / users. 90  

The public consultation 91  indicated that the purposes for using data are (logically) dependent from the type of users. All academic/research institutions use data for research purposes and for 60% of respondents the data is used for reporting purposes. NGOs all indicated that they use data for planning purposes while 80% also use data for research purposes and three out of five for reporting purposes. Overall, reporting purposes and planning purposes are the two first usages of data (59% and 58% of respondents respectively). Research purposes was chosen by almost 50% of respondents to the public consultation. 

Furthermore, the public consultation also gave an indication at sector level ( Figure 5 ) how INSPIRE can support process of planning and assessing impacts (either slightly or strongly). The better results are related to the implementation of the Water Framework Directive (55% of respondents) and the Nature – Birds and Habitats Directives (51%). One respondent out of four (26%) indicated that INSPIRE supports process of planning and assessing impacts as far as Transport / the Intelligent Transport Systems Directive are concerned. They were slightly more to consider that INSPIRE does provide support for Marine protection / Marine Strategy Framework Directive (28%).

Figure 5 Support of INSPIRE to the process of planning and assessing impacts in different policy areas – responses from the public authorities - responses from all respondents (N=49-67)

Source: All respondents, public consultation May-July 2021, Question 18.

5.2.9.What are the effects of INSPIRE on small businesses using spatial data?

The knowledge by INSPIRE implementers (Member States) of companies that use spatial data is limited. They do not monitor such users but indicated that the number of SMEs using spatial data is most likely limited. Based on this, the evaluation concluded that the use of INSPIRE data for commercial purposes or by the private sector more generally is rather limited.

The public consultation did not present conclusive evidence but indicated that the use of spatial data made available under INSPIRE for commercial purposes and more generally by companies themselves might be limited. This can be explained by lack of knowledge in the sector about INSPIRE or because the data as such can be acquired by other means.

Table 7 Summary of the findings on effectiveness

Member States have progressed in the implementation of the Directive. Still, no Member State has achieved full implementation yet. Implementation gaps still need to be closed to fully capture effects and impacts.

The current geographical coverage of implementation does not allow to meet the INSPIRE Directive objective in terms of interoperability.

The implementation of the INSPIRE Directive as well as the sharing and reuse of existing spatial data still face barriers already identified in the previous evaluation of the Directive. These barriers are primarily of a technical nature.

The different ways that Member States can describe the same data, limits cross-border application. It requires extra effort to align standards as has been done by the marine community through EMODnet.

Several Member States provide INSPIRE datasets and services as a standalone activity that is only marginally linked to the national infrastructure, often supplying access to only a subset of the rich spatial data available in national catalogues and limiting the usefulness and effectiveness of the INSPIRE infrastructure.

The use of datasets and services through the INSPIRE framework is developing both in a data-sharing and active dissemination context. However, Member States’ additional efforts would be needed to increase the use of the INSPIRE framework – be it for EU level, national or regional purposes. Revising INSPIRE and the Public Access to Information Directive should be considered to improve their effectiveness and as a result the implementation of both instruments.

5.3.Efficiency

5.3.1.To what extent, and how has the intervention lead to improvements in the quality or efficiency of work of concerned stakeholders?

With regard to the improvements of the quality and/or efficiency of the work of involved stakeholders, the main direct benefits of the directive has been: better overview, discoverability, availability, and accessibility of data. The main benefits are followed by Harmonisation and interoperability, and Innovation, technologies, and technical knowledge. These benefits were identified in the analysis of the country forms reports ( Table 8 ).

To the extent that INSPIRE is implemented, the evaluation has found that it provides the following benefits: better overview, discoverability, availability, and accessibility of data. These are followed by: harmonisation and interoperability; innovation, technologies, and technical knowledge. These findings stem from the analysis of the country form reports.

Table 8 INSPIRE benefits listed by Member States and EFTA/EEA countries in the country forms

Direct benefits

Number of countries in the country forms

Type of benefit

Benefit identified by stakeholders:

Benefits from the production/processing geospatial data

Improved quality and reliability of data

4 (13%)

Harmonisation and interoperability

11 (35%)

Improved cooperation among stakeholders

7 (23%)

Benefits from products (public/private) based on geospatial data

Reduction of time/ costs (efficiency)

10 (32%)

Share and reuse of data

9 (29%)

Economic profit and new business opportunities

4 (13%)

Innovation, technologies, and technical knowledge

11 (35%)

Better overview, discoverability, availability, accessibility of data

18 (58%)

Improved quality and reliability of data

7 (23%)

Indirect benefits

Number of countries in the country forms

Type of benefit

Benefit identified by stakeholders:

Transparency and improved policy making

Contribution to policy making in various areas

4 (13%)

Increased openness to share data by data providers

3 (10%)

Benefits at national and EU level

Socio-economic benefits

5 (16%)

National infrastructure and data strategy development

6 (19%)

EU-wide collaboration

4 (13%)

Source: Current status country forms (Total Number N=31).

Interviews with seven Member States confirmed that especially harmonisation and interoperability is a key benefit. In Member States where data is stored in many different formats and some of these formats are not readable using the most common GIS 92 systems, creating services and formats that can be used by all users is one of the most important benefits.

In targeted surveys with stakeholders from selected communities (environment, marine, agriculture, and spatial data) most of the direct benefit types were judged as significant. The categories “Better overview”, “Harmonisation” and “Share and Reuse of Data” score very significant from more than 20% of the respondents.

Figure 6 Direct benefits of INSPIRE (Total number of respondents N=113-128)

Source: All respondents, Targeted surveys (combined) April-May 2021, Question 23.A.

In terms of indirect benefits “Increased openness to share data by data providers”, “National infrastructure and data strategy development” and “EU-wide collaboration” are identified as most significant. 93  This shows that INSPIRE has been instrumental in furthering the development of the national geoportals as well as in promoting increased sharing of data.

The public consultation showed that better comparability and interoperability are identified as main benefits (64%), followed by the use of data across the EU and better availability of spatial data (57%). 94  

5.3.2.Can any specific provisions in INSPIRE be identified that make cost-efficient implementation more difficult?

Some Member States implemented INSPIRE as an integral part of the national SDI, while others as a separate system with separate IT-infrastructure. The specific approach chosen has a major influence on how to appreciate the cost (and perceived value) of INSPIRE. Moreover, the implementation modalities depend largely on organisation in the countries at the different administrative levels.

With these major precautions in mind, provisions on harmonisation and interoperability of spatial data and the costs (resources) are considered to make implementation more costly and less efficient.

9 countries ( Table 9 ) have reported that the main costs relate to data harmonisation, IT Infrastructure, geodata services and interoperability and staff resources. Some countries provide estimates of actual costs either as totals or as yearly costs.

Table 9 Costs of implementing INSPIRE listed in the country forms

Type of cost

Cost types identified by stakeholders

Number of Member States and EFTA/EEA countries

Costs related to acquiring and processing of geospatial data

Data production and maintenance

5 (16%)

Data harmonization and interoperability

9 (29%)

Provision of metadata

7 (23%)

Costs related to storing and distributing geospatial data

IT infrastructure

9 (29%)

Centralized systems and data centres

2 (6%)

System maintenance

5 (16%)

Network security

1 (3%)

Geodata services and interoperability

9 (29%)

Staff resources

9 (29%)

Consultancy/INSPIRE expertise

3 (10%)

Costs related to improving use of geospatial data

Development of other related systems and projects

2 (6%)

Training of stakeholders/users

-

Staff resources

-

Consultancy/INSPIRE expertise

1 (3%)

INSPIRE reporting

Staff resources

-

Meetings/coordination

2 (6%)

INSPIRE indicators

1 (3%)

Within countries, costs are perceived differently among stakeholders at the same administrative level but from different institutions (i.e. organisations/institutions at national level). Large providers of data such as cadastre or mapping agencies do not have infrastructure costs. Such institutions experience costs in relation to processing and harmonising of data instead.

Targeted surveys confirm that costs related to harmonisation and interoperability are most significant 95 , and that the bulk of these costs are carried by public administrations (national, regional and local in order of volume of expenditures) 96 . 

Also in the public consultation especially harmonisation is identified as a key cost driver for the implementers 97 . Notably the users do not perceive that there are additional costs, and if any these would relate to purchasing additional or new software to access/use the data 98 . 

5.3.3.Can the INSPIRE Directive and implementing rules be made more cost-efficient? What is the simplification potential?

The evaluation evidence suggest further costs-efficiency could be accomplished by: 1) simplifying the implementation requirement and 2) better facilitating the use of the infrastructure (data, services). The latter may not necessarily lead to reduced nominal costs, but to a better ratio to outcome.

Already the mid-term evaluation identified technical complexity as the number one obstacle for the INSPIRE implementation according to the respondents in the public consultation. Simplification of the technical specifications came second as the most important obstacle to achieve the INSPIRE objectives 99 .

JRC started in 2018 defining alternative encodings (e.g. GeoJSON and Geopackage) to simplify the complex data models related to the INSPIRE Directive and introduce encodings that are broadly accepted by the geospatial community and the industry. Relaxation of some semantic requirements would help improve the usability of the INSPIRE framework. When considering changes to the current INSPIRE infrastructure, it is important to not only consider the data but also to consider relevant technological developments and the role of new actors, including the private sector and citizen science initiatives.

One other aspect of simplification is the perception by users that the data models and the way data is presented (view) is too complicated for a number of users. Different types of users have different needs regarding data models: while advanced users need quite complex structures to do their job, using data models with this complexity will be a burden for other users with simpler needs. INSPIRE specifies data models for each data theme covered by INSPIRE, covering the combined needs from the most advanced users.

Interviews with Member States show in general that there is a need to simplify the implementation at the technical level. Due to the complexity in the data models data consumption in mainstream GIS software is limited (not all software can be used). Additionally, technical specifications are not easy to understand.

The need of simple models and standard software was also reflected in the targeted surveys, that propose simpler data models for increased use.

Notably, the analysis of the public consultation 100 found that respondents were more concerned with harmonisation and interoperability than with use (downloading and viewing spatial data).

5.3.4.Are results achieved so far commensurate with the resources put forward and in line with the ones expected from the ex-ante evaluation of INSPIRE?

The key findings of this evaluation are that relatively few assessments of costs and benefits have been made of the implementation of INSPIRE. Even in the cases where these have been conducted, it is clear that it is not always possible to separate the cost of implementing INSPIRE from the costs of implementing and maintaining the national SDI.

The impact assessment estimated that the benefits of implementing INSPIRE would be many-fold compared to the investment needed. 101 The benefits were estimated in the range of EUR 680-1660 millions against costs of EUR 77-161 millions.

The ex-post costs and benefits to Member States from INSPIRE are difficult to assess as these have not been collected and calculated in a uniform manner, if at all. The impact assessment/ex ante evaluation of 2007/2004 sets out a methodology for Member States to record and calculate the costs and benefits, but only a few Member States have complied with the request to apply the methodology.

All cost-benefit assessments focus mainly on the benefits of implementing SDI in general. Overall, all the reviewed cost-benefit analysis find that when SDI is implemented this has a large positive impact/benefit for both the public (cost savings) and private sector (costs savings and business opportunities). Nevertheless, a number of Member States found that it is too early to really assess the cost-benefits ratio as INSPIRE is not yet fully implemented.

Table 10 presents recent cost-benefits analysis (CBA) conducted by individual Member States. CBA studies for NL, DK, UK were already included in the midterm evaluation. The three more recent studies (ES, SE and LT) show that different approaches have been taken to measure the costs and benefits. In the case of Spain, the value of the web services and data are estimated. In the case of Lithuania, the costs of saved working hours resulting from the sharing of data are assessed. In the last study on Sweden, the benefits and costs of physical planning of digitalisation and geodata has been analysed. The three studies all find that the benefits outweigh the costs.

A study conducted in Finland in 2017 102 (and used as basis for the cost-benefit analysis (utility analysis) conducted by Sweden) shows that harmonised digital physical planning can save up 60% of the time used for inquiries and investigations. The Swedish study 103 estimates cost savings for the municipalities at EUR 17 million, for regional authorities it is EUR 3,5 million, for the court system the saving amounts to EUR 0.8 million and for the Swedish Transport Administration to EUR 3.5 million. The estimated total savings are thus EUR 25 million. The same study estimates that the total savings regarding labour costs for house construction in Sweden can be estimated at EUR 1.8–3.7 billion and corresponding cost savings for infrastructure construction at between EUR 39 million and EUR 88 million when using geodata, Building Information Modeling (BIM) and a common perspective and information. The total savings are thus estimated to be between EUR 1.8 billion and EUR 3.8 billion per year in Sweden.

The example from Lithuania 104 included in Table 10  indicatively shows the benefits and costs of INSPIRE implementation. The costs of INSPIRE is estimated to amount to EUR 3 million whereas the benefits are estimated to EUR 6-7 million.

In the report which assesses the costs and benefit for Spain, although concluding that the benefits outweigh the costs, the main purpose is to set up a methodology to estimate the economic benefits generated by the central SDI-node.

Table 10 Examples of cost-benefits analysis conducted in Member States

MS

Description of study

Description of key findings

ES

The study developed and tested a methodology to estimate the economic benefits generated by the central SDI-node of Spain. Benefits estimation is understood as an approximate calculation - as accurate as possible - in monetary terms of the value of the web services and data in the central SDI-node based on a set of objective considerations and criteria. The central SDI node comprises all the SDI resources published on the web by the same organization, IGN-ES, as coordinator of the Spanish SDI 105 .

The authors note that this is a model based on estimates and not hard mathematics – but this provides a possibility for an estimate and a comparison between Member States.

The factor that has the biggest impact on the benefits or value is the number of service requests. When these numbers are rising, then the benefits are rising as well.

The richer the central-node is, i.e. the more WMTS and WMS there are, the more requests this will generate, and thus also more value. However, it should be noted that this depends on whether the services are ‘used’, this means are embedded in (new) applications.

SE

In 2019, in a report to the Swedish government Lantmäteriet estimated the potential benefits (utility) from national governed access to geodata to be in-between 22.3 and 42.4 billion Swedish kronor in the area of societal development only. 106  

Benefits:

-At local government level EUR 25 million

-At central government level EUR 53 million

Private public construction companies EUR 2,1 million

LT

For the structural fund applications, the Lithuanian authorities did a comprehensive study based on assumptions, experiences and statistics. They calculated the working hours that were saved because of the sharing of data. For example, time was saved for users, who no longer need to drive across Lithuania to obtain some paper documents or data storage. The benefits are expressed in saved working hours rather than in monetary terms. Estimates can be then calculated based on the average wage of the employees whose working hours were reduced. Most of the benefits are linked to saving time or buying new software.

Benefits:

-For INSPIRE Annex 3 – estimated ca 20,000 working days annually / ca EUR 1,2 million (for 2020)

-For INSPIRE Annex 1 and 2 estimated EUR 4 million 

-Plus ca. EUR 1 million indirect benefits (better informed decisions, transparency…)

-Total annual EUR 6-7 million

Costs:

-Three EU-funded SDI development projects: EUR 8,9 million (full SDI + administrative services)

-INSPIRE part, explicit: about EUR 2,5 million

-Annual budget 2011–2020 (full SDI); EUR 4 million

INSPIRE part, explicit: ca EUR 0,5 million

It is noticeable that the responses of the public consultation ( Figure 7 ) show that 37% of the respondents overall found that there were some benefits of INSPIRE, but that the costs prevail in terms of sharing and using spatial data. Only 25% of the respondents found that benefits outweigh the costs. This is not particularly surprising, as the majority of respondents belong to public administrations responsible for implementing the INSPIRE Directive and carrying the bulk of the costs (see 5.3.5).

Figure 7 Proportionality of costs and benefits (N=69)

Source: All respondents, public consultation May-July 2021, Question 24.

5.3.5.How proportionate were the costs of the intervention for different stakeholder groups (enterprises including SMEs, citizens …)?

National authorities and agencies are the stakeholders bearing the highest cost and where less of the (direct) benefits appear. Yet, the consultation showed that also businesses have the perception that costs outweigh benefits. The evaluation shows that the role of INSPIRE is not fully understood and notably that the cost of generating data is attributed to INSPIRE whilst the undeniable need for the data to be available regardless of INSPIRE is not fully reflected. The findings point to a need for more targeted information about INSPIRE and how it can utilised for different public and commercial purposes.

The review of the cost-benefits analysis presented under 5.3.4 included a presentation of studies of Sweden and Lithuania that assessed the cost-benefit at different government levels and to the private sector (in the case of Sweden only). In the Swedish study, the assessment of the benefits (cost savings) for the municipal level is the highest among stakeholder levels and groups included (in the example of physical planning). In another example in Sweden concerning the administration of the construction law the municipal level is estimated to have a cost saving of EUR 20 million per year. These examples do not provide information on the costs for the municipal levels as such, but only serve to reflect that the benefits for the municipal level can be significant when implementing an SDI system.

In the JRC Study 107 on access to spatial data for environmental purposes, the study finds that the costs related to acquiring (accessing) spatial data in some Member States are significant.

Interviews with Member States confirm that it is at the national level that the highest cost occur. The main costs relate to acquiring and processing of geospatial data i.e. the production of data. In addition, costs relating to harmonisation of data were identified as a cost category for both national and local level institutions. The cost structure depends on the organisation of the Spatial Data Infrastructure (SDI) in the country, the size and the constitutional structure of the country. Federally organised counties will tend to involve more institutional stakeholders and levels of government in SDI implementation, and this requires additional harmonisation and coordination efforts.

Targeted surveys also confirmed that the main costs are perceived at national level and that these organisations may not see all the benefits. The stakeholder group of geological survey, mapping and cadastre and national authorities are those that perceive that cost outweigh benefits.

It is noticeable that the public consultation shows ( Figure 8 ) that in addition to the national level also businesses have the perception that costs outweigh benefits at this stage.

Figure 8    Proportionality of costs as perceived per stakeholder group (N=69)

Source: All respondents, public consultation May-July 2021, Question 24

5.3.6.Have the resources needed to implement INSPIRE been available?

The resource situation varies from country to country and within countries at different administrative levels. Several resource issues were identified that have a negative impact on the available resources: bad prioritisation of the use of resources between the different tasks of INSPIRE (e.g. underestimation of the data harmonisation effort), uneven distribution of resources/funds between national/regional/local levels of administration, lack of available profiles with the required expertise, budget discontinuity, additional costs of outsourcing the implementation and maintenance of the infrastructure.

Mostly, INSPIRE implementation has been funded as part of the general SDI budget allocation with some difference in terms of which costs are carried at different government levels. Often, funding is provided at national level (state budget). Some Member States 108 have also used funding via European Structural Investment Funds (ESIF) or have reported the participation of a number of organisations to projects with EU level funding from other instruments (the research framework programmes 109 , LIFE+, ISA 110 ) without further budgetary information. Such projects can help to develop solutions and tools that can be used by all Member States (reusable components), which can improve efficiency across multiple policy sectors. However, these opportunities are not used systematically by Member States.

5.3.7.How has the use of INSPIRE for environmental reporting affected the reporting burden?

The evaluation shows that the reporting burden is estimated to be further reduced in function of the ongoing alignment of INSPIRE provisions with regulatory reporting provisions in other environmental regulations. Environmental authorities use the spatial data made available through INSPIRE to some extent. At the same time, it was noted that this does not necessarily reduce the reporting burden.

The Commission identified monitoring and reporting under the environmental acquis as a priority use case for the development of a first set of pan-European information products (see 3.2.1). Based on the evaluation of reporting obligations 111 under the environmental legislation, it was found, inter alia, that the more advanced and systematic use of information technology including the wider application of the INSPIRE positively influence the efficiency of reporting process. It was also found that relying more on active dissemination would also improve these processes.

Findings under effectiveness (see 5.2.6) and under coherence (see 5.4.2) point out that although the ongoing alignment of regulatory reporting obligations with INSPIRE obligations, the use of INSPIRE still offer unused potentials. More work in terms of making it technically more efficient will be needed before INSPIRE really can support the reduction of the administrative burden.

Member States were overall positive (see 5.2.6) about the alignment process of INSPIRE with EU reporting requirements in areas such as: air quality directive, water framework directive, the industrial emissions directive and the bathing water directive. These are examples where it has been implemented with success.

5.3.8.How would further streamlining of the provisions in Articles 7 and 8 of the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive with the active dissemination provisions of the INSPIRE Directive impact the administrative burden on the Member States.

The evaluation found that INSPIRE can further support the implementation of the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive as it provides a technical framework for electronic data sharing.

In terms of the administrative burden, the targeted surveys showed ( Figure 9 ) that stakeholders perceive that INSPIRE supports the implementation of the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive, at least to some extent, by improving the capacity. An improvement in the capacity of public authorities to disseminate environmental information to the public in an easily accessible electronic format should have an effect on the administrative burden.

Figure 9 Extent to which INSPIRE contributes to the capacity of public authorities to disseminate environmental information to the public in compliance with Directive 2003/4/EC

Source: All respondents, First row: Targeted surveys (combined) April-May 2021; and second row: Targeted survey of the environmental community only April-May 2021, Question 41. 

Table 11 Summary of the findings on efficiency

INSPIRE facilitates the work of the stakeholders in the area of spatial data provision through improved discoverability, availability and accessibility to spatial data.

Interoperability (of data and services) is the most important cost factor in the INSPIRE implementation.

There is a simplification potential of the implementation in terms of addressing the requirement for interoperability.

The results achieved so far are commensurate with the resources put forward and are in line with the ones expected from the ex-ante evaluation of INSPIRE in observed cases. However, implementation is not yet complete and hence results cannot be fully assessed yet.

Stakeholders perceive the costs as 'asymmetrical'. Most costs relate to the implementation of the Directive and are largely borne by national governments because the implementation obligation is on their public administrations, but differ significantly in function of how INSPIRE has been implemented notably if it is part of or independent from SDI. A proportion of these costs can therefore not necessarily be attributed to the Directive as such. Users of the spatial data infrastructure do not perceive extraordinary costs.

In most cases, the resources for implementation were available, but some Member States have perceived it as a challenge to secure the resources. In these Member States, costs have been perceived as higher.

The INSPIRE Directive has proven to be a valuable instrument to achieve legal interoperability by streamlining concepts and reporting provisions across different environmental acts (e.g. on environmental emissions).

The INSPIRE Directive can support the implementation of the Public Access to Information Directive by providing a technical framework for electronic data sharing.

While the INSPIRE Directive performs satisfactorily at making geospatial environmental data accessible, simplification, modernisation and future-proofing would mitigate the challenges linked to the costs of implementing the Directive.



5.4.Coherence

5.4.1.To what extent is INSPIRE coherent internally?

The evaluation did not identify any major inconsistencies between INSPIRE Directive, its Implementing Rules and the non-binding Technical Guidance.

The requirements of the INSPIRE Directive are contained in several layers of regulations and guidance, which have different statuses. The general requirements, are contained in the INSPIRE Directive itself, together with the list of spatial data themes, listed in the Annexes to the Directive. These are complemented by a series of Implementing Rules for metadata, network services, and interoperability of spatial data sets and services, which are binding in their entirety, and by non-binding Technical Guidance, which specifies data models and implementation requirements for each spatial data theme, metadata and network services.

No evidence was found that having several layers of regulations and guidance creates any inconsistencies per se. However, a number of the technical elements included in the Implementing Rules are no longer in line with technological developments, such as certain code lists and their values, or coordinate reference systems. Such modifications can currently only be made by amending the Implementing Rules.

If the INSPIRE implementing rules were to be revised through legislative procedure, they would have to be aligned with the provisions of Article 290 and 291 of the Lisbon Treaty regarding Delegated and Implementing Acts, and with the comitology procedures laid down in Regulation (EU) 182/2011. Aligning the comitology procedures referred to in the INSPIRE Directive to the Lisbon treaty might lead to more flexible revision procedures.

5.4.2.To what extent is INSPIRE coherent with environmental legislation with geospatial reporting obligations?

The evaluation did not identify any impediments to the application of INSPIRE contained within relevant EU legislation; in fact many pieces of legislation do make reference to INSPIRE rules. Having a reference to INSPIRE in the various pieces of environmental legislation recalling the obligation to share data according to INSPIRE rules supports compliance with INSPIRE and is considered helpful to increase awareness of the INSPIRE obligations, while also avoiding duplication of obligations and administrative burden.

The midterm evaluation concluded that, despite efforts to increase the coherence between INSPIRE and EU environmental legislation requiring the reporting of spatial data, both in terms of legal coherence and guidance, ‘reporting systems were only partially making use of the INSPIRE rules and specifications’, and that more work was needed to improve coherence of INSPIRE with environmental reporting requirements.

To ensure that in practice environmental reporting and the implementation of INSPIRE become consistent processes, the alignment of reporting data models with INSPIRE data specifications is necessary. Often environmental reporting and provision of INSPIRE data sets are still two distinct processes, resulting in two different datasets produced, because of differences in data specifications, standards or lack of collaboration between competent authorities responsible for environmental reporting and authorities building and maintaining the national SDI. Abramic et al (2018) mentioned for instance that in the case of MSFD, the metadata created by authorities responsible for implementing the MSFD in Member States were not always included in the national metadata catalogues (but only in Reportnet), limiting the benefits in terms of data discoverability 112 .

Progress has been made for certain legislation, with new data specifications being based on INSPIRE requirements (IED, Environmental Noise Directive) and alignment efforts are being made or will be made soon for other environmental Directives (e.g. Floods, Nitrates, Drinking water, or Seveso Directives). The progressive alignment of environmental reporting obligations with INSPIRE is a long process, which requires cooperation between the Commission, the EEA and Member States. It is also a complex process as INSPIRE might not always be perfectly suited for catering the requirements of thematic pieces of legislation.

To facilitate the alignment of reporting obligations and INSPIRE, a new reporting platform has been established by the EEA as Reportnet 3.0 113 . Reportnet is Eionet’s infrastructure used for environmental reporting, which has been operational since 2002.  114 One of the functions of Reportnet 3.0 will allow for the intake of INSPIRE datasets. Member States will progressively have the possibility to connect their reporting processes to INSPIRE services through Reportnet 3.0.  115

5.4.3.To what extent is INSPIRE coherent with other relevant areas of EU policy with geospatial reporting obligations (transport, agriculture, maritime, space, health, disaster management, research)?

The evaluation found that INSPIRE is coherent with other policy areas and further synergies have been identified and used during the evaluated period. Further potentials could be harvested by even closer cooperation across related policy fields.

The evaluation revealed synergies between INSPIRE and sectoral objectives (See Annex 5). INSPIRE is considered as an opportunity in several sectors to have a centralised entry point to access and share data, and to avoid duplication of data collection and reporting processes (IACS data sharing, Copernicus in situ component, climate adaptation data, TEN-T, development of pan-European geospatial reference data sets by Eurostat). Links with INSPIRE are being developed (legal references, technical guidance) and alignment of various data sharing instruments is ongoing (IACS, EMODnet, Copernicus). The pace of implementation (or varying degrees of implementation) of INSPIRE across the Member States is however slowing down the process and, in some cases, impedes successful interactions (e.g., the Copernicus in situ component).

In some sectors the possible use of the INSPIRE Directive is still largely to be defined (MSP, TEN-T, climate adaptation). Collaboration with sectoral DGs at EU level and through committees could be further developed, where relevant (e.g., representation of INSPIRE groups in sectoral committees, formalising cooperation).

5.4.4.To what extent is INSPIRE coherent with the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive and the objectives of the Common European Green Deal data space?

Public Access to Environmental Information Directive and INSPIRE were adopted for partially overlapping purposes. The former has the objective of ensuring the right of access to environmental information held by public authorities to end-users. It also aims to ensure the progressive electronic dissemination of environmental information to the public, for transparency purposes, and for enabling public scrutiny and access to justice, as provided by Article 5 of the Aarhus Convention.

The evaluation did not reveal any formal conflicts between the INSPIRE Directive and Public Access to Environmental Information Directive. However, evidence shows that both Directives were often implemented through separate systems that are not necessarily connected. There are also significant potentials for further alignment between the two instruments to achieve better and more up-to-date outcomes, notably in form of better and more useful information available to the public (and business).

The scope of ‘environmental information’ addressed by the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive is significantly broader than the scope of INSPIRE. Environmental information, in the meaning of the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive does concern a wide range of items, listed in Article 2(1) of the Directive, including environmental assessment, policy and planning documents, environmental permits, implementation reports, enforcement measures etc., which should be made publicly accessible. Although some of these documents might be relevant for some spatial datasets (e.g. list of permitted installations, facilities or transport networks), the aim of the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive is also that those documents are made available to the public in their entirety for transparency purposes.

The provisions in the Directive concerning dissemination of environmental information leave a lot of discretion to the MS and would benefit from:

·a reference to metadata (which is an essential element to ensure that the information made available is of sufficient quality in accordance with Article 8 of the directive);

·a definition of what active dissemination entails, e.g. view and download services.

In terms of scope, the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive and the INSPIRE Directive address information or data held by public authorities. Both directives are fully aligned in the way they define ‘public authority’. 116

The adoption of the INSPIRE Directive introduced an important new mechanism for sharing environmental information that has a spatial dimension through electronic means. Some Member States already use INSPIRE specifications to fulfil its obligations to share environmental information under the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive. In this perspective, the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive and INSPIRE are largely complementary as INSPIRE has the potential to support the implementation of the former.

Recent studies have shown however that both Directives were often implemented through separate systems that are not necessarily connected. A recent study on national environmental information systems (EIS) found that, in many Member States, there are no links between the EIS and the INSPIRE SDI. Only in 15% of the evaluated Member States and regions a link between the EIS and INSPIRE was properly provided. In 38% of the cases, a reference to INSPIRE was made within the EIS, but no links were found, and in 47% of the evaluated Member States and regions there was no reference and no links between the EIS and INSPIRE 117 . The study also found that the monitoring data provided in the EIS did not have metadata in line with INSPIRE. 118 This is clearly pointing to a problem that results in impacting the quality and reliability of the data made available under the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive.

The Public Access to Environmental Information Directive does not mention the INSPIRE Directive as it was adopted before INSPIRE and has not been revised. The language of the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive with regards to data sharing is quite outdated and the obligation to share information through ‘electronic means’ is not further specified with regards to environmental data. This suggests that INSPIRE at present does not actively support the implementation of the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive in the absence of a binding reference to INSPIRE, requiring that data referred to in Article 7(e) should be shared in accordance with INSPIRE.

5.4.5.To what extent is INSPIRE coherent with Directive (EU) 2019/1024 on open data and the re-use of public sector information and what are the implications of Directive 2019/1024/EU?

Although they do overlap in scope, the evaluation showed that technical requirements on data sharing currently laid down in both Directives do not contradict each other. The inconsistencies between INSPIRE and the PSI Directive that were exposed by the study to support the review of the PSI Directive, have been largely resolved by the Open Data Directive.

The 2018 evaluation of the PSI Directive concluded that the ‘question of coherence between the INSPIRE Directive and the charging provisions of the PSI Directive could benefit from some clarification or formal alignment’, 119 as some stakeholders called for more guidance on what charges and licenses are permitted for accessing spatial data and services. 120 Similarly, the midterm evaluation found some inconsistencies regarding the data sharing provisions under INSPIRE (Article 17) and the PSI Directive regarding licensing and charging for the data.

Although both Directives allow for some type of charging mechanism for the provision of data, including the notion of recovering a reasonable return on investment, the PSI Directive is more prescriptive than the INSPIRE Directive. It provides that charges must be limited to the marginal costs incurred for the reproduction, provision and dissemination of the data, and in the case of public bodies that are required to generate revenue to cover the costs of their activities, also a reasonable return on investment. 121 On the other hand, the INSPIRE Directive uses a broader terminology, providing that charges applied for sharing data between public bodies should be kept to the minimum required to ensure the necessary quality and supply of spatial data sets and services, together with a reasonable return on investment. 122  

In addition, the evaluation of the PSI Directive found that metadata interoperability issues could arise, in practice, if the PSI and INSPIRE communities do not sufficiently coordinate with each other, as both communities use their own metadata standards (ISO vs. CKAN standards), which are not interoperable. 123 This issue may increase in the future with the practical implementation of the Open Data Directive and further developments to the EU Open Data portal, created to facilitate the discovery of the data made available by the PSI Directive. Although the PSI Directive does not set obligations in terms of standards or format it will nonetheless be crucial to ensure that supporting guidance and recommendations for both directives are compatible in practice.

In terms of the interplay with the INSPIRE Directive, the new Open Data Directive makes several references to INSPIRE to clarify the interactions between the Directives based on the PSI Directive evaluation. Recital 4 states that the provisions of the Open Data Directive should focus on the relationship with other EU legal instruments, including INSPIRE. Recital 34 states that, where possible and appropriate, public sector information should be ‘made available through an open and machine-readable format and together with their metadata at the best level of precision and granularity, in a format that ensures interoperability, for example by processing them in a way consistent with the principles governing the compatibility and usability requirements for spatial information under Directive 2007/2/EC’. Finally, Article 1(7) specifically clarifies that the Open Data Directive ‘governs the re-use of existing documents held by public sector bodies and public undertakings of the Member States, including documents to which Directive 2007/2/EC applies.’

The main changes in the Open Data Directive that might call for a future alignment in the INSPIRE Directive are related to the principles governing charging (Article 6) and to the provisions on high-value datasets (Articles 13 and 14), more specifically the future implementing act currently being developed by the Commission and the requirement to provide such datasets free of charge. The coherence of the INSPIRE and Open Data Directive cannot be fully assessed at this stage. The national transposition and implementation of the latter is still ongoing and the high-value datasets implementing act is currently being developed.

Close cooperation in future developments of both legal frameworks is needed to guarantee their alignment, complementarity and efficient implementation with minimal burden on stakeholders.

Table 12 Summary of the findings on coherence

INSPIRE is legally coherent with environmental legislation with geospatial reporting obligations and with other relevant areas of EU policy with geospatial reporting obligations. In practice however, data specifications are not yet fully aligned, leading to instances of duplication of reporting processes.

The INSPIRE Directive has been designed to be consistent with the EU legal framework on data sharing and dissemination and can support implementation of the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive and the Open Data Directive. Synergies between the three Directives could however be better exploited, in particular, INSPIRE can be useful in support of improving dissemination of information under other aforementioned two Directives.

Coherence issues between the INSPIRE Directive and the Open Data Directive might however arise in the future and could require aligning INSPIRE with the open data legal framework.

INSPIRE is internally coherent, however, the implementing rules are outdated with regards to Articles 290 and 291 of the Lisbon Treaty on Delegated and Implementing Acts.

5.5.EU Added Value

5.5.1.What is the EU-added value of INSPIRE in comparison to what could be achieved at Member States national and/or regional level activities?

The evaluation showed that due to the incomplete implementation of the INSPIRE Directive the full potential of its EU added value has not materialized yet. However, significant EU added value of the Directive could be achieved through its effective positioning in the emerging European data governance landscape and its potential to become a key driver for the Green Deal data space.

This evaluation had more possibilities to assess the EU added value than was possible in the mid-term evaluation, as the INSPIRE implementation deadlines are now mostly in the past. Nevertheless, the evaluation showed that due to the incomplete implementation of the INSPIRE Directive the full potential of the EU added value has not materialized yet. The evaluation indicated that there is an EU added value potential that would likely not have been possible in the absence of the Directive. For example, for policy makers in terms of environmental reporting, optimization of national data management and data policies, the gains from the improved interoperability with others and the creation of EU level expertise. However, it must be noted that its EU added value in relation to standardisation, cross-border and cross-sector data sharing and collaboration was recognised by several sectoral stakeholders. On the other hand, the EU added value for common users has not been fully recognised so far.

Significant EU added value of the Directive could be achieved through its effective positioning in the emerging European data governance landscape and its potential to become a key driver for the Green Deal data space.

Furthermore, the link between existing Environmental Information Systems and national INSPIRE portals could be strengthened. (see also 5.2.6 and 5.4.4) to improve the connection between the environmental information platforms and INSPIRE and streamline approaches for sharing environmental data under the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive and the INSPIRE Directive.

EU added value for different users

User needs are changing over time and the user landscape is broadening. The Directive itself has not put much emphasis on users and their needs and mainly acts from the policy maker perspective. In this context the EU added value stemming from the INSPIRE Directive is mostly linked to the optimization of national data management and data policies, the gains from the improved interoperability with others (e.g. cross-border and cross-sector data sharing) and the creation of the EU level expertise.

The midterm evaluation lists the progress in terms of more effective sharing of information of spatial data between public authorities and across borders due to the reduction of internal obstacles, following the simplification and harmonisation of data policies, licences and establishment of technical infrastructure. 124 Thus, the discovery, access and use of data had become easier and several countries reported efficiency gains in the midterm evaluation. 125 The optimization of internal data management in public administration is considered as an important benefit, as it has led to: 126

·operating of resources through metadata,

·a lesser duplication of data between organisations,

·the use of services for internal purposes,

·establishing of identification patterns based on Uniform Resource Identifier (IRU),

·reinforcing the e-Government initiatives and making data available for private actors and citizens,

·supporting open data developments.

When considering the national level, a clear benefit is the establishment of an efficient governance structure, bringing together various stakeholders and giving them clear roles based on their existing data responsibilities. A better collaboration has been achieved between public authorities, including between different levels of government (e.g. sub-national). 127  

Furthermore, additional EU added value as acknowledged by the midterm evaluation relates to the EU level expertise and knowledge pool generated, by bringing together experts from the Member States through the coordinated development of the implementing provisions and the Maintenance and Implementation support work programme. 128 This and numerous other platforms of collaboration have led to a number of solutions and a development of reusable tools, sharing of good practices, an improved common understanding and the possibility to learn from each other, achievements that would likely not have been made in the absence of EU level actions.

When considering other types of users across different sectors that may reap the benefits of the INSPIRE Directive (e.g. companies, small businesses, citizens), the EU added value is difficult to determine. There is no systematic monitoring of users (see also 5.2.7, 5.2.8, 5.2.9) and as such there is no evidence of the effects of the Directive on various users. However, several positive examples of benefits found in this evaluation are noteworthy (see the efficiency assessment). Furthermore, the use of the INSPIRE-related data sets by a wider community of common users is hampered due to the lack of user-friendly information products affecting the availability of end-user applications (see also 5.3.3).

EU added value in terms of cross-domain and cross-border collaboration

Interoperability is one of the biggest achievements of INSPIRE and is important because it allows cross-domain and cross-border usage of geospatial data in Europe. 129 The assessment of efficiency (see 5.3.1) confirmed that harmonisation and interoperability is one of the main benefits. INSPIRE benefits also public access to environmental information, as it establishes standards in order to ensure that the appropriate services are in place to share data in an appropriate quality. In many cases INSPIRE establishes standards for other instruments that deal with data sharing, transparency and open data. Examples of combining data from multiple domains include environmental impact assessments 130 , natural hazards and disaster reduction. 131  

When it comes to cross-border collaboration outside the environment policy domains, the existing literature provides limited evidence on the EU added value. Due to the incomplete implementation of the INSPIRE Directive up to date, the EU added value in terms of cross-border collaboration is also limited. Some examples of cross-border collaborations were collected and are presented in  Table 13 .

Table 13 Examples of cross border collaboration

An Interreg project connecting inter alia the French Région Provence Alpes Côte d'Azur and the Italian region Valle d’Aosta as regards the harmonisation related to natural risks 132 ; a project funded by DG CNECT involving stakeholders from Slovenia and Italy to create common structure related to landslide and floods risks; an Interreg project (Harmo-Data) involving Slovenia and two Italian regions (Veneto region, Friuli-Venezia Giulia region) to establish a common approach to some aspects of mobility and transport 133 .

EU added value stemming from a broader legislative context in the field of data governance and Digital Single Market

Another important EU-added value stemming from the INSPIRE Directive relates to the effective contribution to the creation of the Digital Single Market by unlocking public data. 134 Besides the INSPIRE Directive, there are other initiatives in the context of the Digital Single Market, forming the European data governance landscape, which are also expected to contribute to the implementation of the INSPIRE Directive (e.g. the European Interoperability Framework, European Data Strategy, revised Open Data and PSI Directive introducing the concept of High Value Data Sets, upcoming Data Governance Act). As shown in the coherence analysis (see 5.4.5), some of these initiatives such as Open Data Directive serve different purpose than the INSPIRE Directive. Nevertheless, they are complementary and reinforcing each other. The coherence analysis also pointed to the need for a close coordination to ensure coherent future developments, by further aligning the INSPIRE directive with the open data legal framework.

The upcoming Data Governance Act 135 will aim to facilitate data sharing, strengthen mechanisms to increase data availability and data reuse, as well as support the development of common European data spaces in strategic domains (i.e. health, environment, energy, agriculture, mobility, finance, manufacturing, public administration and skills). According to the OECD data from 2019, data sharing can “generate social and economic benefits worth between 0.1% and 1.5% of GDP in the case of public-sector data, and between 1% and 2.5% of GDP (in a few studies up to 4% of GDP) when also including private-sector”. 136 In order to unlock these potentials, the Impact Assessment on enhancing the use of data in Europe among others includes looks into options to establish a European structure for governance aspects of data sharing by meeting the necessary conditions in relation to the agreement and implementation of data standards, metadata standards, data schemes and interoperability principles. 137 Although spatial data is only a small part of all data, it is crucial to keep the INSPIRE Directive aligned with the broader data governance framework in order to achieve the best outcome.

For example, spatial data is becoming an important tool for delivering on the objectives of the European Green Deal. Through the broader accessibility and use of environmental and climate-related spatial data one can better assess and understand the state of the environment and how it affects society and the economy. In this context also citizen science data should be considered as a data source supported by the INSPIRE and the Public Access to Environmental information Directives.

An effective data governance is required to strengthen transparency, underpin evidence-based policy-making and implementation. Due to the fast legislative changes in the field of data and sectoral policies, it is important to ensure a continuous calibration of INSPIRE so it fits in and contributes to the broader data governance landscape.

5.5.2.To what extent do the issues addressed by INSPIRE continue to require action at EU level?

The evaluation confirmed that the demand for harmonised data has been growing, e.g. for ensuring an effective response to cross-border challenges such as climate change adaptation and natural disasters. A vast majority of respondents to the targeted surveys indicated that further action is required at EU level.

The aim of INSPIRE is to produce harmonized national datasets which can be used at cross-border and transnational levels thus facilitating the development of pan-European datasets, 138 and thereby providing a response to a need for relevant data to support effective environmental policy making and beyond. Even today, as climate change and natural disasters are extending across borders, the mitigation of such impacts and support to sustainable development should be accompanied by sharing of information and spatial data across organisations and borders. 139  INSPIRE is also beneficial for improving the quality of environmental information made available to the public, based on its relevant requirements on metadata, services and interoperability.

The evaluation confirmed that the demand for harmonised data – by multiple stakeholders, such as policy-makers, business, and ordinary citizens - has been growing, e.g. for ensuring an effective response to cross-border challenges such as climate change and natural disasters. A majority of respondents to the targeted surveys (106 out of 139 respondents from the agriculture, environment, spatial data and marine sectors; 79%) indicated that action is required at EU level to least some extent or even to a large or very large extent.

Table 14 Summary of the findings on EU added value

The added value of the Directive mainly consists of promoting data sharing as a common principle, the establishment of governance structures, achieving interoperability in a broader scope (EU-wide), unlocking public data, improving transparency and creating a pool of EU level expertise.

Important EU added value of the Directive can be maintained and further enhanced through its effective positioning in the emerging European data governance landscape and to become one of the key drivers of the upcoming Green Deal data space also supporting a higher level of transparency.

6.Conclusions

The INSPIRE Directive aimed to deliver an EU infrastructure for spatial information by the end of 2021 based on interoperable infrastructures in the Member States and useable in an EU and trans-boundary context. The Directive is not an end in itself, but is a crucial framework for data management in the EU and in the Member States. The Directive was adopted in 2007, with the aim to bring order to a fast growing field of data; often incomparable, inaccessible or otherwise of no practical use at a reasonable administrative cost. The Directive was conceived as an environmental policy instrument, but its value also has grown more broadly in recent years, notably for the following reasons:

·The volume of data has increased substantially, which provides significant opportunities for better policies, implementation, environmental protection and commercial applications. However, these benefits only occur if data are sifted, comparable and available in useful formats;

·Today’s societal challenges call for cross-cutting interventions and many EU policies are so interwoven that new policies must inevitably aim to achieve multiple objectives c.f. the European Green Deal. This also calls for better data sharing to underpin better policy at less cost;

·A modern economy depends increasingly on data and, as highlighted in the EU digital strategy, INSPIRE is a key instrument.

This evaluation’s evidence and much of the analysis builds on a high-quality external contractor’s report, which includes information from written sources, stakeholder interviews and a public consultation. The overall conclusion drawn from this analysis is that the objectives of INSPIRE remains relevant, that the Directive has EU added value, it is partially effective given implementation challenges within its original limits, but these scope limits are not fully coherent with the European Green Deal or Digital policy needs. Finally, INSPIRE can be improved in terms of efficiency and is notably hampered by a combination of complex technical (standards) requirements and a too ambitious scope in terms of certain data requested beyond what Member States have been able to provide.

There was also a need to take stock of the experiences gained in the implementation of INSPIRE and its coherence with other relevant instruments notably the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive. The evaluation found that the two complimentary Directives are formally coherent, but the latter Directive is weakened by pre-dating INSPIRE and not anticipating better availability of digital data in the environmental area for the public, other authorities or businesses.

6.1.Conclusions in details

Overall, the implementation of the INSPIRE Directive has matured compared to the 2014 baseline and has lead to an increased availability and better access to spatial data and services. Although progress was made towards meeting the Directive's main and specific goals, the implementation is incomplete and heterogeneous across Europe. Realisation of the Directive's full potential will depend upon improved implementation. No single Member State has yet achieved full implementation in alignment with the roadmap and several Member States lag behind.

In recent years, Member States and the EEA/EFTA countries are removing data sets that have not been harmonised with the interoperable data specifications (often richer data sets following non-INSPIRE data specifications) to improve their overall monitored implementation performance. There has also been data cleaning/aggregating processes at national or regional level. As an effect, there were fewer data sets available in 2020 than reported in previous years.

Recommendations put forward in the INSPIRE midterm evaluation for the Member States have to some extent been implemented. The Member States increased the overall availability of environmental priority data sets according to one of the recommendations. In terms of coordination between the national INSPIRE implementation and other relevant sectors and administrations (e.g. eGovernment, open data, environment, marine, mobility, agriculture), there are some linkages in terms of logistical work and cooperation. Nevertheless, it is mostly considered that these initiatives are not contradicting the main principles of the INSPIRE Directive, and that in some cases, the national data policies benefit from its implementation by facilitating an environment of free and open data. A coherent and effective legal and operational framework for sharing spatial data and services across the EU has not yet fully been established. In particular the legal arrangements for data sharing, such as data policies, are still too complex and/or too heterogeneous in many Member States to be effective.

The INSPIRE monitoring indicators are generally low. Around half of available data sets are not yet accessible across the EU Member States and EEA/EFTA countries. In general, there is a low conformity of metadata for spatial data sets and spatial data services (less than 60%). Half of all listed data sets are in conformity with relevant legislation as regards the interoperability of spatial data sets. The conformity of network services has improved since 2019, but several countries still offer only a few interoperable network services.

The low average values of the INSPIRE indicators in reference years 2019 and 2020 are not fully surprising. Commission Decision (EU) 2019/1372 introduced significant changes to their calculation in 2019. The new automated approach is based on the processing of all metadata harvested from countries discovery services and entails a validation of the provisions on metadata, network services and data specifications that is stricter and more comparable than the previous self-declared assessments. The new approach has initially led to decreasing performance indicators in 2019 but already showed a positive trend in most countries in 2020, indicating that the automated approach is helping countries improve the maturity of their INSPIRE implementation.

6.2.Relevance 

Although the objectives of the INSPIRE Directive are still very relevant and further action is required at the EU level to address the identified obstacles, the legal framework can be improved in terms of effectiveness.

To remain relevant and support the Green Deal ambitions by bringing environmental data into the Green Deal data space, the INSPIRE Directive and relevant provisions of the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive need to better consider evolving technology and information requirements.

The evaluation demonstrates that public authorities have a need for spatial data for the different phases of their policy-making (design of policy, implementation of policy, monitoring of policy and assessment of results and effects). INSPIRE addresses these needs and justifies an action at EU level. As regards actors outside of the public domain, although their needs have not been precisely assessed and identified, the reasoning is that if spatial data are made available and accessible they would be used and dedicated services would be developed. However, at this stage, the evidence to support this causality is scarce.

Regarding barriers for sharing and accessing spatial data, the INSPIRE Directive is considered as a relevant intervention to overcome them and thereby make data available, accessible, and reusable.

INSPIRE establishes a framework for sharing relevant spatial data within the European Union for users and applications in the environmental domain. The evaluation concluded that current technical requirements constitute a barrier to its implementation and use. More specifically, the objective of harmonisation and interoperability within the INSPIRE framework entails technical specificities that were ground-breaking at the time of its entering into force, but have shown to be too prescriptive and rigid to be fit-for-the-future in the context of evolving information requirements, standards and technologies. Within the Local Digital Twins environment a first approach has been launched by the Living-in.EU community through the Minimum Interoperability Mechanism (MIM) number 7, which should be considered due to its future evolution to the standardization bodies.

The evaluation did not find any inconsistencies between the INSPIRE Directive and the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive. The INSPIRE Directive has been designed to be consistent with the EU legal framework on data sharing and dissemination and could further support the implementation of active and systematic dissemination of environmental information to the public and become a key instrument for populating the Green Deal data space.

6.3.Effectiveness 

Member States have progressed in the implementation of the Directive. Still, no Member State has achieved full implementation yet, with significant implementation gaps remaining.

The INSPIRE Directive’s objective for interoperability has not been met because of the (limited) geographical coverage achieved so far.

The implementation of the INSPIRE Directive as well as the sharing and reuse of existing spatial data still face barriers already identified in the previous evaluation of the Directive. These barriers are primarily of a technical nature.

The different ways that Member States can describe the same data limits cross-border application. It requires extra effort to align standards as has been done by the marine community through EMODnet.

Several EU Member States provide INSPIRE datasets and services as a standalone activity that is only marginally linked to the national infrastructure, often supplying access to only a subset of the rich spatial data available in national catalogues and limiting the usefulness and effectiveness of INSPIRE. The use of datasets and services through the INSPIRE framework is developing both in a data-sharing and active dissemination context. However, Member States’ additional efforts would be needed to increase the use of the INSPIRE framework – be it for EU level, national or regional purposes. Revising INSPIRE and the Public Access to Information Directive should be considered to improve its effectiveness and as a result their implementation.

As of June 2021, and close to the last deadline set for implementing the INSPIRE Directive (December 2021), overall progress at Member States level was observed but full implementation is not yet achieved.

The geographical coverage of the implementation of the INSPIRE Directive is uneven across Member States, and at national and regional level. The heterogeneity of datasets that are made available by Member States affect the capacity to combine data from different regions and different Member States. The combination of these facts explain why more work is needed to achieve the INSPIRE Directive's ambition of cross-border interoperability.

The implementation of the Directive as well as the sharing and reuse of existing spatial information has progressed since the last evaluation. However, the technical complexity of the framework required by INSPIRE remains a challenge with impacts on implementation as well as to the use of the infrastructure. Another important remaining barrier lies in the heterogeneous licensing conditions which hampers the reuse of data. Other identified barriers (legal, knowledge, financial, cooperation and organization) were generally not regarded as an implementation bottleneck by the consulted stakeholders for the implementation and use of the INSPIRE framework.

Some Member States have implemented INSPIRE in parallel to a national spatial data infrastructure to satisfy their INSPIRE obligations. More and richer non-harmonised data sets are often being made available through the national infrastructure while a limited offering satisfying the more complex technical and interoperability specifications is published on the INSPIRE Geoportal. Consequently, the data-richer national infrastructures are favoured by end-users. The technical complexity, embedded in the current Directive, seemed appropriate in 2007 when the Directive was adopted. Today, there is a need to modernise it.

There has been progress in use for reporting and efforts have been deployed to align effectively INSPIRE to EU reporting requirements. The results of these efforts are welcomed by Member States, as the main effect of INSPIRE at the EU policy level for the moment. Yet, the evaluation was not conclusive on the use of the INSPIRE framework for reporting under the environmental acquis and for policy making in the field of environment in general. Since the low level of permeation of the INSPIRE Directive at regional and local level, evidence on the use of the infrastructure on these administrative levels is limited.

INSPIRE does not require Member States to monitor the use of the INSPIRE infrastructure, neither was the directive originally put in place to provide private parties with data. However, as access to and use of data have become more important in today’s data economy this aspect has been included in the evaluation. Even if not part of INSPIRE’s original objectives, the evaluation also looked at effects on users active in economic sectors influencing environment, including small businesses using spatial data. Data from the INSPIRE infrastructure is only to a limited extent used by users other than national public authorities and agencies.

6.4.Efficiency

INSPIRE facilitates the work of stakeholders in the area of spatial data provision through improved discoverability, availability and accessibility to spatial data.

Interoperability (of data and services) is the most important cost factor in the INSPIRE implementation.

There is a simplification potential of the implementation in terms of addressing the requirement for interoperability.

The results achieved so far are commensurate with the resources put forward and are in line with the ones expected from the ex-ante evaluation of INSPIRE in observed cases. However, implementation is not yet complete and hence results cannot be fully assessed yet.

Stakeholders perceive the costs as 'asymmetrical'. Most costs relate to the implementation of the Directive and are largely borne by national governments, but differ significantly in function of how INSPIRE has been implemented notably if it is part of or independent from SDI. A proportion of these costs can therefore not necessarily be attributed to the Directive as such. Users of the spatial data infrastructure do not perceive extraordinary costs.

In most cases, the resources for implementation were available, but some Member States have perceived it as a challenge to secure the resources. In these Member States, costs have been perceived as higher.

The INSPIRE Directive has proven to be a valuable instrument to achieve legal interoperability by streamlining concepts and reporting provisions across different environmental acts (e.g. on environmental emissions).

The INSPIRE Directive can support the implementation of the Public Access to Information Directive by providing a technical framework for electronic data sharing.

While the INSPIRE Directive performs satisfactorily at making geospatial environmental data accessible, simplification, modernisation and future-proofing would mitigate the challenges linked to the costs of implementing the Directive.

Despite the fact that the implementation of INSPIRE is not complete, the benefits are beginning to emerge and have contributed to improving the operational efficiency of concerned stakeholders. The key direct benefits are experienced by stakeholders in regards to better discoverability, availability, accessibility of data and especially harmonisation and interoperability. In Member States where data were previously stored in many different formats and some of these formats were not readable using the most common GIS systems, creating services and formats that can be used by all users is one of the most important benefits.

In terms of indirect benefits, two factors were pointed to most significantly by Member States: openness to share spatial data by providers and national infrastructures and development of national geoportals. Overall, this suggests that INSPIRE has been instrumental in furthering the development of the national geoportals as well as in promoting an increased sharing of data.

Interoperability of spatial data and services is one of the key benefits of INSPIRE. Mirroring this however, these are also the costliest elements of implementation. This relates both to financial costs and human resource/expertise needs mainly in national governments. The activities that are necessary to achieve coherent, consistent and harmonised data sets that adhere to shared data models on a national level and at a pan-European level are perceived as costs intensive. The evidence gathered in the evaluation confirms that interoperability of data (harmonising data with the INSPIRE data specifications) and services are the main cost drivers. For users (who are not also producers), the majority perceives that there are no additional costs, and if there are, these relate to purchasing additional or new software to access/use the spatial data.

The evaluation shows that it is difficult to point to specific provisions which would make the INSPIRE implementation more cost-efficient. This largely depends on the institution and/or administrative level in question. The costs of implementation are also influenced by the approach taken by the individual Member States to INSPIRE implementation. The INSPIRE Directive might be implemented as an integral part of the national SDI as originally intended or implemented as a separate system. The latter can lead to disjoined data foundation and/or separate IT-infrastructure which again influences the cost (and the perceived value) of INSPIRE. Further, Member States that implement INSPIRE as a separate system, in parallel to the national SDI, may tend to perceive the harmonization linked to INSPIRE as more costly and/or invoking additional costs. Member States that implement INSPIRE as part of the national SDI system cannot in general identify the costs. This suggest that the activities are integrated in these situations.

Different stakeholders in Member States also have different perceptions on costs and benefits depending on whether they are spatial data providers or spatial data users, their administrative level or specific type of stakeholder.

The evaluation identified that further efficiency measures may happen at two levels: A) Simplifying the implementation and thereby reducing costs of harmonisation and enabling interoperability and B) align with other digital processes and making use and data reuse easier. The latter may not necessarily lead to reduced cost but to an increased use. Further, increasing the correspondence between national SDI and INSPIRE will not only reduce cost but also increase the value of national SDI data that is more targeted for specific use cases.

Users perceive that data models and the way data is available is too complicated for a number of users. Different types of users have different needs regarding data models: Advanced users might need quite complex data structures for the data to match their needs - but using data models with this complexity will be a burden to other users with simpler needs. INSPIRE specifies data models for each data theme covered by INSPIRE, which cover the combined needs from the most advanced users.

A limited number of cost-benefit assessments of the implementation of INSPIRE are available supplementing those that were included in the 2016 mid-term evaluation. Most of those focus on the benefits of an SDI in general (and not specifically on INSPIRE). Overall, they conclude that the benefits of a national SDI by far outweigh the costs. The reviewed Cost Benefit Analysis found that when the SDI is implemented this has a large positive impact/benefit for both the public (cost savings) and private sector (costs savings and business opportunities). However, a number of Member States found that it is too early to really assess the costs and benefits of INSPIRE, especially as INSPIRE is not fully implemented yet.

Overall, national authorities and agencies are the stakeholders who bear the biggest share of the cost and where less of the (direct) benefits are expected to fall. Depending on the administrative structure of the Member State and of the responsibilities allocated, the cost distribution can vary considerably between Member States. In countries with a federal structure, some implementation responsibilities may lie at subnational level. The main costs identified by national and local level institutions relate to the production and harmonization of data and data services.

Member States have applied different ways of funding the implementation of INSPIRE. In most cases, INSPIRE implementation has been funded as part of the budget allocation for the institution in question (with some difference in terms of which costs are carried by the different government levels, mostly the funding is provided by the national level government (state budget)). Some Member States have also used funding via European Structural Investment Funds (ESIF).

For some Member States the key problem is not the availability of resources (capacity), but the availability of the required expertise (competence). Many different institutions can be involved in the implementation of INSPIRE, which further complicates its implementation.

Environmental authorities to some extent make use of the spatial data that are made available through INSPIRE. It is noted that this does not necessarily reflect on the reporting burden. More work in terms of making it technically more efficient will be needed before INSPIRE can really support the reduction of the administrative burden for the reporting under the environmental acquis.

There are no inconsistencies between the INSPIRE Directive and the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive. The two Directives have different scopes (despite some overlap), but have a very important common element, namely active dissemination of information to the public. INSPIRE being the more advanced of the two, can support the implementation of the Public Access to Information Directive by providing a technical framework for electronic data sharing. Stakeholders perceive that INSPIRE supports the implementation of the Public Access to Information Directive by improving the capacity of stakeholders to provide spatial data, which should have an effect on the administrative burden also by potentially avoiding duplication of efforts in implementation.

6.5.Coherence

INSPIRE is legally coherent with environmental legislation with geospatial reporting obligations and with other relevant areas of EU policy with geospatial reporting obligations. In practice however, data specifications are not yet fully aligned, leading to instances of duplication of reporting processes.

The INSPIRE Directive has been designed to be consistent with the EU legal framework on data sharing and dissemination and can support implementation of the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive and the Open Data Directive. Synergies between the three Directives could however be better exploited, in particular, INSPIRE can be useful in support of improving dissemination of information under other aforementioned two Directives.

Coherence issues between the INSPIRE Directive and the Open Data Directive might however arise in the future and could require aligning INSPIRE with the open data legal framework.

INSPIRE is internally coherent, however, the implementing rules are outdated with regards to Articles 290 and 291 of the Lisbon Treaty on Delegated and Implementing Acts.

Although INSPIRE consists of several layers of rules and technical guidance, with different statuses and revision procedures, the evaluation presented no instances of incoherence. However, identified overlaps by stakeholders between data themes in the Annexes of the INSPIRE Directive should be resolved in the relevant technical expert groups. Revision procedures applied to Implementing Rules may also appear cumbersome for the revision of technical elements. Aligning the comitology procedures referred to in the INSPIRE Directive to the Lisbon treaty might lead to more flexible revision procedures.

INSPIRE applies to all environmental policies and other policies or activities which may have an impact on the environment. A review of the relevant EU legislation did not find provisions that would potentially impede the applicability of INSPIRE rules within the scope of the legislation. In fact, many pieces of legislation make direct reference to INSPIRE rules and it was found that such references do support compliance in practice.

The evaluation also identified many ongoing initiatives, both from the Commission services/agencies and stakeholders, to develop synergies between INSPIRE and data collection and sharing processes and instruments under other pieces of legislation. In particular in the environmental field of particular relevance is the ongoing work to align reporting obligations in EU environmental legislation with INSPIRE rules. Such initiatives are supported by reporting guidance and increased cooperation between sectoral authorities and authorities responsible for INSPIRE both at EU and national level. However, stakeholders stressed that environmental reporting obligations are not yet fully coherent with INSPIRE, both in terms of data content and models. Similar comments were made in relation to non-environmental policy areas. Such situations may lead to duplication of data processing and dissemination efforts.

Alignment initiatives are especially relevant in the context of the recently announced ambition to develop common European data spaces, in particular the Green Deal data space, as INSPIRE could become an important instrument for building these data spaces. Some of these initiatives (for instance in the transport sector) also show that INSPIRE services, as they are, cannot satisfy all data needs in all sectors. Some current developments, such as the new Climate Adaptation Strategy, point to a need for a possible expansion of the scope of INSPIRE to be more in line with sectoral data needs.

In the case of the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive, there are limited synergies with INSPIRE. Public Access to Environmental Information Directive, which requires the dissemination of environmental information held by public authorities, including through electronic means, does not refer to INSPIRE rules for disseminating geospatial data covered by Article 7(e), or to the open data framework (formerly PSI Directive, now Open Data Directive). The Directive is in this regard outdated and could benefit from stronger alignment with INSPIRE.

The evaluation has identified a possible need for alignment in relation to the Open Data Directive and the upcoming implementing Regulation on High Value Datasets to serve a general and consistent purpose (the Green Deal). Moreover, provisions in Articles 13, 14 and 17 of the INSPIRE Directive provide ample possibilities to limit public access to spatial data, and to license and/or require payment for spatial datasets and services. Given the evolution of the legal framework on open data, alignment of these Articles in the INSPIRE Directive with the open data legal framework might be considered in the future.

Although the Open Data Directive does not set legal obligations in terms of technical standards or data format and makes several references to INSPIRE, it will nonetheless be crucial to ensure that future developments, supporting guidance, and recommendations for both directives remain compatible.

6.6.EU added value

The added value of the Directive mainly consists of promoting data sharing as a common principle, the establishment of governance structures, achieving interoperability in a broader scope (EU-wide), unlocking public data, improving transparency and creating a pool of EU level expertise.

Important EU added value of the Directive can be maintained and further enhanced through its effective positioning in the emerging European data governance landscape and to become one of the key drivers of the upcoming Green Deal data space also supporting a higher level of transparency.

Due to the on-going implementation of the INSPIRE Directive, the EU added value has been not fully realised so far. The EU added value of the Directive as acknowledged by the majority of stakeholders relates mostly to the policy-making and implementation purposes at national and European level. One of the key benefits concerns the environmental reporting by the Member States. At a national level, the Directive has led to EU added value through the establishment of governance structures, achieving interoperability in a broader scope (EU-wide), unlocking public data, improving transparency and creating a pool of EU level expertise. The EU added value of the Directive in terms of data sharing is limited when it comes to benefits for users outside the policy-making field and could be further exploited, e.g. by providing more user-friendly applications. Cross-border collaboration is not always smooth due to technical challenges. Nevertheless, the stakeholders in the targeted survey agree that EU-wide data sharing and cross-border collaboration has improved due to the INSPIRE Directive.

Environmental and climate-related spatial data is becoming an important tool for delivering on the objectives of the European Green Deal, which is also acknowledged in the European Strategy for Data by putting forward the GreenData4all initiative. Interoperable data of high quality is crucial to ensure informed and evidence-based policy making and implementation. INSPIRE-relevant data must be aligned with other data policy initiatives in order to achieve its full potential at the European level. A close collaboration between policy makers and other relevant stakeholders is crucial in shaping future developments.

INSPIRE benefits also public access to environmental information, as it establishes standards in order to ensure that the data services are in place to share data in an appropriate quality. This can be considered as a standard for other instruments that deal with data sharing, transparency and open data. Coherence between various initiatives and instruments is key for developing the Green Deal data space. In this context also citizen science data should be considered as data source for the Green Deal data space, supported by the INSPIRE and the Public Access to Environmental information Directives.

The demand for harmonised data has been growing in Europe, especially for ensuring an effective response to cross-border challenges such as climate change and natural disasters. Most of the stakeholders acknowledge that the action is required at EU level and that the rationale behind and the principles of the INSPIRE Directive are justified.

6.7.Lessons Learned

There are lessons to be learned from the past fourteen years of application of the INSPIRE Directive since its entry into force. Despite the obvious issues and difficulties triggered by the process, the INSPIRE Directive has been, and still is today, seen as a reference example by many countries and organisations all over the world that intend to establish Spatial Data Infrastructures from the local to the national and international level. During these 14 years, the context around geospatial data sharing across Europe has radically changed, as a consequence of both a non-stop, disruptive technological innovation in standards and technical approaches, and a new European political framework. The new policies put data and data sharing at the centre of the digital transformation to address urgent societal and environmental challenges. The European Green Deal recognised the potential of digitalisation and the availability of data as essential enablers of the changes needed for a just, green transition. The European Strategy for Data announced a common European Green Deal data space, to use the major potential of data in support of the Green Deal priority actions on climate change, circular economy, zero-pollution, biodiversity, deforestation and compliance assurance.

The previous and current evaluation of the INSPIRE Directive confirmed that the overarching vision for a European spatial data infrastructure for the purposes of EU's environmental policies as well as policies or activities which have an impact on the environment is still very relevant in view of the European Green Deal and Digital strategies. The ambition to promote data sharing and put in place easy-to-use, transparent, interoperable spatial data services which are used in the daily work of environmental and other policy makers and policy implementers across the EU at all levels of governance as well as businesses, science and citizens is well aligned with the objectives of the European Strategy for Data.

The evaluations and stakeholder workshops helped to identify lessons learned and issues that should be addressed to enable full implementation of the Directive. This has given direction and guidance to a set of recommendations for the future development of the legal framework.

Remaining implementation gaps in Member States should be closed to optimise the reuse of spatial data and facilitate its pan-European use. The further implementation of the INSPIRE Directive should be user-driven by a common demand across administrative levels to improve the EU added value of the infrastructure and its cost-benefit balance.

Many EU Member States share only a limited number of datasets within the INSPIRE infrastructure with a varying offering, making it difficult to achieve pan-European coverage for specific themes. In many cases, the INSPIRE infrastructure is a standalone effort, implemented in parallel and only indirectly linked to the national spatial data infrastructures and portals that serve identified national use cases. This is because INSPIRE requirements are different, more limited or go beyond the requirements adopted at the national level.

Despite the remaining implementation gaps, the INSPIRE Directive has proven to be a particularly useful framework for improving the discoverability of existing spatial data through the compilation and exposure of metadata, as well as the accessibility through the implementation of download services. The implementation should be continued and further streamlined to achieve a common level of comparable technical maturity and data offering across countries that supports regional, national, trans-boundary and pan-European use cases, maximally building on existing national initiatives.

The legal framework needs to be technology neutral and future proof. Implementers should have the option and the freedom to deploy cost-effective off-the-shelf tools that apply state of the art technology to share data in a user-friendly way. 140  

In the conceptualisation of the INSPIRE Directive and its implementing acts, it was assumed in multiple cases that technical requirements which were during the scoping stage not supported by existing software tools, would be implemented once the acts would enter into force. Unfortunately, this rarely happened.

The implementation of the INSPIRE Directive is based on several crosscutting and domain-specific standards (e.g. from ISO and OGC). The implementation of the Directive has led to probably the largest uptake of the OGC standards worldwide. However, at the same time the strong, formal utilisation of particular standards has slowed down the implementation process. From that perspective, it is critically important to ensure that mature and well-supported standards are considered for the technical provisions related to the evolution of INSPIRE.

It is essential that the technical requirements put forward by INSPIRE are easy to implement, do not disrupt data providers technology stacks and promote usage by a broad community of stakeholders. Leveraging on out-of-the-box solutions and standards should therefore be the default approach for all technical developments.

The need was identified for more work on standardising data reuse conditions and licensing. 141  

INSPIRE was conceptualised with an inclusive and open approach in mind. In fact, collaboration on multiple levels between a broad spectrum of users is critical to the overall success of the implementation.

The licensing approaches, based on the metadata made available by EU Member States, are very heterogeneous. Even more substantially, in a vast majority of cases, licensing information is not available at all. This lack of consistency and the absence of harmonisation poses a serious obstacle to the uptake and reusability of the data.

The effectiveness and efficiency of the INSPIRE Directive and the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive are insufficient if they are to be enabling instruments for implementing data sharing in Europe and building a Common European Green Deal data space. Dealing proactively with new requirements coming from the twin digital and green transition and possible coherence issues with recent and emerging EU data legislation (Open Data Directive and its implementing Regulation on High Value datasets, Data Governance Act, Data Act) by aligning the existing legislative framework and implementation guidance could prevent or minimize implementation burden on the Member States.

To boost the relevance and added value of the INSPIRE Directive for supporting the dual digital and green transition and achieving the objectives of the European Green Deal and the Green Deal Data Space:

-the current interoperability and technical provisions should make better use of contemporary and state-of –the-art digital technology;

-and new data sources could be considered ( IoT 142 data, citizen-generated data, data from the private sector, open research data …) beyond the current spatial data scope to better address information needs of a larger stakeholder community. 

The existing Maintenance and Implementation Framework (MIF) governance structure with its technical and policy arms ensures that the different organisational, legal and technical questions are being addressed by the right fora. However, this governance structure has not always been flexible and fast in accommodating novelties and responding to changing user requirements.

(1)     Regulation (EU) 2019/1010 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 5 June 2019 on the alignment of reporting obligations in the field of legislation related to the environment
(2)      Commission Report (COM(2016)478/2) and Staff Working Document on the midterm evaluation of the INSPIRE Directive (SWD(2016)273))
(3)      See Textbox 1 - What are spatial data?
(4)      See Textbox 2 - What is a spatial data infrastructure?
(5)       https://ec.europa.eu/digital-single-market
(6)       https://ec.europa.eu/digital-single-market/en/news/infographic-egovernment-action-plan-2016-2020-glance
(7)      Council Decision 2005/370/EC - https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dec/2005/370/oj  
(8)      Citizen science is scientific research conducted, in whole or in part, by amateur (or nonprofessional) scientists whose outcomes often provide advancements in scientific research, as well as an increase in the public's understanding of science.
(9)       https://ec.europa.eu/info/strategy/priorities-2019-2024/european-green-deal_en  
(10)      COM(2020) 64 final, Shaping Europe’s digital future - https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:52020DC0064  
(11)      COM(2020) 66 final, A European strategy for data - https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:52020DC0066  
(12)      COM(2020) 65 final, White Paper On Artificial Intelligence - A European approach to excellence and trust - https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=COM:2020:65:FIN  
(13) Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway, Switzerland.
(14) Better Regulation Guidelines Toolbox Tool #47: Evaluation Criteria and questions.
(15) COWI A/S, Milieu, Technopolis Group, (2021) ‘Support to the evaluation of the implementation of the Directive 2007/2/EC on Infrastructure for Spatial Information in the European Community (INSPIRE)’
(16)      Commission Communication " A sustainable Europe for a better world: A European strategy for Sustainable Development " (COM(2001) 264)
(17)       2009 Review of the EU Sustainable Development Strategy COM (2009) 400
(18)      Decision No 1600/2002/EC (6th EAP), DECISION No 1386/2013/EU (7th EAP), COM(2020) 652 final (proposal 8th EAP)
(19)      Integrated across policy and economic sectors
(20)      COM(2004)516
(21) INSPIRE Directive Article 3(2), definition of 'spatial data': 'any data with a direct or indirect reference to a specific location or geographical area'. For example: spatial data can be a polygon with coordinates defining the borders of a protected site, the exact location of a point of emission into the environment, the borders of an industrial site, facility, building or an administrative unit. But it can also be data collected on species occurring within and referenced to such a protected site or the measurements taken by a sensor at the point of emission, it can be administrative data related to an industrial facility or statistical data related to the geographical area of the administrative unit such as for example, population density or a value describing the air quality at such a location during a certain period.
(22)      For further illustration, see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xew6qI-6wNk
(23)      Gaps in spatial data availability; Duplication of data collection efforts, even within organisations; Non-harmonised spatial data which made it difficult to combine and to integrate data in applications; Lack of documentation, which made it difficult for potential users to assess whether the data were “fit for use”; Data were difficult to find and not easy to access, with often many and complex procedures and agreements to be established before access is given or before data are obtained; Data are often expensive;
(24)      INSPIRE Directive preamble (5) and Article 1
(25)      E.g. https://www.plumelabs.com/ or https://www.simacan.com or …
(26)      E.g. http://www.directionsmag.com/entry/dutch-kadaster-tackles-european-inspire-initiatives-for-spatial-data-infras/122509 ;
(27)      E.g. https://joinup.ec.europa.eu/node/150019/
(28)      According to the thematic scope defined in the Annexes I, II and III of the Directive and detailed in INSPIRE - "Data Specifications" –D2.3: Definition of Annex Themes and Scope' , 2008
(29)      Metadata provides structured information allowing the spatial data to be discovered online, to know its origins, the conditions for use and to evaluate its fitness for purpose.
(30)      The Commission is empowered to adopt Common Implementing Rules (IR) in a number of specific areas (Metadata, Data Specifications, Network Services, Data and Service Sharing and Monitoring and Reporting).
(31)      Only the deadline to make invocable spatial data services conformant with Annexes VI and (where practicable) VII of Commission Regulation (EU) No 1089/2010 as regards interoperability of spatial data services was still in the future (deadline 10/12/2021)
(32)       https://inspire.ec.europa.eu/reports/stateofplay2007/INSPIRE-SoP-2007v4.pdf  
(33)      The finalisation was delayed due to extensive analysis that was carried out also as a result of inclusion of the INSPIRE Directive in the REFIT programme.
(34) INSPIRE (2003), Report on the feedback of the Internet consultation on a forthcoming EU initiative establishing a framework for the creation of an Infrastructure for Spatial Information in Europe. Available at: https://inspire.ec.europa.eu/reports/analysis_consultation_01092003.pdf
(35)      OJ L 148, 11.6.2009, p. 18–26
(36)      OJ L 220, 23.8.2019, p. 1–5
(37)      https://inspire.ec.europa.eu/validator
(38)      For a detailed description of all indicators and their calculation see: Minghini, M., Cetl, V., Ziemba, L.W., Tomas, R., Francioli, D., Artasensi, D., Epure, E. and Vinci, F., Establishing a new baseline for monitoring the status of EU Spatial Data Infrastructure, EUR 30513 EN, Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg, 2020, ISBN 978-92-76-27384-4, doi:10.2760/296219, JRC122351.
(39) Cetl V., V. Nunes de Lima, R. Tomas, M. Lutz, J. D'Eugenio, A. Nagy, J. Robbrecht (2017), Summary Report on Status of implementation of the INSPIRE Directive in EU. EUR 28930 EN. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.
(40)

See Annex 6 for a more detailed view on the implementation maturity across Member States.

(41)      Country summary reports, yearly monitoring data, country fiches are publicly available at https://inspire.ec.europa.eu/INSPIRE-in-your-Country  
(42)      https://inspire-geoportal.ec.europa.eu/
(43)      https://github.com/INSPIRE-MIF/need-driven-data-prioritisation/tree/main/documents 
(44)      Minghini, M., Cetl, V., Ziemba, L.W., Tomas, R., Francioli, D., Artasensi, D., Epure, E. and Vinci, F., Establishing a new baseline for monitoring the status of EU Spatial Data Infrastructure, EUR 30513 EN, Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg, 2020, ISBN 978-92-76-27384-4, doi:10.2760/296219, JRC122351.
(45)      The snapshot uses the data gathered for all countries in the monitoring process in December 2020.
(46)   Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2019/1372 of 19 August 2019 implementing Directive 2007/2/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council as regards monitoring and reporting (notified under document C(2019) 6026)
(47)      https://wikis.ec.europa.eu/x/HZn-AQ
(48)       https://op.europa.eu/en/publication-detail/-/publication/6aa0e08c-d0d9-11ea-adf7-01aa75ed71a1  
(49)       https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/ALL/?uri=celex:32019R1010
(50)   http://ec.europa.eu/transparency/regcomitology/index.cfm?do=search.documentdetail&Dos_ID=16928&ds_id=59505&version=1&page=1
(51)       https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:02010R1089-20131230  
(52)       https://wikis.ec.europa.eu/x/65j-AQ  
(53)      see latest situation at: http://inspire-geoportal.ec.europa.eu/pdv_home.html
(54)       https://inspire.ec.europa.eu/portfolio/inspire-your-country  
(55)      https://inspire.ec.europa.eu/documents/summary-report-status-implementation-inspire-directive-eu
(56)       http://inspire-geoportal.ec.europa.eu/  
(57)      Maintenance and Implementation Work Programme for the INSPIRE Directive for the period from 2021-2024: "Towards a Common European Green Deal data space for environment and sustainability", endorsed at the 12th MIG meeting on 26-27 November 2020. Available at: https://webgate.ec.europa.eu/fpfis/wikis/display/InspireMIG/INSPIRE+work+programme+2021-24
(58)       http://ec.europa.eu/environment/eir/country-reports/index2_en.htm  
(59)      Better Regulation Guidelines Toolbox Tool #47: Evaluation Criteria and questions.
(60)      The methodology is also described in detail in sections 3 and 4 of the supporting study.
(61)      Triangulation is a method used to increase the credibility and validity of research findings.
(62)      Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2019/1372 of 19 August 2019 implementing Directive 2007/2/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council as regards monitoring and reporting (notified under document C(2019) 6026) - https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dec_impl/2019/1372/oj  
(63)      COM(2020) 66 final, ”A Common European Green Deal data space, to use the major potential of data in support of the Green Deal priority actions on climate change, circular economy, zero-pollution, biodiversity, deforestation and compliance assurance. The “GreenData4All” and ‘Destination Earth’ (digital twin of the Earth) initiatives will cover concrete actions.”
(64)      Common European data spaces will ensure that more data becomes available for use in the economy and society, while keeping the companies and individuals who generate the data in control. The European Green Deal data space aims to provide more accessible and exploitable environmental data in support of the European Green Deal priority actions.
(65)      https://eur-lex.europa.eu/procedure/EN/2004_175
(66)      77% of respondents indicated that an action is required at the EU level
(67)      Kotsev A., Minghini M., Cetl V., Penninga F., Robbrecht J., Lutz M., INSPIRE – A Public Sector Contribution to the European Green Deal Data Space. A vision for the technological evolution of Europe’s Spatial Data Infrastructures for 2030, EUR 30832 EN, Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg, 2021, ISBN 978-92-76-41564-0, doi:10.2760/8563, JRC126319.
(68)      Cetl V., V. Nunes de Lima, R. Tomas, M. Lutz, J. D'Eugenio, A. Nagy, J. Robbrecht (2017), Summary Report on Status of implementation of the INSPIRE Directive in EU.
(69)      As data cannot be directly compared across the years due to the changes in the reporting and monitoring system introduced in 2019 and the official performance indicators do not necessary give a full picture of the quality of implementation
(70)      As the coordination structures and data sharing arrangements were not assessed for the EEA/ EFTA countries in 2016, the progress assessment for the relevant countries (NO, LI, CH, IS) is not taken into account.
(71)      European Commission (2016), Report from the Commission to the Council and the European Parliament on the implementation of Directive 2007/2/EC of March 2007 establishing an Infrastructure for Spatial Information in the European Community (INSPIRE) pursuant to article 23 (COM/2016/0478 final/2).
(72)      European Commission (2019), Promotion of good practices for national environmental information systems and tools for data harvesting at EU level. Final Report, drafted by Wageningen University and Research (The Netherlands), Umweltbundesamt GmbH (UBA) (Austria), Epsilon (Greece), COWI (Belgium).
(73)      EEA & JRC (2014), Mid-term evaluation report on INSPIRE implementation, EEA Technical report No 17/2014, ISSN 1725-2237., P.7.
(74)      The Geography Markup Language (GML) is the XML grammar defined by the Open Geospatial Consortium (OGC) to express geographical features. GML serves as a modeling language for geographic systems as well as an open interchange format for geographic transactions on the Internet.
(75)  European Commission (2019), Promotion of good practices for national environmental information systems and tools for data harvesting at EU level. Final Report, drafted by Wageningen University and Research (The Netherlands), Umweltbundesamt GmbH (UBA) (Austria), Epsilon (Greece), COWI (Belgium).
(76)       https://emodnet.ec.europa.eu/en  
(77)      MDI-DE aims to provide data and information coming from coastal engineering, coastal protection, marine environmental protection and marine nature protection via a joint internet portal. Metadata and web-services support the search for data and their use. The database helps German administration to fulfill reporting for EU directives like MSFD and INSPIRE.
(78)    ‘The distributed service‑oriented architecture and implementation of INSPIRE services and data models allows serving information on several environmental policies (such as Directive 2008/56/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 17 June 2008 establishing a framework for community action in the field of marine environmental policy’, EEA & JRC (2014).
(79)    Directive 2008/50/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 21 May 2008 on ambient air quality and cleaner air for Europe.
(80)    EEA & JRC (2014), Mid-term evaluation report on INSPIRE implementation, EEA Technical report No 17/2014, ISSN 1725-2237., P.7
(81)       European Commission (2019), Promotion of good practices for national environmental information systems and tools for data harvesting at EU level. Final Report, drafted by Wageningen University and Research (The Netherlands), Umweltbundesamt GmbH (UBA) (Austria), Epsilon (Greece), COWI (Belgium).
(82)      e.g. European Air Quality Index - https://www.eea.europa.eu/themes/air/air-quality-index  
(83)       e.g. EU registry on industrial sites that improves the coherence of the E-PRTR, IED and LCP data sets, and reduces the reporting burden on operators and competent authorities
(84)      European Commission (2019), Promotion of good practices for national environmental information systems and tools for data harvesting at EU level. Final Report, drafted by Wageningen University and Research (The Netherlands), Umweltbundesamt GmbH (UBA) (Austria), Epsilon (Greece), COWI (Belgium).
(85)      Kotsev A., Minghini M., Cetl V., Penninga F., Robbrecht J., Lutz M., INSPIRE – A Public Sector Contribution to the European Green Deal Data Space. A vision for the technological evolution of Europe’s Spatial Data Infrastructures for 2030, EUR 30832 EN, Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg, 2021, ISBN 978-92-76-41564-0, doi:10.2760/8563, JRC126319.
(86)      See: https://inspire.ec.europa.eu/inspire-pilots/59289  
(87)      Hans Bloem, Ray Boguslawski, Maria Teresa Borzacchiello, Piergiorgio Cipriano, Albana Kona, Giacomo Martirano, Isabella Maschio, Francesco Pignatelli (2015), Location data for buildings related energy efficiency policies, European Union Location Framework (EULF) Project Feasibility Study, JCJRC Technical report.
(88)      Bourée, K., De Vries, B., Duquesne, C., Dodson, C., Jugelt, S., Martirano, G., Minghini, M., Pignatelli, F. (2019), INSPIRE-MMTIS: overlap in standards related to the Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/1926, EUR 29975 EN, Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg. 
(89)      Source: All respondents (N=134-136), Targeted surveys (combined) April-May 2021, Question 12
(90)      Source: All respondents (N=88-103), Targeted surveys (combined) April-May 2021, Question 13
(91)      Source: EU/EEA respondents (N=91), public consultation May-July 2021, Question 3
(92)      A geographic information system (GIS) provides the ability to capture and analyse spatial and geographic data. GIS applications are computer-based tools that allow the user to create interactive queries (user-created searches), store and edit spatial and non-spatial data, analyse spatial information output, and visually share the results of these operations by presenting them as maps.
(93)      Source: All respondents (N=110-117), Targeted surveys (combined) April-May 2021, Question 23.B
(94)      Source: All respondents (N=70), public consultation May-July 2021, Question 23
(95)      Source: All respondents (N=117-118), Targeted surveys (combined) April-May 2021, Question 19.A.
(96)      Source: All respondents (N=113-115), Targeted surveys (combined) April-May 2021, Question 21.A
(97)      Source: Spatial data providers (N=68), public consultation May-July 2021, Question 21
(98)      Source: Spatial data providers (N=74), public consultation May-July 2021, Question 22
(99)      A similar conclusion was reached at the “What if…?” sessions at the 2017 INSPIRE conference. Simple APIs by providing user-friendly access to datasets for common ICT professionals, would likely have a higher impact on creating value-added services on top of INSPIRE data and services.
(100)      Source: Spatial data providers (N=64), public consultation May-July 2021, Question 25
(101)      European Commission (2004), Commission Staff Working Document, Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council establishing an infrastructure for spatial information in the Community (INSPIRE). Extended Impact Assessment, SEC(2004) 980.
(102) Ministry of Environment Finland, 2017
(103)      Ekonomisk nytta av ett samlat nationellt tillgängliggörande av geodata i samhällsbyggnadsprocessen. 2019. Lantmäteriet
(104)      Data provided by Lithuania as part of the Focus Group interview.
(105)      Vandenbroucke, D. and G. Vancauwenberghe (2021), The benefits and value of the Central SDI-node of Spain, Final Report.
(106)  https://www.lantmateriet.se/contentassets/50c7b8feec4744e5a0fa2ffaf0ea07ec/519-2018_2889-bilaga-2-ekonomisk-nytta-rattelse-190514.pdf
(107)      JRC (not yet published), Evolution of the access to spatial data for environmental purposes. JRC Technical Report.
(108)      BG, LT, RO, PL 
(109)      For example: SMARTOPENDATA - Linked Open Data for environment protection in Smart Regions , FP7-ENVIRONMENT, Start date: 2013-11-01, End date: 2015-10-31 
(110)       Interoperability Solutions for European Public Administrations
(111)   https://ec.europa.eu/environment/legal/reporting/pdf/SWD_2017_230.pdf , page 76
(112)      Ibid. 
(113)

     Reportnet: https://reportnet.europa.eu/ (Last accessed on 19.05.21).

(114)

     About Reportnet : https://www.eionet.europa.eu/reportnet (Last accessed on 19.05.21).

(115)

     Scoping Interview with EEA.

(116)

     ‘public authority’:

a)Any government or other public administration, including public advisory bodies, at national, regional or local level, or

b)Any natural or legal person performing public administrative functions under national law, including specific duties, activities or services in relation to the environment, or

c)Any natural or legal person having public responsibilities or functions, or providing public services relating to the environment under the control of a body or person falling within (a) or (b). (Article 3(9) of the INSPIRE Directive / Article 2(2) of the Public Access to Environmental Information Directive).

(117)

     European Commission (2019) Promotion of good practices for national environmental information systems and tools for data harvesting at EU level. Final report, p.31.

(118)      Ibid, p.35.
(119)      European Commission (2018), Evaluation accompanying the proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on the re-use of public sector information (SWD/2018/145 final), p.40
(120)      European Commission (2018), Evaluation accompanying the proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on the re-use of public sector information (SWD/2018/145 final); and Scoping interview with DG CONNECT - G1 Data Policy and Innovation, 6 April 2021.
(121)      PSI Directive 2013/37/EU, Article 6
(122)      INSPIRE Directive 2007/2/EC, Article 17
(123)      European Commission (2018), Study to support the review of Directive 2003/98/EC on the re-use of public sector information, Final Report.
(124)      European Commission (2016), Commission Staff Working Document: Evaluation on the implementation of Directive 2007/2/EC of March 2007 establishing an Infrastructure for Spatial Information in the European Community (INSPIRE) pursuant to article 23.
(125)      Belgium, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands, and United Kingdom.
(126)      Cetl V., Tomas R., Kotsev A., de Lima V.N., Smith R.S., Jobst M. (2019), Establishing Common Ground Through INSPIRE: The Legally-Driven European Spatial Data Infrastructure. In: Döllner J., Jobst M., Schmitz P. (eds) Service-Oriented Mapping. Lecture Notes in Geoinformation and Cartography. Springer, Cham.
(127)      Ibid.
(128)      European Commission (2016), Commission Staff Working Document: Evaluation on the implementation of Directive 2007/2/EC of March 2007 establishing an Infrastructure for Spatial Information in the European Community (INSPIRE) pursuant to article 23.
(129)      Ibid.
(130)      Vanderhaegen M, Muro E. (2005), Contribution of a European spatial infrastructure to the effectiveness of EIA and SEA studies. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 25(2): 123-142. Available at: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0195925504000782  
(131)      Tomas, R., Harrison M., Barredo J. I. et al. (2015), Towards a cross-domain interoperable framework for natural hazards and disaster risk reduction information. Natural Hazards 78 (2015): 1545-1563. Available at:  https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11069-015-1786-7  
(132)       http://www.risknet-alcotra.org
(133)       https://harmodata.dia.units.it/en/the-project  
(134)      Cetl V., Tomas R., Kotsev A., de Lima V.N., Smith R.S., Jobst M. (2019), Establishing Common Ground Through INSPIRE: The Legally-Driven European Spatial Data Infrastructure. In: Döllner J., Jobst M., Schmitz P. (eds) Service-Oriented Mapping. Lecture Notes in Geoinformation and Cartography. Springer, Cham.
(135)      European Commission (2020), Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on European data governance (Data Governance Act), COM/2020/767 final.
(136)      OECD (2019), Enhancing Access to and Sharing of Data: Reconciling Risks and Benefits for Data Re-use across Societies.
(137)      European Commission (2020), Impact Assessment on enhancing the use of data in Europe. Report on Task 1 – Data governance, written by Deloitte, The Lisbon Council, JIIP, GOVLAB, TIMELEX.
(138)      Minghini, M, V. Cetl, A. Kotsev, R. Tomas, and M. Lutz (2021), INSPIRE: The Entry Point to Europe’s Big Geospatial Data Infrastructure. In: Werner M., Chiang YY. (eds.) Handbook of Big Geospatial Data. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-55462-0_24
(139)      Rajabifard A., Feeney MEF, Williamspon IP (2002), Future directions for SDI development. International Journal of Applied Earth Observation and Geoinformation 4(1): 11-22.
(140)      See also: Kotsev, A., Minghini, M., Cetl, V., Penninga, F., Robbrecht, J. and Lutz, M., INSPIRE - A Public Sector Contribution to the European Green Deal Data Space, EUR 30832 EN, Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg, 2021, ISBN 978-92-76-41564-0, doi:10.2760/8563, JRC126319.
(141)      See also : Hernandez Quiros, L., Nunes De Lima, M. and Smith, R.S., Study of the terms of use applied in the INSPIRE resources and their usability barriers, EUR 29119 EN, Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg, 2018, ISBN 978-92-79-79910-5, doi:10.2760/555208, JRC109943.
(142)  The Internet of Things (IoT) describes physical objects (or groups of such objects) that connect and exchange data with other devices and systems over the Internet or other communications networks.

Table of contents

Annex 1: Procedural information

Annex 2: Stakeholder consultation

Annex 3: Methods and analytical models

Annex 4: Logic of the Action

Annex 5: Coherence of INSPIRE with specific sectoral legislation and initiatives

Annex 6: State of play details based on INSPIRE reporting and monitoring obligations.

Annex 1: Procedural information

1.Lead DG, Decide Planning/CWP references

Lead DG: Directorate-General for Environment

Decide planning references: PLAN/2020/8050

CWP reference: COM(2020) 690 final, Annex II, “A European Green Deal” - “12. Evaluation of Directive 2007/2/EC establishing an Infrastructure for Spatial Information in the European Community (INSPIRE)”

2.Organisation and timing

The evaluation has been coordinated by the European Commission's Directorate-General (DG) for Environment supported by an interservice steering group involving representatives of DG Climate Action, DG Agriculture and Rural Development, DG Maritime Affairs and Fisheries, DG Regional and Urban Policy, DG Mobility and Transport, DG Energy, the Joint Research Centre, Eurostat, DG Research and Innovation, DG Health and Food Safety, DG Economic and Financial Affairs, DG Communications Networks, Content and Technology, DG Informatics, the Legal Service, the Secretariat-General and the European Environment Agency.

The group steered and monitored the evaluation's progress and ensured that it met the necessary standards for quality, impartiality and usefulness. A webpage was set up on the INSPIRE knowledge base hosted by the Joint Research Centre to provide information on the evaluation process. The evaluation roadmap was published on 7 September 2020, with a four-week period for the public to give feedback. The open public consultation ran for 12 weeks (19 April-12 July 2021) on EU Survey. It consisted of two parts. The first part included general questions on the relevance of the INSPIRE Directive to EU citizens and was aimed at all respondents to the public consultation. The second part of the questionnaire included more detailed questions on the implementation of the Directive and its performance according to five evaluation criteria (effectiveness, efficiency, coherence, relevance and EU added value). This second part was particularly aimed at respondents directly involved with or affected by the Directive and its requirements.

Preparations for the evaluation commenced shortly after its announcement. The initial phase of the evaluation involved the preparation of the terms of reference, the call for tender and the award of a supporting study. The study 1 started in December 2020 and was conducted by COWI, MILIEU and TECHNOPOLIS. The final report was approved in September 2021 after a stakeholder validation workshop on 7 September 2021 had validated the key finding, conclusions and recommendations of the study.

All information is also available on INSPIRE knowledge base hosted by the Joint Research Centre: http://inspire.ec.europa.eu/  

3.Exceptions to the better regulation guidelines

The evaluation was completely carried out in the framework of the Better Regulation Guidelines, no exceptions were made.

4.Consultation of the RSB

An upstream meeting with the Regulatory Scrutiny Board took place on 9 October 2020. The Regulatory Scrutiny Board received the draft version of the Staff Working Document on 11 October 2021. Following the hearing, which took place on 10 November 2021, the Regulatory Scrutiny Board issued a positive opinion on the Evaluation and suggested some improvements. In its opinion, the Board recommended to further improve the report with respect to the following aspects:

1)The conclusions are not sufficiently nuanced and do not reflect the weaknesses and regulatory deficiencies identified in the main body of the report.

2)The report does not sufficiently analyse the drivers behind the partial implementation and limited use of the Directive, nor does it consider the implications of this underachievement for the continued relevance of the Directive.

The Board’s comments have been addressed as follows:

RSB recommendations / Revisions

(1)The analysis transparently identifies shortcomings in the performance of the Directive and its current adequacy. However, these shortcomings and the lessons learned from 14 years of implementation are not sufficiently reflected in the conclusions. This is particularly the case for the conclusion that the Directive is still largely fit for purpose. Conclusions on effectiveness and efficiency should be more nuanced, given the partial implementation of the Directive, the limited uptake by users and the criticisms presented in the report on costs. The conclusions should better acknowledge the remaining gaps and identify potential areas for improvement.

We have revised the conclusions on relevance, effectiveness and efficiency to better reflect the findings of the analysis and give a more nuanced picture of the Directive’s performance. The need for further action at European level is better balanced against the need to revise the current legal framework to make it fit-for-future. It was also made more prominent in the conclusions that although the original objectives of the Directive remain valid, the legislation must be adapted to the fast-changing data landscape and technical reality to remain relevant and improve effectiveness and efficiency.

(2)The evaluation identifies aspects where the Directive has not delivered on its initial objectives. However, it should analyse in greater depth why this has happened, and what should have been achieved by this point in time. It should analyse and explain why many Member States have developed parallel systems for their own purposes in addition to those required to comply with the Directive. It should also analyse the reasons why businesses and citizens (by and large) are not using the data provided on the platform and whether this differs by Member State. The analysis should then conclude whether the Directive is still relevant given such analysis.

In Section 5.1.3 we highlighted that the INSPIRE Directive was a front-running initiative regarding spatial data sharing that unfortunately was not always picked up by technology providers, resulting in lack of cost-effective, out of the box software solutions to support its implementation.

Section 5.2.1 was amended to better explain where the implementation of the INSPIRE was successful and where the implementation is lagging behind and does not meet its objectives.

Furthermore, in Sections 5.2.5 and 5.2.7 the evaluation was revised to clarify that the current INSPIRE interoperability rules are often considered over-specified and unfit for national use cases by data providers, giving way to parallel national spatial data infrastructures. These national infrastructures are better suited to meet practical national and regional needs, but also result in a limited and less rich INSPIRE-compliant data offering that is difficult to use in practical cross-border and EU application.

References to studies to support the analysis have been added in Sections 5.1.3 and 5.2.7.

(3)While evaluations are backward-looking exercises and should not pre-empt possible future revisions, the analysis should more operationally present and substantiate with evidence the key elements where the Directive has performed well and where it has not, and thus needs to be adapted. The review of elements where the Directive performed well should go beyond the very high-level objectives of the initiative, and look at the details of implementation across Member States. Likewise, the elements to be improved should be investigated in more detail, e.g. the simplification of data requirements, or the implications of ensuring consistency with the Open Data directive. These will also provide the basis for any forthcoming forward-looking exercise.

Building on the findings in Section 3.1 on the state of play of the implementation of the INSPIRE Directive, we highlighted under section 5.2.1 the key elements where the implementation of the INSPIRE was successful and where not. This was substantiated by a reference to a Science for policy report prepared by the Commission’s Joint Research Centre on “INSPIRE - A Public Sector Contribution to the European Green Deal Data Space”.

Possible remediation and recommendations to address the identified regulatory bottlenecks and implementation gaps have been elaborated in more detail in Section 6.7 on lessons learned. 

5.FIT FOR FUTURE Platform Opinion

The Fit for Future Platform 2 is a high-level expert group that helps the Commission in its efforts to simplify EU laws and to reduce related unnecessary costs. The platform strengthens the Regulatory fitness and performance  (REFIT) programme ’s outreach by bringing together expertise from national, regional and local authorities, the Committee of the Regions, the European Economic and Social Committee, and various stakeholders (such as the SME Envoy Network).

The Platform examines whether existing laws can achieve their objectives efficiently as we  tackle new challenges such as digitalisation. The Commission will take into account the Platform’s opinions to ensure EU laws help, not hinder, people and business, in particular small and medium-sized enterprises. The Platform opinions are based on the Platform’s annual work programmes 3 .

Having considered the evidence, the Platform adopted an opinion on 10 December 2021 as a contribution to the evaluation of the INSPIRE Directive (Ref: 2021/SBGR2/09) 4 . Overall, the Platform’s suggestions are in line with the findings of this evaluation. The Commission will consider and explore the suggestions in its impact assessment work that is expected to commence in Q2 2022.

Fit For Future Platform suggestions

(1)Data specifications can be less technology-bound, more generic and focused on the purpose.

(2)The focus should be on defining priorities and on clarifying policy needs.

(3)Mechanisms to improve European legislation in the field of geospatial information

(4)The potential benefits of INSPIRE have not yet been fully exploited.

(5)To overcome technical and financial barriers, non-legislative initiatives should be supported.

6.Evidence, sources and quality

Given the abundant availability of INSPIRE relevant documents and data sources preference was given to desk research, complemented with a broad stakeholder consultation consisting of an open public consultation, Member State implementation interviews, targeted surveys for the main relevant sectors (spatial data, environment, marine, agriculture) and scoping interviews with European Commission services.

The evaluation could build on an extensive source of data and information for the period 2014 -2021 acquired from:

•official country reports,

•country monitoring reports including indicators, data sets and services provided through the INSPIRE Geoportal,

•the 2014 midterm evaluation,

•the 2014-2021 INSPIRE conferences,

•national and cross-border conferences,

•reports from EU and national related projects and activities,

•EU-national-international policy documents,

•public consultations and independent assessments on the technical implementation of INSPIRE.

The supporting study includes a list of all data sources, reports on all consultation activities used and also describes how the information and data were assessed for its quality and robustness.


Annex 2: Stakeholder consultation

1.INTRODUCTION

In line with the Better Regulation guidelines on stakeholder consultation, the synopsis report summarises the methodology and results of all of the consultation activities undertaken for the study to support the evaluation of the Directive2007/2/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 14 March 2007 establishing an Infrastructure for Spatial Information in the European Community (INSPIRE Directive). It is the result of the consultation strategy that was developed by the Commission’s Directorate-General for Environment (DG ENV) for the evaluation.

This report presents the key issues raised in the consultation activities. The detailed overview of quantitative and qualitative results of the public consultation is contained in a separate report. The results of each consultation activity are also presented in the main evaluation report.

2.Consultation strategy

2.1.Objectives 

Consultation activities served the dual objective of collecting the evidence necessary to answer the evaluation questions and providing sufficient opportunities to all interested parties and the public to provide input and comply with the Better Regulation guidelines. It aimed to complement the information gathered through documentary review, in particular by providing data that could not be gathered through literature (e.g., data on costs and benefits, examples of uses of INSPIRE, implementation issues, etc.).

2.2.Target groups 

As INSPIRE covers a wide range of geospatial data, which can be useful for many types of institutions and business in multiple sectors, there was a long and diverse list of stakeholders across the EU that could provide valuable input on the performance of the INSPIRE Directive. There are four main ways in which stakeholders interact with INSPIRE, which is useful for understanding how to approach them in consultation activities. These are the following:

·Authorities/institutions in charge of the governance and coordination of the implementation of INSPIRE: these are mainly EU-level stakeholders, including Commission services, the JRC, the EEA and Eurostat, which maintain and oversee the infrastructure from legislative/policy, technical and networking perspectives.

·Authorities/institutions responsible for implementing the Directive: mostly national authorities, as well as other agencies involved in spatial data and data infrastructure.

·Data producers: authorities and agencies who collect spatial datasets through a variety of activities including legal mandates and environmental monitoring responsibilities.

·Data users: the wide range of institutions and stakeholders who require geospatial datasets to conduct their activities, including planning; environmental responsibilities; research; advocacy and informing the public; and commercial activities such as development of software and interactive instruments, engineering designs, etc.

Stakeholders have been identified across the following five general groups:

·INSPIRE coordination team / European Commission contacts

·EU/international organisations

·Member State/EEA/EFTA country administrations/agencies (national level)

·Sub-national level authorities

·Non-governmental stakeholders

The lists of various contact points (e.g., national focal points responsible for various pieces of legislation) were collected from different DGs following the kick-off meeting. The project team created, based on these contact lists and publicly available contacts (notably the database Who’s who in INSPIRE), a stakeholder database that has been used for all consultation activities.

2.3.Consultation methods and tools 

Consultation activities consisted of several field research activities including interviews, targeted surveys, online public consultation, and a stakeholder workshop.

Consultation activity

Number

Scoping interviews

10 interviews + 2 written inputs

Focus group interviews

7 interviews in 7 Member States involving 56 participants

Targeted surveys

4 surveys reaching 144 responses

Online public consultation

1 OPC reaching 93 responses

Validation workshop

1 workshop involving 61 participants.

A detailed description of each activity and their results is provided in the sections below.

3.Consultation activities 

3.1.Consultation on the evaluation Roadmap 

The evaluation roadmap 5  was opened for feedback from 7 September 2020 to 19 October 2020. The roadmap received 17 contributions, from various types of stakeholders, but with a predominance of public authorities (9 out of 17). All contributions are published on the European Commission’s website.

Figure 10 : Overview of feedback to evaluation Roadmap (n=17)

Main feedback received

·Several contributions indicated that INSPIRE has had a positive effect on the availability of standardised spatial data and on the development of national SDIs.

·Several contributions noted the heterogeneity of the data available in the geoportal and the heterogeneity of the implementation of the Directive across Member States

·On the same note, two contributions observed that there are very few European datasets in the INSPIRE Geoportal that are completely harmonised and so that fragmentation is still a significant obstacle to full interoperability.

·One contribution therefore stressed the need for a strong EU body with sufficient capacity to coordinated implementation (including in relation to technical guidance, monitoring, capacity building, user communication and outreach).

·Several contributions underlined that some data specifications are outdated and should be revamped – this was noted in particular for Transport Networks, which uses an outdated linear referencing model and should be aligned with the ISO standard, and Elevation, which follows outdated standards and should be aligned with more up-to-date elevation standards.

·Several contributions underlined the need to reduce the complexity of technical requirements and data models, which make INSPIRE difficult and costly to implement. Two public authorities underlined that the complexity of INSPIRE is a significant cost driver.

·One public authority stressed the need for prioritisation in the implementation of the Directive. The scope of spatial data defined in the 34 data themes is very broad, making implementation difficult. Further prioritisation would help Member States prioritise their investments.

·One public authority underlined the need for more flexible technical requirements that would allow the uptake of new technologies when they become available.

·Several contributions reflected on the limited use of INSPIRE data and underlined that at national or regional / local levels, spatial data are often used in different data models that those of INSPIRE or through different services, as INSPIRE does not fully cover national and regional/local needs. One contribution also indicated that INSPIRE is too complex for many users. Another explanation for the limited use of INSPIRE data is that the national SDI existed before INSPIRE and covered most national use cases, leading to little demand for INSPIRE data.

·The situation described above explains, according to several contribution, that INSPIRE has been implemented in some Member States in parallel to the national SDI, merely for compliance reasons. One contribution expressed the concern that INSPIRE services may end up as a set of ‘shadow services’ meeting the requirements of the Directive but attracting few users.

·Based on this, one contribution underlined that the focus on specific use cases with concrete benefits at the local, regional and national level would improve the effort-benefit ratio on the ground and thus acceptance.

·Two contributions advised that several initiatives (in the field of transport and environment) should be aligned to avoid multiple reporting processes. Another contribution however indicated that the value of using INSPIRE specifications in the context of environmental reporting is unclear as only a small part of the environmental reports consists of spatial data defined by INSPIRE implementing rules

·Two contributions stressed that potential limits to data sharing imposed by personal data protection legislation should be taken into account.

·One contribution stated that restrictions must be maintained regarding public access to data on critical infrastructures / essential services to protect those infrastructures from malicious acts and protect people’s health and the environment.

3.2.Public consultation 

Objectives and target group

The public consultation aimed to provide an opportunity to all interested parties and the general public to provide input and comply with the Better Regulation guidelines. To adapt to the broad audience of the public consultation, a number of questions focused on the experience of the user.

Questionnaire

The questionnaire was available in all EU official languages 6 . The consultation ran for 12 weeks (19 April-12 July 2021) on EU Survey. It consisted of two parts. The first part included general questions on the relevance of the INSPIRE Directive to EU citizens and was aimed at all respondents to the public consultation. The second part of the questionnaire included more detailed questions on the implementation of the Directive and its performance according to five evaluation criteria (effectiveness, efficiency, coherence, relevance and EU added value). This second part was particularly aimed at respondents directly involved with or affected by the Directive and its requirements.

Responses received

The public consultation received 93 responses. 77 respondents replied to both parts of the questionnaire, while 16 replied only to the first part.

More than half of the respondents (55% or 51 respondents) were public authorities. EU citizens responding in a personal capacity were the second largest group of respondents, representing a total of 17% (16), followed by companies or business organisations/associations (15% or 14 respondents). Figure 1 shows the distribution of respondents by type.

Figure 11 : Responses to the online public consultation, by stakeholder group (N=93)

The consultation received replies from 21 EU Member States (all except Bulgaria, Ireland, Latvia, Lithuania, Malta and Slovakia), and one EFTA country (Norway). The largest group of respondents came from Germany, representing 30% of respondents (28 in total).

Responses to online public consultation by country (N=93)

Country

Number of respondents

Country

Number of respondents

Country

Number of respondents

Austria

5

Finland

2

Non-EU

2

Belgium

5

France

3

Norway

2

Croatia

2

Germany

28

Poland

3

Cyprus

1

Greece

2

Portugal

6

Czech Republic

1

Hungary

4

Romania

6

Denmark

4

Italy

5

Slovenia

1

Estonia

1

Luxembourg

1

Spain

3

EU-level

2

Netherlands

3

Sweden

1

Respondents to the online public consultation overall stated that they have a good knowledge of the INSPIRE Directive. More than half of the respondents (62%, 56 respondents) indicated that they are highly knowledgeable about the Directive and its provisions. It can be concluded from these responses that respondents to the online public consultation are mostly experts, rather than citizens.

Figure 12 : Online public consultation respondents’ familiarity with the INSPIRE Directive (N=91)

Processing and use of responses

Contributions to the online public consultation were published on the Commission website. Following the Better Regulation template for public consultations, respondents to the consultation were provided with two options for the publication of their contributions: 1) Public, with both organisation details and respondent details published; 2) Anonymous, with only organisation details published.

Results from the online public consultation were downloaded in Excel format from EU Survey. A full report was drafted 7 , presenting the profile of respondents, the results of the closed questions and summaries of responses to open-ended questions. In the evaluation report, results from the online public consultation were summarised in each evaluation question under a dedicated heading.

Main results from the online public consultation

Effectiveness

·Respondents found that data discoverability is facilitated by INSPIRE, but opinions are more mixed regarding access to data:

·Most respondents (51%, 39 in total) reported that it is very or moderately easy to find relevant geospatial data published under the INSPIRE Directive.

·39% of respondents (30) indicated that it is very or moderately easy to get access to the content of geospatial data published under INSPIRE, while 26% (20) indicated that it is moderately or very difficult.

·Opinions were also mixed regarding the ease of use and reuse of data under INSPIRE:

·A slightly higher proportion of respondents (32%, 25) indicated that it is moderately or very difficult to use the geospatial data published under the INSPIRE Directive from a technical accessibility point of view than moderately or very easy (30%, 23) – while 27% (21) indicated that it is neither easy nor difficult.

·Similarly, a slightly higher proportion of respondents (30%, 23 in total) indicated that it is moderately or very difficult to reuse or re-publish geospatial data published under the INSPIRE Directive than respondents who indicated that it is moderately or very easy (27%, 21 in total).

·According to respondents, the INSPIRE Directive supports the process of planning and assessing impacts, at least in some policy areas:

·More than half of the respondents indicated that the INSPIRE Directive supports (slightly or strongly) the Water Framework Directive (55%, 36 respondents) and the Birds and Habitats Directive (51%, 33 respondents); 47% (31 respondents) indicated that the INSPIRE Directive supports floods management.

·According to respondents, the INSPIRE Directive supports the active dissemination of environmental data to the public at least in some policy areas:

·Nearly half of the respondents indicated that the INSPIRE Directive supports (slightly or strongly) the active dissemination of environmental data in relation to the Birds and Habitats Directives (49%, 31 respondents), the Water Framework Directive (49%, 32 respondents) and for floods management (45%, 29 respondents).

Efficiency

·The vast majority of spatial data providers that replied to the public consultation indicated that the INSPIRE rules on data harmonisation, metadata, view services and download services and rules on publishing spatial data covered by INSPIRE resulted in additional costs.

·Better comparability and interoperability between spatial data sources was the most frequently selected benefit linked to the INSPIRE Directive selected by respondents (64%, 45 respondents).

·Overall, a higher proportion of respondents believe that the costs linked to sharing/using spatial data outweigh the current or expected future benefits for their organisation (37%, of the respondents (26) indicated that there are some benefits, but that costs prevail).

·The vast majority respondents (79%, 50 respondents) indicated that the process for harmonising spatial data could be simplified and more than half of the respondents (over 30 respondents) indicated that the processes for transforming, documenting and publishing spatial data along with the process of making spatial data downloadable could be simplified.

Coherence

·One fourth of the respondents believe that INSPIRE supports authorities in complying with their obligations under the Open Data Directive to a large extent (19 respondents / 76 – 25%) and roughly the same proportion to a moderate extent (20 respondents / 76 - 26%)

Added value

·Nearly half of the respondents (49%, 37 respondents) believe to a large extent that the EU-wide standardisation of data policies, licences and technical infrastructure resulting from INSPIRE has brought additional benefits compared to what could have been achieved a national and subnational levels.

Nearly half of the respondents (49%, 37 respondents) believe to large extent that the obstacles and needs related to sharing and disseminating spatial data as addressed by INSPIRE still require EU-level action.

3.3.Scoping interviews 

Objectives and target group

Scoping interviews were carried out with EU-level stakeholders, in particular with relevant Commission services and the EEA. The main purpose of these interviews was to understand the key issues for the evaluation, including the main implementation issues, the main benefits and uses of INSPIRE, to support a better interpretation and scoping of the evaluation questions, and the preparation of other consultation tools.

Interview questionnaires

Interview questionnaires, tailored to each interview were drafted by the evaluation team and sent beforehand to participants. A number of standard questions on the implementation, uses and benefits of INSPIRE, which were asked in most interviews, were complemented by specific questions related to the role of the different Commission services and EU-level organisations in the development of INSPIRE, the use (or expectations towards the use) of INSPIRE in different policy areas (e.g. agriculture, transport, marine environment, climate), the main benefits of INSPIRE for these policy areas, and the coherence between INSPIRE and reporting obligations or data sharing provisions in other pieces of legislation.

Interviews completed

Ten interviews were carried out by the evaluation team between March and early May. In addition, one EU organisation and one Commission Unit (contacted at a later stage in the project) provided written feedback to interview questions. An overview of the interviews completed is presented below.

Table 15 Scoping interviews completed

Participants

Date

Commission services

•DG JRC – Digital economy

26 March 2021

•DG CONNECT – Data Policy and Innovation

6 April 2021

•DG MARE – Maritime innovation, Marine Knowledge and Investment

8 April 2021

•DG MOVE - Sustainable and Intelligent Transport

12 April 2021

•DG CLIMA – Climate Adaptation / EEA (Climate-ADAPT)

16 April 2021

•DG ENV – Compliance and Better Regulation

20 April 2021

•EEA – Data and Information Services & Data Management units

26 April 2021

•DG AGRI – Implementation support and IACS / JRC – Land Resources Unit

29 April 2021

•DG ESTAT - Regional statistics and geographical information

3 May 2021

•DG MOVE – TEN-T

Provided written feedback to interview questions

EU-level stakeholders

•Eurogeographics

17 April 2021

•Eurogeosurveys

Provided written feedback to the scoping interview questionnaire

Processing and use of responses

Transcripts were drafted for each interview and shared with the whole evaluation team. In the evaluation report, results from scoping interviews were integrated in each evaluation question under a specific heading.

Main results from scoping interviews

Effectiveness

·There is still a great heterogeneity in the data available within and across Member States, which limits as of today the effectiveness of INSPIRE. The availability and harmonisation of data also vary across data themes (for some themes, like orthophotos, availability is quite good, for others it is much lower).

·Many users that need data for regional or national purposes will not use INSPIRE data but other national datasets following other standards (e.g. open data) instead.

·INSPIRE is not fully aligned with sectoral needs and therefore the cross-sector use is limited at the EU level. Efforts have been made to align between INSPIRE provisions and data requirements in different thematic domains.

·INSPIRE is too specific in terms of technological standards and implementing rules are quite rigid. One solution to move on from this issue is to work on communities of best practices instead of over-specifying the implementing rules too much

Efficiency

·Data sets and services that created in order to meet INSPIRE requirements but are not used in other contexts are considered by data providers at national level as a burden from a technical and organisational perspective.

Coherence

·Work is ongoing to align better reporting obligations with INSPIRE rules. This long and complex process will extend over many years and require significant coordination with Member States. Reportnet 3.0 will allow for the intake of INSPIRE datasets.

·INSPIRE is considered as an opportunity in several sectors to have a centralised entry point to access and share data. Alignment of various data sharing instruments is ongoing at EU level. In some sectors, relationships with INSPIRE and how INSPIRE might support those policy areas is still largely to be defined (MSP, TEN-T, climate adaptation). Further collaboration with sectoral DGs at EU level and through committees could be developed, where relevant. The creation of a single data platform for all sorts of spatial data might however be an unachievable perspective as some sectors have specific objectives and data needs.

·Directive 2003/4 could benefit from aligning some of its terminology with INSPIRE as INSPIRE provides a technical framework for electronic data sharing. Directive 2003/4 refers to data sharing through ‘electronic means’ but without further specifications, it could be made explicit that this is referring to the INSPIRE Directive specifications.

·Inconsistencies and call for clarifications highlighted in the evaluation of the PSI Directive have been largely resolved in the 2019 recast of the PSI Directive (2019/1024/EU). DG CONNECT is working with the Member States on the interoperability of INSPIRE and Open Data metadata. The upcoming Regulation on High Value Datasets will ensure maximum alignment with INSPIRE both in terms of the technical obligations and in terms of the geospatial datasets covered.

3.4.Focus group interviews 

Objectives and target group

The main objective of the focus group interviews was to better understand the different ways the Directive is being implemented in the Member States and how the national context and governance structure might influence the successes and failures in implementation. They aimed to collect information on current drivers and barriers to the implementation of the Directive in the Member States, including on the progress made in the Member States in relation to the implementation roadmap. Focus group interviews also aimed to collect relevant information to respond to evaluation questions for which only limited literature is available – including uses of INSPIRE for policy-making and reporting purposes, uses of INSPIRE by other types of users (research community, companies, including SMEs), costs and benefits of INSPIRE, relationships between INSPIRE and PSI/Open Data and Public Access to Environmental Information Directives, and the added value of the INSPIRE compared to what would have happened in the Member State without the EU framework.

As differences in implementation was a focus of the interviews, Member States were selected for their diversity of national contexts (larger vs smaller Member States, federated vs centralised Member States), their different levels of advancement in the implementation of the INSPIRE Directive (more advanced vs less advanced Member States), and their geographic spread across the EU. The level of advancement in the implementation of the INSPIRE Directive of each Member States was assessed based on the criteria of the INSPIRE reporting (conformity of metadata, conformity of spatial datasets, accessibility of data through view and download services, conformity of network services). Based on these criteria, four groups of Member States were created. Focus group interviews targeted two Member States of each group (as initially eight interviews were planned).

The focus group interviews were organised with small groups (around 6-8) of national stakeholders, responsible for and/or involved in the implementation of the Directive, as well as for the production of and use of spatial data. Participants were selected by the INSPIRE National Contact Point, who was always present during the interview.

Focus group interview guide

A standard interview guide was prepared by the evaluation team and sent to all participants beforehand (see Appendix I). The questions were the same for all Member States. To prepare the interview and be ready to tailor questions to the national situation, moderators from the team reviewed the country forms before the interview. Several Member States sent written responses to this questionnaire to complement the discussions in the focus group interview.

Focus group interviews completed

Seven focus group interviews were carried out between Mid-April and early May. An additional interview was initially planned but was cancelled following the defection of one Member State. Focus group interviews were carried out online. Two moderators from the evaluation team were present in each interview, as well as a note taker. An overview of the focus groups interviews carried out and of the participating organisations is provided below.

Table 16 Focus group interviews completed

Member State

Participants

•BE (4 May 2021)

11 participants

•National Geographic Institute of Belgium

•Federal Public Service for Policy and Support, DG Digital Transformation

•Flemish Agency for Geographical Information

•Flemish Environment Agency

•Public Service of Wallonia, Geodata Integration Directorate

•Public Service of Wallonia, Agriculture, Natural Resources and Environment

•Brussels Environmental Agency (Bruxelles Environnement)

•Brussels Regional Informatics Centre

•BG (27 April 2021)

5 participants from:

•State e-Government Agency

•Geodesy, Cartography and Cadastre Agency

•Ministry of Interior

•Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Forestry

•National Institute of Meteorology and Hydrology

•DE (22 April 2021)

8 participants from:

•Steering Committee SDI Germany

•Coordination Office SDI Germany

•Federal Agency of Cartographie and Geodesy

•Federal Institute for Geosciences and Natural Resources

•Federal Ministry for the Environment, Nature Conservation and Nuclear Safety

•State Agency for Nature, Environment and Consumer Protection of North Rhine-Westphalia

•State Agency for Agriculture, the Environment and Rural Areas of Schleswig-Holstein

•IE (6 May 2021)

7 participants from:

•Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage

•Ordnance Survey Ireland

•Geological Survey Ireland

•Environmental Protection Agency

•Central Statistics Office

•IT (26 April 2021)

7 participants from:

•ISPRA

•Ecological Transition Ministry

•AgID (Agency for Italian Digitalization)

•Italian National Institute of Statistics

•Interregional Center for Statistic and Geographic Information System

•LT (4 May 2021)

11 participants from:

•Ministry of Agriculture

•National Center for Remote Sensing and Geoinformatics “GIS-Centras”

•State Enterprise Centre of Registers

•National Land Service

•Environmental Protection Agency

•National Public Health Centre

•State Service for Protected Areas

•ES (20 April 2021)

7 participants from:

•National Center of Geographic Information

•Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food

•Ministry of Finance (Directorate General for Cadastre)

•SDI of Navarre region (IDENA)

•SDI of Catalonia region (IDEC)

Processing and use of responses

Transcripts were drafted for all focus groups interview and shared with the whole evaluation team. In the evaluation report, results from focus group interviews were summarised in each evaluation questions under a dedicated heading.

Main results from Focus Group interviews

Effectiveness

·The governance structure varies greatly from one Member State to another – ranging from a very ‘slim’ governance structure to extensive governance structure. Each Member State has tried to adapt the INSPIRE Directive requirements to their national situation (e.g. federated systems vs centralised systems). INSPIRE has been a driver in some Member States in setting up a governance structure to manage the national SDI.

·Harmonisation of regional datasets is a challenge and a cost, but also brings up benefits. The harmonisation process triggered by INSPIRE is seen in some Member States as a driver for improving the harmonisation of regional and local datasets.

·The implementation of the INSPIRE SDI is sometimes carried out in parallel to the maintenance of national SDIs, to reach a better compliance rate.

·The implementation of INSPIRE and environmental reporting are also still largely separated processes, although positive experiences were mentioned for some policy areas where reporting obligations are aligned with INSPIRE rules.

·It is almost impossible for Member States to identify the nature of INSPIRE users if they are not the data providers as there are no requirements for users to register or provide personal data to use INSPIRE services.

·Many users that need data for regional or national purposes will not use INSPIRE data but other national datasets following other standards (e.g. open data) instead.

Relevance

·The objectives of the INSPIRE Directive (harmonised datasets and services at EU level) are still relevant.

·The relevance of the Directive for potential users (outside of EU authorities) is however not completely obvious as diverse user groups might need diverse services (simpler services accessible though apps for many users vs more specific and detailed services for professional users). A new focus could be on easy access to data for mainstream users and for the general public.

Efficiency

·National authorities see harmonisation and interoperability is a key benefit of INSPIRE.

·There are different assessments within the Member States as to the main cost drivers as costs often depend on the institution and/or administrative level. It also depends on the organisations of SDI in the country and on the size and structure of the country. For instance, large providers of data such as cadastre or mapping agencies do not have infrastructure costs. Such institutions experience costs in relation to processing and harmonising of data instead. The costs of data harmonisation was often mentioned as a key cost, identified as a cost category for both national and local level institutions.

·The perception on the availability of funding and expertise to implement INSPIRE varies across Member States. Some Member States did mention problems of lack of funding and staff expertise, leading to INSPIRE implementation not being prioritised, and significant outsourcing of tasks.

·There is a need to simplify the implementation at the technical level, in particular as regards the complexity in the data models. Focus group interviews also mentioned that technical specifications are not easy to understand for public authorities.

·It is too early to assess the proportionality of cost and benefits due to the fact the benefits are only now beginning to emerge.

Coherence

·There are some overlaps between INSPIRE data themes leading to diverse implementation of INSPIRE across Member States.

·A clear reference to INSPIRE in the environmental legislation is useful to promote awareness of INSPIRE rules among authorities. Because reporting obligations under environmental Directives are not yet fully aligned with INSPIRE rules, environmental reporting is still quite largely separated from INSPIRE implementation. INSPIRE and environmental reporting are often dealt with at national level by different authorities, which makes coordination more complex.

·Member States authorities indicated that there are relatively few interactions in the implementation of Directive 2003/4/EC and INSPIRE at national level; that both Directives are implemented separately.

·Member States authorities indicated that there are relatively few interactions in the implementation of the Open Data Directive and INSPIRE at national level and that both Directives are implemented separately.

·A few Member States authorities were concerned that the Open Data Directive, and in particular the provision on high-value datasets and future implementing act, will in practice lead to a parallel infrastructure, which may lead to a duplication of efforts.

Added Value

·The broad scope of INSPIRE (geographically and in terms of themes) is perceived as an added value. Common standards for data exchange and conditions of use, usage of data by different stakeholders (not only at national level), greater reach and dissemination, stronger commitment across borders, better justification of the use of resources for the implementation and a rationale for other necessary investment in the national SDI were some elements of added value mentioned.

·The INSPIRE Directive has also been an incentive for the mapping agencies to cooperate with the neighbourhood countries, even if no effective guidelines for cross border aspects have been developed.

·EU-level action is still required to achieve interoperable data in Europe.

3.5.Targeted surveys 

Objectives and target group

The focus group interviews described above mainly targeted authorities who are chiefly responsible for the implementation of the Directive, as well as production of data and high-level use of data sets, in seven Member States. To reach a broader coverage of stakeholder groups (e.g. data users such as research institutions, business associations, NGOs) and of Member States, a series of four targeted surveys were organised. In terms of stakeholder coverage, targeted surveys also aimed to reach stakeholders that were less represented in the focus groups interviews, in particular environmental authorities. If a representative from the Ministry responsible for Environment or the EPA, was often present in the focus group interview, it was not always the right person to discuss issues linked to environmental reporting. Representatives from various environmental policy area were often not present in the interview. Similarly, representatives from regional authorities were present in focus group interviews of federated countries, but the coverage of regional and local authorities could only be minimal in those interviews. The surveys provided a good opportunity to reach out to a broader range of stakeholders and was therefore widely distributed.

The survey of the spatial data community had the broadest target group and really aimed to reach a broad range of stakeholders producing and using spatial data in all Member States and EFTA countries.

Environmental reporting was the focus of the survey of the environmental community. As the issue of environmental reporting was covered both in effectiveness and coherence evaluation questions, this survey was particularly important for the evaluation.

The targeted surveys also provided an opportunity to focus on selected sectors to investigate more in-depth uses of INSPIRE for policy-making, reporting, research and planning. Those two sectors, marine policy and agriculture, were selected with the Commission at the beginning of the project based on their high level of spatial data needs and potential for cooperation with INSPIRE. In addition to specific uses for these sectors, those sectoral questionnaires provided an opportunity to investigate potential coherence issues and alignment of data sharing and reporting.

Table 17 Target groups of the four targeted surveys

Surveys

Target stakeholder groups

•Spatial data community

•National Mapping, Cadastre and Land Registry Authorities/Agencies

•Geological surveys

•National authorities responsible for the implementation of the Open Data Directive

•EU and international organisation with responsibilities related to spatial data dissemination (Copernicus, OECD, UNGGIM / UNGGIM-Europe)

•Smart cities / Sustainable cities service providers

•PSI reusers

•TN-ITS community

•Environmental community

•EIONET network

•National focal points to the Aarhus Convention

•Environmental Protection agencies

•Meteorological organisations

•Business associations / research organisations in specific environmental sectors

•Marine community

•EMODNET network

•MSFD DIKE working group

•EIONET network (organisations in marine fields)

•Regional Sea Conventions

•The Technical Expert Group "Data for MSP"

•Copernicus marine service

•Agriculture community

•National EAGF/ EAFRD paying agencies

•EU farmers associations: COPA-COGECA and members, European Council of Young Farmers

Targeted survey questionnaires

A specific questionnaire was drafted for each survey (see Appendix II). The four questionnaires had relatively similar structures, and similar sets of questions (e.g. questions on costs and benefits, added value, consistency with Open data and Public Access to Environmental Information Directive). However, they also all contained specific sets of questions targeted at the specific community reached by the survey – e.g. environmental reporting, Maritime spatial planning, reporting of IACS data. The four questionnaires were put online on EU survey.

Dissemination was done partly by the evaluation team and partly by Commission DGs and the EEA. The evaluation team took charge of the dissemination to stakeholders whose contacts could be found either in the INSPIRE database (Who’s who in INSPIRE) or from public sources. Commission services and the EEA targeted their own working groups (e.g. EIONET, EMODnet network, MSFD working groups, national paying agencies, Copernicus services, smart cities service providers). Participants were given five weeks to respond (from 29 April to 4 June 2021).

Responses received

In total, 144 responses were received. The largest number of responses were received from the spatial data community and the environmental communities, which had the largest target groups.

Figure 13 : Overview of responses to the targeted surveys (n=144)

It is difficult to estimate the response rate (percentage of targeted stakeholders who responded) as the evaluation team did not have access to all Commission distribution lists for confidentiality reasons. The evaluation team therefore does not have full knowledge of the number of targeted stakeholders, in particular as overlaps between the various distribution lists are very likely. The stakeholder database compiled by the evaluation team contained 422 stakeholders. It should be noted, as a general remark, that there might be overlaps between responses to the targeted survey, the public consultation and the focus group interviews. It is however difficult to fully grasp as in some cases different divisions of the same organisation might have participated in the various consultation activities.

In terms of stakeholder groups, most responses were received from public authorities, in particular authorities directly involved in the implementation of INSPIRE as data producers (national authorities, environmental protection agencies, mapping agencies, geological surveys). In this regard, the surveys did not completely fulfil to the initial objective of reaching out a broader stakeholder range, in particular in reaching out to other types of data users than public authorities. This can be explained partially by the difficulty to identify them and reach them. This might also come from the fact that those stakeholders might not differentiate between INSPIRE data and other types of open data and feel less concerned by INSPIRE. Results from consultation activities also showed limited use of INSPIRE data in some communities, which might also explain the low response rate.

Figure 14 : Responses to the targeted survey by stakeholder groups (n=144)

At least one answer was received from each Member State. Among EFTA countries, responses were only received from Norway. Poland, Czech Republic, Belgium, Netherlands and Germany represent around a third of responses. As three of these countries were not selected for focus group interviews, the targeted surveys have succeeded to broaden the stakeholder range participating in consultation activities in terms of country coverage.

Table 18 Responses to targeted survey by Member States (n=144)

Member State

Nb of respondents

Member State

Nb of respondents

Poland

10

France

4

Czech Republic

10

Portugal

4

Belgium

10

EU-level

4

Netherlands

9

Ireland

4

Germany

9

Romania

3

Spain

7

Latvia

3

Cyprus

6

Croatia

3

Denmark

6

Greece

3

Hungary

6

Norway

3

Italy

6

Estonia

3

Slovenia

5

Luxembourg

2

Slovak Republic

5

Non-EU

1

Finland

5

Lithuania

1

Austria

5

Bulgaria

1

Sweden

5

Malta

1

Processing and use of responses

Results from the targeted consultation questionnaires were downloaded in Excel format from EU Survey. General results from all of the closed questions and results by stakeholder groups and Member States were computed and provided in a readable format to the evaluation team. In the evaluation report, results from the targeted surveys are included in each evaluation question, under a specific heading.

Main results from scoping interviews

Effectiveness

·The progress made so far in the provision of INSPIRE compliant data services is not in line with the initial expectations and the INSPIRE Implementation Roadmap according to 48% of respondents (53).

·Respondents to the targeted surveys believed that the INSPIRE Directive contributed to access, exchange and reuse of geospatial data across public sector organisations to a large extent (48 respondents – 35%) or to some extent (44 respondents – 32%).

·Respondents identified technical access to data as the most important barrier to the use of spatial data from the point of view of the users (83 out of 131, 63%). The second barrier is the level of data available (for 61 respondents, 47%). Format and quality of data are respectively third (56 respondents 43%)and fourth barriers (50 respondents 38%).

·Respondents to targeted surveys think that spatial data are used first by national governments / ministries, regional and local authorities and national and regional agencies. Respondents believe that spatial data made available thanks to INSPIRE are barely used by companies selling data products or services.

Relevance

·According to respondents, the INSPIRE Directive addresses to a very large extent (49%) or large extent (53%) the future most significant needs in terms of availability of spatial data for reporting to the European commission and planning, and to a lesser extent the availability of spatial data for policymaking (41%) and for monitoring of policies (39%).

Efficiency

·According to respondents, key costs are related to harmonization and interoperability (almost 50% of the respondents think these activities carry significant costs).

·Main costs are borne by national level organisations, and these organisations these organisations may not see all the benefits. Geological survey, mapping and cadastre and national authorities generally perceived that cost outweigh benefits. Generally, relatively few of the respondents groups found that the benefits where higher than the costs.

·Regarding benefits of INSPIRE, a large share of respondents have rated direct and indirect benefits of INSPIRE proposed as significant (between 25-40% of the respondents), in particular the direct benefits ‘Harmonisation and interoperability’, ‘Better overview, discoverability, availability, accessibility of data’ and ‘Share and reuse of data’, and the indirect benefits ‘EU-wide collaboration’ and ‘National infrastructure and data strategy development’.

·Responses to the targeted surveys pointed to a need or potential for simplifying the INSPIRE data models and increased use of international standards.

Coherence

·There are some inconsistencies or overlaps between INSPIRE data themes – as a result, the same data could fall under various data themes.

·A clear reference to INSPIRE in the environmental legislation is useful to promote awareness of INSPIRE rules and compliance. Reporting under environmental legislation and provision of INSPIRE datasets are still often two distinct processes, resulting in two different datasets produced, because of differences in data specifications and standards, although progress has been made in some environmental areas.

·Results from targeted surveys partially contrast with focus group interviews where it appeared that both Directives where implemented in silos. Respondents to the targeted surveys found that the INSPIRE Directive supports the implementation of Directive 2003/4/EC to a large or very large extent (46 respondents – 34%) or at least to some extent (45 respondents – 33%).

·Similarly, respondents to the targeted surveys found that that INSPIRE supports the implementation of the Open Data Directive to a very large or large extent (62 respondents - 46%) when it appeared in focus groups that there were limited interactions between the two at national level.

Added value

·Respondents generally found that EU-wide standardization of data policies, licences and technical infrastructure as a result of the INSPIRE Directive brought additional benefits in comparison to what could have been achieved at national, regional and/or local level (52 respondents – 49% - to a very large or to a large extent).

·The majority of respondents (74 respondents – 55% - a very large or to a large extent) to believe that the obstacles and needs related to sharing and disseminating spatial data as addressed by the INSPIRE Directive continue to require action at EU level.

3.6.Stakeholder validation workshop 

Objectives and target group

The purpose of the workshop was to present and validate the preliminary findings and conclusions of the evaluation and give participants an opportunity to provide feedback. As a variety of perspectives was expected, invitations were sent to a wide range of stakeholders including representatives from relevant Commission services and agencies, national authorities involved in the implementation of INSPIRE (contacted through the national contact point in each Member State / EFTA country), relevant EU umbrella organisations (EuroGeographics, EuroGeoSurveys, EUROGI), companies specialising in GIS software or geospatial data analysis, standards developing organisations (OGC), academics and research organisations. Member States / EFTA countries and other organisations invited were asked to limit their participation to one or two representatives.

Validation survey

Prior to the workshop, a workshop survey had been circulated to registered participants. The survey included nine questions and aimed to gauge participants’ support to some of the preliminary conclusions and recommendations included in the evaluation study. The survey received 47 responses. More than half of the respondents (55%, 26 in total) were from national authorities or agencies. An overview of the results from the survey is available in Workshop Report (Appendix 6 to the evaluation study).

Table 19 Responses to the validation survey (N=47)

Workshop agenda

The workshop was held online, on 7 September 2021 from 10-12 am. The workshop included a short introduction, during which the main findings per evaluation criterion, the conclusions and recommendations of the evaluation study, as well as the results from the validation survey, were presented to participants. Participants were also provided with the draft final report of the evaluation study prior to the workshop. The introduction was followed by breakout sessions, moderated by members of the evaluation team the desk officer for the study in DG Environment, during which four groups of participants were invited to comment on the preliminary conclusions and recommendations of the study. Feedback gathered through breakout sessions was summed up and discussed in a plenary setting, before the Commission closed the workshop by presenting the next steps in the evaluation and the revision of the INSPIRE Directive.

Table 20 Workshop agenda

Time

content

10.00-10.35

Introduction

▪Welcome

▪Overview of evaluation process

▪Criteria, conclusions and recommendations of the evaluation study

▪Short Q&A

10.35-11.10

Break-out sessions

▪Group discussions on main conclusions and recommendations

11.10-11.55

Plenary discussions

▪Key points from each break-out session by rapporteurs

▪Plenary discussions

11.55-12.00

Closing of the workshop

▪Next steps in the evaluation process

The breakout sessions were structured according to three themes (i.e. the three groups of recommendations presented during the introduction):

·Closing the implementation gap

·Applying a user-driven approach

·Ensuring the alignment of INSPIRE with other policy areas

The three themes were discussed in each group. To facilitate the discussions, prompting questions were submitted to participants.

Stakeholder participation

The workshop gathered 61 participants (72 had initially registered). Among the 72 participants registered, 10 were Commission / EU agencies representatives, 36 representatives from national authorities and 26 representatives of umbrella organisations, private sector and research. Among the 36 representatives of national authorities, 19 Member States and 2 EFTA countries were represented. Although it was difficult to check during the workshop, it seems the balance between groups was quite similar during the event compared to the registration.

Processing and use of feedback

Minutes of the workshop were drafted by the evaluation team based on the recording of the workshop and notes taken by members of the evaluation team during the event and the breakout sessions. These minutes are available in the Workshop Report (Appendix 6 to the evaluation study). The evaluation team then organised a brainstorming session on how to best integrate the feedback of the workshop in the final evaluation study.

Main feedback from the validation workshop

Closing the implementation gap

·There was a consensus among participants that data harmonisation should focus on a pre-identified number of datasets, prioritised based on their level of use. Several participants suggested that prioritisation of datasets should concern datasets that are selected as High Value Datasets, or relevant for the Green Deal and the European data spaces. In the validation survey, the vast majority of respondents (91%) agreed, 40% of which strongly, that there is a need for a more targeted and proportional harmonisation based on use-case driven data priorities in order to reduce costs of implementation.

·In the validation survey, the majority of respondents (81%) agreed, 45% of which strongly, that the INSPIRE Directive should be implemented as part of the national SDI to increase its relevance and reduce costs. During the workshop, two participants also called for more integration between the national and European infrastructures, one of them bringing up the idea of establishing an EU SDI.

·Several stakeholders called for the simplification of INSPIRE specifications and more alignment on international data models (e.g., OGC/ISO) as a way to improve and accelerate the implementation of INSPIRE.

·In the validation survey, the majority of respondents (72%) agreed, 15% of which strongly agreed, that there is a need to involve a more diverse representation of stakeholders (i.e. other stakeholders than EU Member States and EFTA countries representatives) to increase the relevance and usability of INSPIRE. However, this issue was more debated during the workshop. Several stakeholders were of the opinion that other stakeholders should not be involved in the implementation of INSPIRE for fear of it becoming unmanageable and for too many conflicts to arise.

Applying a user driven approach

·There was support from participants for shifting the current approach to the implementation of INSPIRE towards a user driven approach, which would be based on the identification of users’ needs and most prominent use cases and would allow prioritising datasets that should be harmonised. The vast majority (93%)of respondents to the validation survey also agreed that there is a need to specifically assess the needs of the different user groups in order to prioritise data to be harmonised.

·A few participants however highlighted that identifying users’ needs could be challenging (in particular for private users) as there is a significant gap between end users and data providers.

·In the validation survey, the vast majority of respondents (79%) agreed that there are constraints to the use of data shared under INSPIRE, especially for less experienced users. During the workshop, a few participants however warned against the additional burden and costs that developing complementary data models for non-expert users would entail.

·A few participants also indicated that the priority should be placed on closing the implementation gap as the lack of data availability, quality and harmonisation is currently impeding the use of INSPIRE.

Alignment with other policy areas

·In the validation survey, the majority of respondents (72%) agreed, 38% of which strongly, that there is a need to update Directive 2003/4 on Public access to environmental information so that the spatial data covered by Article 7 is shared in accordance with INSPIRE rules. This topic did not raise comments from participants during the workshop.

·Two participants commented on the benefits of developing synergies between INSPIRE and Open data platforms, including reducing costs.

·A representative of public utilities service providers underlined the necessity to retain the provisions of Article 13 of the INSPIRE Directive as they are now to ensure the protection of infrastructures vulnerable to attacks and/or criminal damage. This point echoes remarks made in the public consultation by similar types of stakeholders.

 

Annex 3: Methods and analytical models

This annex provides a summary of the methodology used to prepare this evaluation. The methodology is described in detail in section 4 of this document and in sections 3 and 4 of the supporting study. The methodological approach was guided by a set of 30 evaluation questions, which have been operationalised in an evaluation questions matrix. The evaluation questions were structured around five evaluation criteria: effectiveness, efficiency, relevance, coherence and EU added value.

The main analytical method used for most questions was content analysis, based on the aggregation and analysis of information collected with the literature review, desk study, targeted questionnaires, interviews, public consultation and validation workshop. Data were analysed according to the principles of triangulation of evidence from different perspectives (stakeholder categories) and different sources.

Evaluation questions

CURRENT STATUS

·EQ 1.1: How has the implementation and application of INSPIRE evolved from 2014 to 2020 and how it has affected different stakeholders?

·EQ 1.2: To what extent has the recommendations from the 2016 INSPIRE REFIT been implemented?

EFFECTIVENESS

·EQ 2.1: What progress has been made over time towards achieving the objectives and targets set out in INSPIRE in various Member States?

·EQ 2.2: Is the progress made in line with the initial expectations and the INSPIRE implementation roadmap?

·EQ 2.3: Is the geographical coverage of implementation consistent with the Directive's objectives?

·EQ 2.4: To what extent does the implementation of the INSPIRE Directive in the Member States build further on the obligations of Directive 2003/4/EC on public access to environmental information (specifically the provisions under Articles 7 and 8 of the Directive 2003/4/EC)?

·EQ 2.5: Which main factors have contributed to – respectively stood in the way of achieving these objectives?

·EQ 2.6: To what extent is INSPIRE used for reporting under the environmental acquis?

·EQ 2.7: What are the qualitative and quantitative effects of INSPIRE on the policymaking users in the field of environment in Member States?

·EQ 2.8: What are the qualitative and quantitative effects of INSPIRE on users active in economic sectors influencing environment?

·EQ 2.9: What are the effects of INSPIRE on small businesses using spatial data?

RELEVANCE

·EQ 3.1: To what extent does INSPIRE still match current needs and do they continue to require action at EU level?

·EQ 3.2: Is INSPIRE still relevant to the issues (obstacles) it addresses?

·EQ 3.3: To what extent is INSPIRE future-proof?

·EQ 3.4: Are the Articles 7 and 8 of Directive 2003/4/EC on public access to environmental information still relevant in view of the current state of the INSPIRE infrastructures?

EFFICIENCY

·EQ 4.1: To what extent and how has the intervention lead to improvements in the quality or efficiency of work of concerned stakeholders?

·EQ 4.2: Can any specific provisions in INSPIRE be identified that make cost-efficient implementation more difficult?

·EQ 4.3: Can the INSPIRE Directive and implementing rules be made more cost-efficient? What is the simplification potential?

·EQ 4.4: Are results achieved so far commensurate with the resources put forward and in line with the ones expected from the ex-ante evaluation of INSPIRE?

·EQ 4.5: How proportionate were the costs of the intervention for different stakeholder groups (enterprises including SMEs, private citizens …)?

·EQ 4.6: Have the resources needed to implement INSPIRE been available?

·EQ 4.7: How has the use of INSPIRE for environmental reporting affected the reporting burden?

·EQ 4.8: How would further streamlining of the provisions in Articles 7 and 8 of Directive 2003/4/EC on public access to environmental information with the active dissemination provisions of the INSPIRE Directive impact the administrative burden on the Member States.

COHERENCE

·EQ 5.1: To what extent is INSPIRE coherent internally?

·EQ 5.2: To what extent is INSPIRE coherent with environmental legislation with geospatial reporting obligations?

·EQ 5.3: To what extent is INSPIRE coherent with other relevant areas of EU policy with geospatial reporting obligations (transport, agriculture, maritime, space, health, disaster management, research)?

·EQ 5.4: To what extent is INSPIRE coherent with Directive 2003/4/EC on public access to environmental information and the objectives of the Common European Green Deal data space?

·EQ 5.5: To what extent is INSPIRE coherent with Directive 2003/98/EC on the re-use of public sector information and what are the implications of Directive 2019/1024/EU?

EU ADDED VALUE

·EQ 6.1: What is the EU-added value of INSPIRE in comparison to what could be achieved at Member States national and/or regional level activities?

·EQ 6.2: To what extent do the issues addressed by INSPIRE continue to require action at EU level?

Annex 4: Logic of the Action

Part A: Detailed INSPIRE ImplemenTation Roadmap

(Source: EEA/JRC Technical report, 10/2014)

ARTICLE 

Milestone

DESCRIPTION 

21§1 21§2

15/05/2010

Implementation of provisions for  Monitoring and Reporting

6(a)

03/12/2010

Metadata available for spatial data sets and services corresponding to  Annex I and II

15 

30/06/2011

The EC establishes and runs a geo-portal at Community level

17(8)

19/10/2011

Implementation of  Regulation as regards the access to spatial data sets and services  of the Member States by Community institutions and bodies under harmonised conditions for new arrangements

16

09/11/2011

Discovery and view services  operational

7§3, 9(a)

23/11/2012

Implementation of  Commission Regulation (EU) No 1089/2010 of 23 November 2010  implementing Directive 2007/2/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council as regards interoperability of spatial data sets and services for Newly collected and extensively restructured  Annex I  spatial data sets

16

28/12/2012

Download services  operational

16

28/12/2012

Spatial data sets shall be available for download and transformation (whenever applicable) from the INSPIE Geo-portal ( data does not yet need to be conformant with the  COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 1089/2010 of 23 November 2010 implementing Directive 2007/2/EC  of the European Parliament and of the Council as regards interoperability of spatial data sets and services)

7§3, 9(a)

04/02/2013

Implementation of  Commission Regulation (EU) No 102/2011 of 4 February 2011  amending  Regulation (EU) No 1089/2010 implementing Directive 2007/2/EC  of the European Parliament and of the Council as regards interoperability of spatial data sets and services for newly collected and extensively restructured  Annex I  spatial data sets

17(8)

19/10/2013

Implementation of  Regulation as regards the access to spatial data sets and services  of the Member States by Community institutions and bodies under harmonised conditions for existing arrangements

6(b)

03/12/2013

Metadata available for spatial data sets and services corresponding to Annex III

7§3, 9(b)

21/10/2015

Newly collected and extensively restructured  Annex II and III  spatial data sets available

- 

10/12/2015

All invocable spatial data services shall be conformant to Annex V of  Commission Regulation (EU) No 1089/2010 as amended by Regulation (EU) No 1312/2014 of 10 December 2014  (...) as regards interoperability of spatial data services

-

10/12/2016

Invocable spatial data services related to newly collected and extensively restructured spatial data sets shall be conformant with Annex VI and, where practicable, Annex VII of  Commission Regulation (EU) No 1089/2010 as amended by  Regulation (EU) No 1312/2014  of 10 December 2014 as regards interoperability of spatial data services

7§3, 9(a)

23/11/2017

Implementation of  Commission Regulation (EU) No 1089/2010 of 23 November 2010  implementing Directive 2007/2/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council as regards interoperability of spatial data sets and services for other  Annex I  spatial data sets still in use at the date of adoption

7§3, 9(a)

04/02/2018

Implementation of  Commission Regulation (EU) No 102/2011  of 4 February 2011 amending  Regulation (EU) No 1089/2010  implementing Directive 2007/2/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council as regards interoperability of spatial data sets and services for other  Annex I  spatial data sets still in use at the date of adoption

7§3, 9(b)

21/10/2020

Other  Annex II and III  spatial data sets available in accordance with  IRs for Annex II and III

- 

10 /12/2021

All invocable spatial data services shall be conformant with Annexes VI and (where practicable) VII of  Commission Regulation (EU) No 1089/2010  as amended by  Regulation (EU) No 1312/2014 of 10 December 2014  (...) as regards interoperability of spatial data services

Source: European Commission (n.d.), INSPIRE roadmap.

Part B: Detailed INSPIRE INTERVENTION LOGIC

Annex 5: Coherence of INSPIRE with specific sectoral legislation and initiatives

Agriculture

Regulation (EU) No 1306/2013 on the financing, management and monitoring of the common agricultural policy set up the Integrated Administration and Control Systems (IACS), which is the main instrument for the management of the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) payments system. IACS allows the control of direct payments to farmers as well as others such as payments for agricultural practices beneficial for the climate and the environment and ensures the traceability of payments. The IACS system requires the establishment of several databases including: 8

·An identification system for agricultural parcels – the land parcel identification system (LPIS)

·A system enabling farmers to graphically indicate the agricultural areas for which they apply for aid (geospatial aid application - GSAA)

·A computerised database for animals in EU countries where animal-based aid schemes apply

·An integrated control system, for systematic checks of aid applications based on computerised cross checks and physical on-farm controls.

The LPIS and the GSAA are the main spatial information elements contained in IACS. Member States are responsible for designing and operating their own IACS system at national level through their accredited paying agencies. There is a total of 40 IACS systems in Europe (some Member States having regional systems as in Germany and Spain).

The need for spatial data sharing for the implementation of the CAP was stressed by Member States in the Declaration of cooperation on ‘A smart and sustainable digital future for European agriculture and rural areas’ 9  signed in April 2019 by almost all Member States. One of the proposed measures was to ‘increase CAP administration efficiency, notably in sharing geospatial information among public administrations’. The new CAP, which will apply from 2023, will provide a more significant focus on data sharing, in particular concerning the ambition to assess its environmental and climate performance, and the general objective of promoting digitalisation of agriculture.  10  

Regulation (EU) No 1306/2013 does not make reference to the INSPIRE Directive. However, a specific provision in the next CAP legislation - Art. 65 of the Horizontal Regulation (European Commission proposal not yet adopted) – will provide for the obligation to share geospatial information included in the IACS of the Member States in the context of the INSPIRE Directive. To support national Paying Agencies in this process, DG AGRI setup a process in collaboration with DG ENV and JRC with the aim to have an efficient access to data (use of INSPIRE) and an effective re-use of data (through use cases). An important arrangement AGRI/JRC “IACS 65” (with DG ENV support)has been concluded in 2020. In this context, Technical Guidelines on IACS spatial data sharing 11 through INSPIRE, focusing on data discovery, have been prepared. As reflected in the Technical Guidelines, the sharing of IACS data through INSPIRE will be done in two steps – discovery services will be implemented first; view and download services and data harmonisation will be dealt with in a second stage. 12

According to EU institutions and national authorities, one of the barriers are that LPIS is not a specific INSPIRE theme but that LPIS data may fit in a range of INSPIRE themes (Cadastral parcels, Land Use, Land Cover, Area management zones and reporting units, Agricultural facilities); another obstacle is that IACS contains sensitive or personal data, which, however, is generally not spatial data (farmers’ registers, entitlements, payments, applications for certain payment schemes), therefore not in the scope of the process setup by DG AGRI.  13

In the context of the new CAP, the INSPIRE infrastructure has been considered as an opportunity to have one single entry point for accessing IACS spatial (and non-personal) data, which is scattered across 40 national and regional systems. Using INSPIRE will facilitate the implementation of the new CAP provisions (in particular article 65 (Horizontal Regulation – HZR), as well as data sharing across administrations, and to some extent to the public. In addition, some of the IACS datasets have also been identified as High Value Datasets. In this perspective, IACS data sharing through INSPIRE is regarded as valuable. 14 In the framework of IACS 65 a new entry in INSPIRE geoportal is proposed to make IACS (limited to LPIS and GSAA) data more discoverable.

The second part of the Technical Guidelines will be published in 2021 15 . At present, nine Member States have implemented the first part of the Technical Guidelines (Belgium, Croatia, Denmark, Estonia, Germany, Latvia, Luxembourg, Slovakia and Slovenia). DG AGRI is anticipating that all Member States will have done so by the end of 2021.  16  As the Technical Guidelines are being implemented, it is too early to draw conclusions on the integration between national IACS systems and national INSPIRE SDIs.

Maritime Spatial Planning

Directive 2014/89/EU establishing a framework for maritime spatial planning (MSP Directive) introduced the concept of maritime spatial planning into EU legislation, with the aim to coordinate the different activities and uses of the sea (energy, transport, fisheries, aquaculture) while ensuring the protection of the environment, including resilience to climate change impacts. The MSP Directive requires all Member States to establish a maritime spatial plan. It leaves a large margin to national authorities to design it according to national governance structure, with the requirement to coordinate with other Member States bordering their marine waters in order to ensure that maritime spatial plans are coherent and coordinated in a shared basin (Article 11 of the MSP Directive). As the maritime spatial plans address industrial and commercial uses of the sea, which are activities impacting the marine environment, and their coexistence with the protection of marine ecosystems, the MSP Directive is relevant in the context of INSPIRE.

The MSP Directive requirements on data use and sharing explicitly refer to INSPIRE as a source of data for the establishment of maritime spatial plans and as a possible data sharing tool. Article 10 of the MSP Directive states that Member States should ‘organise the use of the best available data, and decide how to organise the sharing of information, necessary for maritime spatial plans’, including environmental, social and economic data, collected as per other EU legislation, and marine physical data about marine waters. For this purpose, Member States should make use of relevant instruments and tools already available under the Integrated Maritime Policy (e.g. EMODnet) and other relevant EU policies, ‘such as those mentioned in Directive 2007/2/EC’.

Data gathering is an important part of the establishment of the maritime spatial plans. Given the nature of the plans, they require the gathering of a wide range of diverse data – environmental data, data related to different sectors – and, in many cases, this data should be gathered in the cross-border context. 17 According to Abramic et all (2018), maritime uses and activities that must be considered in the MSP process 18 are largely covered by the INSPIRE 34 data themes and, as a result, a lot of the data needed for the MSP could potentially be available through INSPIRE, in particular in themes ‘Land use’, ‘Transport networks’, ‘Protected sites’, ‘Agricultural and Aquaculture Facilities’, ‘Energy resources’ or ‘Utilities’.  19 The requirement to fulfil some MSFD reporting requirements in accordance with INSPIRE should also ensure that environmental data needed for the MSP process is available in INSPIRE compliant format. In addition, interoperability across sectoral datasets could be beneficial for the establishment of the maritime spatial plan.  20

Data sharing obligations under the MSP Directive are linked to public participation requirements (Article 9) and monitoring and reporting requirements (Article 14). Public participation requirements include ‘informing all interested parties and consulting relevant stakeholders and authorities, and the public concerned, at an early stage in development of the plan’, and ensuring that ‘the relevant stakeholders and authorities, and the public concerned, have access to the plans once they are finalised’. Article 14 requires Member States to ‘send copies of the maritime spatial plans’, and ‘all subsequent updates’, to the European Commission and other Member States concerned. According to Abramic et al (2018), national SDIs should be used for sharing the maritime spatial plans with stakeholders, the European Commission and other Member States and therefore fulfil the requirements from Article 9 and 14. The article concluded in this respect that the Planned Land Use data model in INSPIRE is appropriate for sharing maritime spatial plans. This is however not explicitly required by the MSP Directive, which also does not require that maritime spatial plans are developed in digital formats, 21 but leaves Member States the choice of the format in which the plan should be established and published.

As mentioned above, cooperation between Member States sharing sea basins is required for consistency of planning (Article 11), and cooperation with third countries should be sought to the extent possible using existing international forums or regional institutional cooperation (Article 12). INSPIRE could also support cooperation across Member States and third countries through the sharing of interoperable data by allowing the combination of datasets from various national sources, and through the possibility to integrate national plans into a spatial plan for the entire marine region or sub-region. 22  The use of INSPIRE standards could resolve the current difficulties in harmonising maritime spatial plans across countries coming from the use of different data models and standard rules for layers and styles.  23 As mentioned above, this is however not part of the requirements of the MSP Directive. Article 10 does not contain requirements regarding the form in which the plans should be submitted. The absence of such requirements might reduce the possibility for harmonisation between plans within a marine region. This might also be limited by the fact that, although some third countries (EFTA members and some accession countries) participate to the implementation of INSPIRE, they do not have the same obligations as EU Member States in terms of compliance and some neighbouring countries do not participate in INSPIRE at all.

Although there is potential for INSPIRE to support the establishment and update of maritime spatial plans, there are still barriers to supporting the MSP process. The number of marine-related metadata records available in the geoportal is still low, and their availability varies greatly across Member States and marine regions. 24   25

The possibility to share maritime spatial plans through INSPIRE has been studied in several EU or regional projects. A pilot case has been carried out in 2019, through the Macaronesian Maritime Spatial Planning (MarSP) project, in which an MSP INSPIRE data model was developed based on the Planned Land Use data model.  26 HELCOM has developed, as part of the project Pan Baltic Scope ‘Guidelines on transboundary MSP output data structure in the Baltic Sea’,  27 data specifications for MSP output data (i.e. national MSP plans and planned sea uses), as well as a portal to access Baltic Sea MSP relevant data, including both input data (i.e. thematic data relevant for MSP purposes) and output data (i.e. national MSP plans and planned sea uses). The INSPIRE Data Specification on Land Use has been taken as guidance when designing the data model for output data. 28 These initiatives could be a basis for the further harmonisation of input and output MSP data with INSPIRE data models.

Another possibility to share maritime spatial plans is likely to be through the European Marine Observation and Data Network (EMODnet), the marine data portal initiated by DG MARE. 29 Work has been done since 2018 to align the EMODnet Human Activities’ portal 30 data models to INSPIRE’s Data Specifications. A first study published in February 2018 31 compared the EMODnet Human Activities’ datasets to the INSPIRE application schemas to identify actions that needed to be taken for further harmonisation. The study concluded that the harmonisation of EMODnet Human Activities’ datasets to INSPIRE application schemas could be difficult (as 17 INSPIRE application schemas could be applicable to 66 EMODnet Human Activities’ datasets, with more or less direct alignment depending on the themes). Following this report, the approach taken has been to harmonise EMODnet Human Activities datasets using the INSPIRE Land Use data model, following the approach taken in the MarSP project mentioned above.  32 Results from this harmonisation exercise with the INSPIRE Land Use data model have been presented online in a dedicated map viewer. 33 The final report from the study concluded that harmonising the EMODnet human activities datasets to the INSPIRE Land Use data model is feasible although some information from EMODnet's datasets are lost when applying the INSPIRE Land Use model, as there is no direct alignment between the two. The study came to a similar conclusion that the MarSP project mentioned above, that the HILUCS Land Use code list, used in the INSPIRE Land Use model is too broad to characterise many maritime uses, which results in several different datasets using the same HILUCS codes and therefore not being properly identified. To ensure better coherence between INSPIRE and EMODnet human activities data, the study recommended to provide more flexibility to extend the HILUCS Land Use code list and to extend data models with new attributes.  34  

Transport

TEN-T Guidelines

The TEN-T policy supports the development of a Europe-wide transport networks for all modes, including railway lines, roads, inland waterways, maritime shipping routes, ports, airports and railroad terminals. The TEN-T has a dual layer structure: the comprehensive network, which aims to ensure connectivity of all regions of the EU, and the core network, which consists of the elements of the network which are of the highest strategic importance for the EU, because they link the most important nodes and cover main cross-border connections. Regulation n°1315/2013 of 11 December 2013 on Union guidelines for the development of the trans-European transport network (the TEN-T Regulation) defines binding targets for implementation, as the core network needs to be implemented by 2030 and the comprehensive network by 2050. The TEN-T Regulation also establishes core network corridors which are operational tools for the implementation of the core network.

The TEN-T Regulation requires Member States report annually on the progress made in implementing transport projects and the investments made for that purpose (Article 49 of the TEN-T Regulation). Member States should report through the technical information system for the trans-European transport network (TENtec). 35  Similar information should also be provided by Member States through their national SDI as the TEN-T network is part of the INSPIRE ‘Transport networks’ data theme.  36 There is consequently some overlap between the TEN-T reporting and the creation of transport INSPIRE data sets, although the reporting under TEN-T also requires non-spatial data not covered by INSPIRE (such as financial data on transport projects).

The TEN-T Regulation currently does not refer to INSPIRE. The Regulation is however under revision and the evaluation of the TEN-T Regulation stated that the TEN-T Regulation should ‘consistently build on EU data sharing policies, such as the Open Data Directive and the Inspire Directive’.  37  

The information to be reported through TENtec as per the TEN-T Regulation and the information to be provided through INSPIRE are currently not entirely harmonised. Further improvements of TENtec are planned, in particular the implementation of a linear referenced network followed by an automated data exchange solution together with Member States, which will follow INSPIRE rules and standards as much as possible. The aim is to ensure that Member States only have to provide the information only once. Synergies between TENtec and INSPIRE could be further developed and collaboration between the European Commission services on this could be formalised. The current revision of the TEN-T Regulation, which should result in the adoption of a new Regulation in 2023, addresses issues linked to monitoring and reporting and could provide a basis to discuss whether and how links to INSPIRE could be created. 38 The data model of the TEN-T network with it specificities could be used under INSPIRE as a good practice. Initial discussions between DG MOVE and DG ENV have started.

Intelligent Transport Systems (ITS) Directive

Directive 2010/40/EU on the framework for the deployment of Intelligent Transport Systems in the field of road transport and for interfaces with other modes of transport (ITS Directive) establishes general conditions to support the coordinated and coherent deployment and use of Intelligent Transport Systems (ITS) across the EU in the field of road transport and its interfaces with other modes of transport. ITS are ‘systems in which information and communication technologies are applied in the field of road transport, including infrastructure, vehicles and users, and in traffic management and mobility management, as well as for interfaces with other modes of transport’ (Article 4 of the ITS Directive). Specifications addressing the compatibility, interoperability and continuity of ITS have been developed through five Delegated Regulations on safety-related traffic information; an EU eCall service; safe parking places for trucks and commercial vehicles; real-time traffic information services; and multimodal travel information services. A proposal for the revision of the ITS Directive has been adopted by the European Commission in December 2021, updating its scope in order to reflect the latest developments in the field (e.g. Mobility as a Service and Cooperative, Connected and Automated Mobility). Also, the proposal includes the objective to increase the availability of some of the data types listed in the Delegated Regulations by mandating the availability of specific crucial data types for a specified geographical coverage by a certain date. The ITS Directive and its Delegated Regulations cover activities which may have an impact on the environment and control the access to spatial data that may be of interest for environmental policies. They are in this respect relevant in the context of INSPIRE.

Delegated Regulation (EU) 2015/962 on the provision of EU-wide real-time traffic information services aims to ensure the accessibility, exchange, re-use and update of road and traffic data by road authorities, road operators and information service providers. Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/1926 on the provision of EU-wide multimodal travel information services controls the provision of accurate wide multimodal travel information services and their availability across borders to ITS users. Both Regulations require the establishment of National Access Points, which are single points of access for users to transport related data supplied by authorities, operators, infrastructure managers or service providers. Both Regulations cover both static data (related to the transport network, its physical attributes and data related to traffic signs, speed limits, facilities) and dynamic data (real time traffic information). Static data could potentially be shared through INSPIRE.

Both Delegated Regulations refer to the INSPIRE Directive as a tool to share data related to the transport network. Regulation (EU) 2017/1926 on the provision of EU-wide multimodal travel information services contains a requirement that transport authorities, operators, infrastructure managers or service providers provide static travel and traffic data and historic traffic data using ‘for the spatial network the requirements defined in Article 7 of Directive 2007/2/EC’ (Article 4(1)(c)). A similar requirement currently does not yet exist in the current Delegated Regulation (EU) 2015/962 on the provision of EU-wide real-time traffic information services. However, Recital 6 of this Regulation states that ‘the specifications set out in this Regulation should be compatible with the specifications established by Directive 2007/2/EC’ and a revision process of the legal text was started in 2020. Article 4 of the Delegated Regulation has been revised to support the use of INSPIRE data specification on transport networks, along with other data standards used for traffic information exchange (such as Datex II) 39 . As a result, the revised Delegated Regulation (EU) 2015/962 has been be aligned with Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/1926 and the coherence with INSPIRE regarding static data has been ensured, at least legally. The revision also extends the geographical scope of the Delegated Regulation to the entire road network, and includes a number of new data types linked to traffic regulations and restrictions. 

The gaps, overlaps and alignment potential between standards used in the transport area has been investigated in two JRC studies – a study related to the EULF transportation pilot in 2016,  40 which investigated the possibility of road safety data sharing drawing on INSPIRE specifications, and more recently, the INSPIRE-MMTIS study, carried out in 2019 on overlaps in standards related to the Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/1926.  41 The 2019 study examined how INSPIRE related with other standards used in the transport domain (Transmodel, NeTEX, DATEX, IATA, TAP-TSI and INSPIRE) and provided recommendations to Member States on the usage of the various standards for the different data categories covered by the delegated regulation. 42  

The link between the ITS Regulations and INSPIRE was explicitly made in the legislation to avoid creating overlapping datasets, and to make sure that Member States could use INSPIRE data, where considered relevant by national authorities, to fulfil data requirements of ITS Regulations. As a result, if a national authority considers that the data already made available through INSPIRE is of sufficient quality to fulfil some of the requirements under the ITS Regulations, they can consider themselves compliant by making a link to the INSPIRE via the National Access Point.  43

Although using INSPIRE data to fulfil the data requirements of the ITS Regulations is in theory possible, experience has shown that, in practice, it might not often be the case that INSPIRE is sufficiently accurate. Quality requirements for data needed for real-time travel and traffic information services are high – for instance, such data must be very regularly updated to provide real time accurate information. The data available in INSPIRE, updated annually, might not be sufficiently recent for the types of services developed under ITS. Another example relates to spatial accuracy – the spatial accuracy in INSPIRE might not be sufficient for navigation services and automated driving. In some cases, INSPIRE data does not match ITS requirements – regarding cycling infrastructure, not all types of cycling lanes (on road and in separated lanes) are represented in INSPIRE, which is leading Member States or private initiatives to develop separate datasets on cycling infrastructure.  44

Climate adaptation (including disaster management)

The new Strategy on adaptation to climate change,  45 adopted in February 2021, includes as one of its four main objectives to make adaptation ‘smarter’, by improving knowledge on climate impacts and adaptation solutions, improving data availability to inform policy decisions, and developing Climate-ADAPT as the authoritative European platform for adaptation knowledge. The Strategy in particular highlights the need to gather more and better scientific data on climate-related risks and losses to improve climate risk assessment and decision-making. In this regard, the Strategy mentions that the review of the INSPIRE Directive offers an opportunity to extend the scope of INSPIRE to cover environmental and climate-related disaster loss data, with a view to facilitate access to climate-related risk and losses data for stakeholders.

The rationale behind the inclusion in the Strategy on adaptation to climate change of an objective to collect ‘More and better climate-related risk and losses data’ (section 2.1.2. of the Strategy) came from the observation that access to climate-related risk and loss data 46 in Europe was poor. Based on this observation, a European Commission inter-service group was created, including one working group on data, which was tasked to do an inventory of the data needs and propose ways to improve the collection and sharing of climate-related disaster loss data and its quality. Including climate-related disaster loss into the scope of the INSPIRE Directive was a recommendation from this working group.  47 For the time being, the focus of the work has been mainly on data collection and recording, not yet on data sharing. To go further, discussions will be initiated with other European Commission services on how climate-related risk and loss data can be included in INSPIRE. 48

Although the Strategy focuses on climate related issues, there is an understanding across the European Commission that the scope of climate-related risk and losses data could, when included in INSPIRE, cover more than climate issues, such as natural disasters (e.g. volcano eruptions). 49

As climate-related risk and loss data covers several types of climate change impacts (droughts, floods, wildfires, storms, etc.), and sectors (such as agriculture, forestry, transport, buildings and infrastructure, and human health), many INSPIRE data themes might be relevant and might already contain part of the data needed. A full screening and comparison of INSPIRE data sets and the required climate-related risk and loss data has not yet been carried out. This would be necessary to identify possible amendments to INSPIRE data specifications and where new datasets are needed. Based on an indicative screening, it is likely that some socioeconomic data indicating the geographic distribution of assets will require the creation of new datasets. 50

A potential barrier for the inclusion of climate-related risks and losses data into INSPIRE might be the need to collect data from both public and private data providers. Insurance and reinsurance companies are relevant private data providers in this area – currently the EEA indicator on losses from weather and climate-related is based on data from MunichRe. The INSPIRE Directive however only covers spatial data held by public authorities and there are not yet any obligations for private companies to share data.

Climate ADAPT

Climate-ADAPT 51 is the information platform on climate adaptation, created as a partnership between the European Commission and the EEA. Climate-ADAPT currently contains two different spatial data features:

·An Urban Adaptation Map Viewer 52 , which might be further developed/extended in the future. Data used in the map viewer are collated by the EEA from various sources.

·A version of this map viewer specifically for health and climate-related topics in the new European Climate and Health Observatory 53 .

The map services provided by the EEA on Climate-ADAPT are compatible with the INSPIRE directive. The metadata are already fully INSPIRE compliant, and although the services may still need some fine-tuning, they do follow the INSPIRE main standards. The map services could be integrated into the EU/national SDI as the metadata (including the links to services) is provided via INSPIRE compliant discovery services. 54

From June 2021, the EEA is providing access to climate related indicators provided by the Copernicus Climate Change Service. The Copernicus Climate Change Service provides data and products that are described using the ISO19115 metadata record standard and are made available through the OAI-PMH and OGC-CSW protocols for interoperability with the World Meteorological Organization Information System and the EU’s INSPIRE initiative, respectively. 55

Space Policy / Copernicus

The EU space policy aims to harness the potential of space technology, data and services to provide services (navigation systems, satellite TV, meteorology, transport safety etc.), and support policy development. The Space Strategy for Europe 56 , adopted in 2016, highlights that ‘data and services derived from space systems, including satellite images, geo-positioning information and satellite communications’ can strongly contribute to various public policies, including environmental protection, climate, disaster management, transport, agriculture or fisheries. The EU space policy is implemented through three flagship space programmes: Copernicus, the EU’s Earth observation programme, which is the most relevant of the three programmes in relation to INSPIRE, Galileo, Europe's global satellite navigation system, and EGNOS, the European Geostationary Navigation Overlay Service, which provides navigation services to aviation, maritime and land-based users in Europe. 57

Copernicus is managed by the European Commission, together with partners such as the Member States, the European Space Agency, or the European Organisation for the Exploitation of Meteorological Satellites. The programme provides data, information and services based on satellite Earth Observation data and in situ (non-space) data. 58 Copernicus offers six thematic services 59 . These services rely on data coming from a set of dedicated satellites (the Sentinels) and contributing missions (existing commercial and public satellites) 60 , as well as on in situ monitoring networks (e.g. ground based weather stations, ocean buoys and air quality monitoring networks) managed by the Member States. The EEA is coordinating the in-situ component of Copernicus at EU level. 61

Copernicus is closely related to INSPIRE as Copernicus Services require access to harmonised geospatial information at EU level to produce and validate a number of their products. In situ data required by the Copernicus Services and the INSPIRE data themes also clearly overlap, 62 as they include geospatial reference data (e.g. transport networks, administrative boundaries, elevation models). As a result, INSPIRE can support the objectives of Copernicus as it ensures that more datasets will gradually be discoverable and accessible by the Copernicus Service. In turn, this might create demand for INSPIRE data. 63 On the other hand, the fact that many geospatial datasets and services produced by Copernicus follow INSPIRE guidelines 64 should increase their interoperability and support the objectives of INSPIRE.

The alignment between INSPIRE and Copernicus services is required in the legislation. The former Copernicus Regulation (Regulation (EU) No 377/2014 65 ), no longer in force, provided that ‘Copernicus data should be compliant with Member States' spatial reference data as well as with implementing rules and technical guidelines of the infrastructure for spatial information in the Union established by Directive 2007/2/EC’ (Recital 9). This obligation is also present in Article 5.2 of Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) No 1159/2013, 66 which requires that ‘dedicated data and Global Monitoring for Environment and Security (GMES) service information – including Copernicus – shall comply with the requirements of Directive 2007/2/EC to the extent that the data and information fall within the scope of those provisions.’ Discovery, view and download services of the various Copernicus services available follow INSPIRE standards. 67

Regarding the contribution of INSPIRE to Copernicus in situ data, Regulation (EU) 2021/696 68 establishing the Union Space Programme states that ‘Where feasible and appropriate, Copernicus should also make use of the available in-situ and ancillary data provided mainly by the Member States in accordance with Directive 2007/2/EC’ and recommends that ‘the Commission should work together with the Member States and the European Environment Agency to ensure an efficient access and use of the in-situ data sets for Copernicus’ (Recital 72). The EEA launched a study in 2017 to assess whether Copernicus services benefit from the implementation of INSPIRE, and if known gaps in in-situ data can be closed with the continued implementation of INSPIRE. 69 The main conclusions of the study were that INSPIRE and Copernicus share key requirements, as they both aim to use spatial data harmonised across borders, and that INSPIRE is a good source of data to add to the Copernicus in-situ component and support the services, but that the current status of implementation of INSPIRE still prevents the full contribution of INSPIRE to Copernicus. As not all data is fully harmonised yet, usable data for Copernicus services is only progressively made available. 70

Annex 6: State of play details based on INSPIRE reporting and monitoring obligations.

Coordination, governance structure, data sharing arrangements and usage of the infrastructure

To ensure a relevant governance structure, each Member State and EEA/EFTA country designated a National Contact Point (NCP), usually a public authority, to be responsible for contacts with the European Commission in relation to the INSPIRE Directive. The NCPs are responsible for collecting the information about the implementation of the INSPIRE Directive and report on behalf of their country to the European Commission.

The Member States and EEA/ EFTA countries have set up different coordination and governance structures for their implementation of the Directive, depending on their governance culture and constitutional organisation. In some cases, the INSPIRE implementation was entrusted to mapping and cadastral agencies, which could result in lack of coordination with the environment authorities and a lesser focus in terms of availability of Annex III data sets (compared to Annex I and Annex II data sets). In most Member States the current governance structure addressed the need for coordination across different types of authorities. Currently, around two thirds of countries show a positive development ensuring an effective coordination.

As regards the data sharing and usage of the infrastructure among stakeholders, the documentation of spatial data sets and services through metadata helped improve the situation by making the public authorities aware of their availability. It is important to ensure availability of view and download services which can be reused by targeted applications. 71 The supporting Study shows that in several countries, open data strategies and other national initiatives are separate from the INSPIRE related processes, however, they do not conflict with the principles and ambition of the INSPIRE Directive. In some other countries, use cases are being developed and the INSPIRE infrastructure can be used for other data work streams, which brings a desired complementarity and an increased added value of the INSPIRE Directive.

The table below ( Table 21 ) shows the overall implementation status regarding coordination as well as data sharing arrangements and usage of the infrastructure in 2016 and in 2020. The scoring thresholds are as follows: green smiley (top performance), yellow smiley (middle performance) and red smiley (low performance). For the 2016 baseline, the Summary Report on Status of implementation of the INSPIRE Directive in EU, published by JRC in 2017 72 was used. 

Table 21: Implementation status across EU Member States regarding coordination, data sharing arrangements and usage of the infrastructure

Effective coordination

Data sharing arrangements and usage of the infrastructure

2016

2020

2016

2020

Austria

Belgium

Bulgaria

Croatia

Cyprus

Czech Republic

Denmark

Estonia

Finland

France

Germany

Greece

Hungary

Ireland

Italy

Latvia

Lithuania

Luxembourg

Malta

Netherlands

Poland

Portugal

Romania

Slovakia

Slovenia

Spain

Sweden

Performance monitoring based on the INSPIRE monitoring indicators 73

To ensure better comparison pre- and post-2019, the results for the entire period from 2014 to 2020 have been aligned to the new indicator framework established in the most recent reporting Decision. All 19 indicators measure implementation of the INSPIRE Directive and are grouped into 5 categories (see Table 22 ) that are in line with the envisaged outputs according the intervention logic and the main implementation steps required by the INSPIRE Directive.

Table 22 Implementation categories and corresponding indicators

Implementation category

Codes of monitoring indicators

Availability of spatial data and services 74  

DSi1.1, DSi1.2, DSi1.3, DSi1.4, DSi1.5

Conformity of metadata

MDi.1.1, MDi1.2

Conformity of spatial data sets

DSi2, DSi2.1, DSi2.2, DSi2.3

Accessibility of spatial data sets through view and download services

NSi.2, NSi2.1, NSi2.2

Conformity of network services

NSi.4, NSI.4.1, NSi.4.2, NSi.4.3, NSi.4.4

All indicators except those related to the availability of spatial data and services are presented in a percentage, thus providing a direct measure of performance. 75 In graphical presentations of chronological results, a shift in trend between 2018 and 2019 is clearly outlined, showing a change in monitoring and reporting process that was driven by the new Implementing Decision. Furthermore, a transition from the Metadata Technical Guidance v. 1.3 to Technical Guidance v. 2.0 also played a role in determining a shifting trend (also between 2019 and 2020) as at the end of the transition period in December 2019, only 3% of the total number of metadata from all countries were encoded according to Technical Guidance v. 2.0.

For a more comprehensive overview of the overall performance of the countries, four distinct implementation groups have been defined that are used to group countries based on their performance:

•Group I: 80-100%

•Group II: 55-79%

•Group III: 30-54%

•Group IV: 0-29%

 The map below ( Figure 15 ) shows the four implementation groups when considering the overall set of monitoring indicators. The countries are quite evenly spread across the four groups, which shows considerable differences between the countries regardless of the geographic location.

Figure 15 INSPIRE implementation, based on the INSPIRE performance indicators, 2020

Availability of spatial data sets and services

As shown in Figure 16 , the total number of spatial data sets and services with metadata offered across Europe in December 2020 equalled 179,186 records, comprising of 83,805 data sets and 95,381 spatial data services. 2,068 spatial data sets were used for reporting under the environmental legislation, i.e. priority data sets. Overall, 12,917 were regional data sets and 4,456 data sets were tagged as national.

In terms of availability of data sets, there were now fewer available than in 2016. The JRC report showed that by mid-2016, Member States had identified more than 90,000 spatial data sets with relation to the themes listed in the INSPIRE annexes. 76 These records did not even include the data sets reported by the EFTA/ EEA countries. Although in some cases this is a result of data cleaning processes at national level, aiming at aggregating local and regional datasets and deleting for users irrelevant data sets and/or duplicates of data sets, one of the reasons for removing data sets is also that the Member States see this as an opportunity to improve their overall performance.

The number of data sets and services varies across countries and regions. In the recent years, several countries reduced the number of spatial data sets, for example, by combining several local and regional data sets into national ones. Thus, the number of data sets and services does not show any findings in terms of implementation maturity; it only presents the overall picture together with other indicators.

Figure 16 Availability of spatial data sets and services

77

Conformity of metadata

As regards the indicators related to the conformity of metadata for spatial data sets and spatial data services, the values are heterogeneous across countries, spanning from 0% to 100%. One third of all the listed countries are placed in the best implementation group, Group I. The number of countries is slightly higher in the first two implementation groups (Group I and Group II) compared to the number of countries in the last two groups ( Figure 17 ).

Figure 17    INSPIRE implementation based on the INSPIRE monitoring indicators related to the conformity of metadata (MDi.1.1, MDi1.2), 2020

As can be seen in the graph presenting the implementation status from 2014 and 2020 (see Figure 18 ), the average values for both indicators were rather low in 2020, i.e. 59% for MDi1.1 and 55% for MDi1.2.

There is a significant shift in the trend between 2018 and 2019 because the values related to these two indicators were until 2018 reported based on the old indicator scheme. From 2019 onwards, the indicators are calculated using the INSPIRE Reference Validator. Transition to the new version of the Technical Guidance (TG v. 2.0) importantly contributed to the shift in trends. As described in the country forms, countries reported additional issues that contributed to the drop in performance from above 90% in 2018 to around 50% in 2019, including structural problems, and software configuration accessibility restrictions. Some of the problems were resolved in the in the reference year 2020, which is also visible in the column presenting the performance results in 2020.

Figure 18 Conformity of metadata with Regulation (EC) No 1205/2008 78    

Conformity of spatial data sets

When it comes to the spatial data sets, which are conformant with Commission Regulation (EU) No 1089/2010 as regards interoperability of spatial data sets, four indicators are being used to assess the performance: DSi2 (overall percentage of conformant spatial data sets) and three indicators reflecting the conformity of spatial data ts corresponding to the themes listed in Annex I (DSi2.1), Annex II (DSi2.2) and Annex III (DSi2.3). The values of these indicators are calculated using the INSPIRE Geoportal. The information about conformity is included in the metadata of spatial data sets and is self-declared by the Member States. As outlined in the map below ( Figure 19 ), the performance of countries is very heterogeneous. The values spanned from 3% to 100% in the reference year 2020. One third of all the listed countries were located in the second-best implementation group, Group II.

Figure 19 INSPIRE implementation based on the INSPIRE monitoring indicators related to the conformity of spatial data sets (DSi2, DSi2.1, DSi2.2, DSi2.3), 2020

The graph below ( Figure 20 ) demonstrates a significant shift in trend between 2018 and 2019 that resulting an increase in compliance, despite the change in monitoring and reporting process. The aggregated value for DSi2 increased from 20% in 2018 to 47% in 2019. The reason behind is that the deadlines for implementation of the spatial data set interoperability were in 2018 and 2019 still in the future: 23 November 2017 for Annex I data and 21 October 2020 for Annex II and III data. In 2020, the situation further improved and the average value of indicator DSi2 reached 50%. An interpretation of these results must take into consideration that these indicators will in many cases never reach 100%, since majority of countries provide their national data sets ('as-is' data) in addition to the INSPIRE harmonised data sets.

Figure 20 Conformity of spatial data sets 79

Accessibility of spatial data sets through view and download services

Three indicators measure the actual accessibility of INSPIRE spatial data sets from a user perspective: NSi2 corresponds to the percentage of spatial data sets accessible through both view and download services; NSi2.1 corresponds to the percentage of spatial data sets that are accessible through view services and NSi2.2 measures the accessibility of data sets through download services. The values of these indicators are calculated using the INSPIRE Geoportal, which, based on the metadata records harvested from national catalogues, aim to establish linkages between metadata of spatial data sets and those of spatial data services (in particular view and download services). When linkages are found, the data set is classified as viewable and/or downloadable. 80

As illustrated in the map below ( Figure 21 ), the performance of countries is quite heterogeneous, with majority of countries (17 out of 31) located in the lowest two implementation groups. In 2020, 42% of datasets were available through both view and download services (NSi2), 50% were viewable (NSi2.1) and 50% were downloadable (NSi2.2). This means that around half of available data sets were not yet accessible across the EU Member States and EEA/ EFTA countries.

Figure 21    INSPIRE implementation based on the INSPIRE monitoring indicators related to the accessibility of spatial data sets through view and download services (NSi.2, NSi2.1, NSi2.2), 2020

The graph below ( Figure 22 ) shows a stable trend between 2014 and 2018, followed by a relatively significant drop in performance in 2019 due to the change in monitoring and reporting process. The situation has considerably improved in the next reporting round (reference year 2020).

Figure 22    Accessibility of spatial data sets through view and download services 81

Conformity of network services

The last five indicators measure the conformity of spatial network services. While the indicator NSi4 measures the overall percentage of conformant network services, indicators NSi4.1, NSi4.2, NSi4.3 and NSi4.4 correspond to the conformant portions of each type of network services, i.e. discovery services, view services, download services and transformation services, respectively. The calculation of performance is based on self-declaration of conformity included in the network service metadata harvested from the INSPIRE Geoportal. 82 With the exception of NSi4.4 (related to the conformity of transformation services), the values of all monitoring indicators reached similar values in 2020. The average share of conformant discovery, view and download services was 65%, 65% and 62%, respectively. The overall average percentage of conformant network services amounted to 63%.

The statistical analysis related to the conformity of transformation services (NSi4.4) is not considered in this current status analysis due to the extremely low availability of transformation services across countries. Thus, the scoring in the country forms is further adapted by excluding the indicator NSi4.4 in the assessment of conformity of network services. When omitting this indicator, more than a half of countries (16 out of 31) is positioned in the group of 'group I' implementers ( Figure 23 ), with overall average values of four indicators spanning from 80% to 100%.

Figure 23 INSPIRE implementation based on the INSPIRE monitoring indicators related to the conformity of network services (NSi.4, NSI.4.1, NSi.4.2, NSi.4.3), 2020

As presented in the graph below (see Figure 24 ), the performance over the reporting years has remained fairly stable. The average value of indicator NSi.4 has been reported to reach between 43% to 63% between 2014 and 2020. The overview of annual results is marked with a slight shift in the trend in 2018 and 2019, when the average values slightly decreased, mostly due to the introduction of the new monitoring and reporting process in 2019.

Figure 24    Conformity of the network services 83

(1)      070201/2020/837303/SFRA/ENV.E.4 implementing Framework Contract no. ENV.F.1/FRA/2019/0001
(2)   https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/law-making-process/evaluating-and-improving-existing-laws/refit-making-eu-law-simpler-less-costly-and-future-proof/fit-future-platform-f4f_en
(3)   https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/law-making-process/evaluating-and-improving-existing-laws/refit-making-eu-law-simpler-less-costly-and-future-proof/fit-future-platform-f4f/annual-work-programme_en  
(4)   https://ec.europa.eu/info/sites/default/files/final_opinion_2021_sbgr2_09_directive_establishing_an_infrastructure_for_spatial_information_in_the_european_community.pdf  
(5) https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/better-regulation/have-your-say/initiatives/12427-Sharing-geospatial-data-on-the-environment-evaluation-INSPIRE-Directive-_en
(6)      The public consultation questionnaire is available in Appendix I of the Report on the public consultation.
(7)      The report on the public consultation is available in Appendix 5 of the evaluation report.
(8)      European Commission, Integrated Administration and Control System (IACS): https://ec.europa.eu/info/food-farming-fisheries/key-policies/common-agricultural-policy/financing-cap/financial-assurance/managing-payments_en (Last accessed on 14 May 2021)
(9)

     Declaration - A smart and sustainable digital future for European agriculture and rural areas, April 2019: https://ec.europa.eu/newsroom/dae/items/648242 (Last accessed on 14 May 2021)

(10)

     Mohamed El Aydam, European Commission – DG AGRI D3, Integrated Administration Control System : which data for sharing? Presentation at INSPIRE Conference, 3 June 2020: https://inspire.ec.europa.eu/sites/default/files/inspire2020_greendataspace_iacs_land_use_data.pdf (Last accessed on 14 May 2021)

(11)      Ibid.
(12)      Ibid. 
(13)

     Tóth, K. (Joint Research Centre), CAP and INSPIRE: history, perspectives and challenges. Presentation at Eurogeographics INSPIRE extension workshop, Marne la Vallée, 20-21 June, 2017.

(14)

     Scoping interview with DG AGRI.

(15)

     Ibid.

(16)

     Ibid. 

(17)

     Abramic, A., Bigagli, E., Barale, V., Assouline, M., Lorenzo Alonso, A. and Norton, C. (2018) Maritime Spatial Planning supported by Infrastructure for Spatial Information in Europe (INSPIRE), Ocean and Coastal Management, 152, p. 23-36.

(18)

     Activities listed in Article 8 of the MSP Directive: aquaculture and fishing areas, installations and infrastructures for the exploration, exploitation and extraction of oil, of gas and other energy resources, of minerals and aggregates, and for the production of energy from renewable sources, maritime transport routes and traffic flows, military training areas, nature and species conservation sites and protected areas, raw material extraction areas, scientific research, submarine cable and pipeline routes, tourism, underwater cultural heritage.

(19)

     Abramic, et al. (2018) Maritime Spatial Planning supported by Infrastructure for Spatial Information in Europe (INSPIRE), Ocean and Coastal Management, 152, p. 23-36.

(20)

     Ibid.

(21)

     Ibid. 

(22)      Ibid.
(23)

     Ibid.

(24)

     Ibid.

(25)

     Strategic Environmental Assessment North Sea Energy(SEANSE) (2018) Analysis of Data Needs and Existing Gaps: https://northseaportal.eu/downloads/ (Last accessed on 14 May 2021).

(26)

     Abramic A, Garcia A, Tello Antón O, Agudo LM, Bruque Carmona G, Zanella A, Norton C, Haroun R. (2019) Data specification for Maritime Spatial Planning INSPIRE data model, Macaronesian Maritime Spatial Planning (MarSP) C-3PO - D.5.1, Version 1.0:

http://www.marsp.eu/media/files/61/marspwp5d51mspinspiredatamodel.pdf (Last accessed on 14 May 2021).

(27)

     HELCOM (VASAB CSPD/BSR) (2019) Guidelines on transboundary MSP output data structure in the Baltic Sea: https://vasab.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/Guidelines-on-transboundary-MSP-output-data-structure-ADOPTEDbyVASAB__HELCOM.pdf (Last accessed on 14 May 2021).

(28)      Andžej Miloš, Transboundary MSP output data in the Baltic Sea: https://inspire.ec.europa.eu/sites/default/files/8_andzej_m._basemaps.pdf (Last accessed on 14 May 2021).
(29)      EMODnet Central Portal: https://emodnet.eu/en (Last accessed on 17 May 2021)
(30)

     EMODnet Human Activities: https://www.emodnet-humanactivities.eu/ (Last accessed on 17 May 2021)

(31)

     Sagarminaga, Y., Solaun, O. (2018) EMODNET human activities data models: towards compliance with INSPIRE DATA Specifications. EMODnet Phase III, Task Report, "Analyze compliance with INSPIRE”: https://webgate.ec.europa.eu/maritimeforum/en/system/files/EMODNET_INSPIRE_data_models_comparison.pdf (Last accessed on 17 May 2021).

(32)

     Sagarminaga, Y., EMODNET-Human activities : steps forward for INSPIRE compliance. Presentation at the Virtual Workshop “Exploring and applying INSPIRE principles within Maritime Spatial Planning”, at the INSPIRE Conference 2020, 12 June 2020: https://inspire.ec.europa.eu/sites/default/files/2_yolanda_s._azti_emodnet.pdf (Last accessed on 17 May 2021).

(33)      INSPIRE Land Use - EMODnet's Human Activities Locations Dataset: http://oceandata.azti.es/thredds/fileServer/EMODNET_HA/EMODNET_INSPIRE_webgis.html  (Last accessed on 05 July 2021).
(34)      Sagarminaga, Y., Solaun, O, Menchaca, I., Franco, J. (2020) Implementation of the INSPIRE Land Use Theme (LU) for EMODnet Human activities datasets. EMODnet Phase III, Task Report: http://oceandata.azti.es/thredds/fileServer/EMODNET_HA/INSPIRE_LAND_USE_4_EMODNET_2020.pdf (Last accessed on 05 July 2021).
(35)      TENtec: https://ec.europa.eu/transport/infrastructure/tentec/tentec-portal/site/index_en.htm
(36)      D2.8.I.7Data Specification on Transport Networks–Technical Guidelines, 2014: https://inspire.ec.europa.eu/id/document/tg/tn  
(37)      European Commission (2021) Commission Staff Working Document. Evaluation of the Regulation (EU) N° 1315/2013 on Union Guidelines for the development of a trans-European transport network. SWD(2021) 117 final.
(38)      Based on information provided in writing by DG MOVE, TENtec Team. 
(39) Datex II: https://www.datex2.eu  
(40)      Pignatelli, F ; Boguslawski, R ; Borzacchiello, M. T (2016) Improving accuracy in road safety data exchange for navigation systems. European Union Location Framework Transportation Pilot, Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg, JRC104569: https://joinup.ec.europa.eu/collection/european-union-location-framework-eulf/document/report-improving-accuracy-road-safety-data-exchange-navigation-systems-european-union-location (Last accessed on 26.05.21).
(41)      Bourée, K., De Vries, B., Duquesne, C., Dodson, C., Jugelt, S., Martirano, G., Minghini, M. and Pignatelli, F. (2019) INSPIRE-MMTIS: overlap in standards related to the Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/1926, Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg, JRC118744: https://publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/handle/JRC118744 (Last accessed on 26.05.21). 
(42)      INSPIRE support to Multi-Modal Travel Information Services: https://joinup.ec.europa.eu/collection/elise-european-location-interoperability-solutions-e-government/inspire-support-multi-modal-travel-information-services (Last accessed on 26.05.21). 
(43)

     Scoping interview with DG MOVE.

(44)

     Scoping interview with DG MOVE.

(45)      European Commission (2021) Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions. Forging a climate-resilient Europe - the new EU Strategy on Adaptation to Climate Change. COM(2021) 82 final. 
(46)      This data comprise direct economic losses from physical climate change impacts, including public and private (citizens and businesses) losses from buildings, infrastructure, agriculture and commercial forestry operations and from the private and public cost of emergency response and recovery.
(47)      Scoping interview with DG CLIMA, Unit A.3 – Adaptation, and the EEA, 16 April 2021.
(48)      Scoping interview with DG CLIMA, Unit A.3 – Adaptation, and the EEA, 16 April 2021.
(49)      Scoping interview with DG CLIMA, Unit A.3 – Adaptation, and the EEA, 16 April 2021.
(50)      Scoping interview with DG CLIMA, Unit A.3 – Adaptation, and the EEA, 16 April 2021.
(51)      Climate-ADAPT: https://climate-adapt.eea.europa.eu/  
(52)      Urban Adaptation Map Viewer : https://climate-adapt.eea.europa.eu/knowledge/tools/urban-adaptation  
(53)      European Climate and Health Observatory : https://climate-adapt.eea.europa.eu/observatory/evidence/projections-and-tools/urban-adaptation-mapviewer-health-focus/  
(54)      Scoping interview with DG CLIMA, Unit A.3 – Adaptation, and the EEA, 16 April 2021.
(55)      Scoping interview with DG CLIMA, Unit A.3 – Adaptation, and the EEA, 16 April 2021.
(56)      European Commission (2016) Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions. Space Strategy for Europe. COM(2016) 705 final.
(57)      European Commission, Space : https://ec.europa.eu/growth/sectors/space_en  
(58)      Copernicus in detail : https://www.copernicus.eu/en/about-copernicus/copernicus-detail  
(59)      Copernicus services: https://www.copernicus.eu/en/copernicus-services  
(60)      Copernicus in detail : https://www.copernicus.eu/en/about-copernicus/copernicus-detail  
(61)      In situ component: https://www.copernicus.eu/en/about-copernicus/infrastructure/situ-component  
(62)      Henrik Steen Andersen (2017) Report from workshop: Has the Copernicus services’ access to geospatial data been improved through the implementation of INSPIRE? at the INSPIRE Conference 2017, 4-5 September 2017: https://inspire.ec.europa.eu/conference2017/workshops#c_32_235  
(63)      Henrik Steen Andersen (2017) Report from workshop: Has the Copernicus services’ access to geospatial data been improved through the implementation of INSPIRE? at the INSPIRE Conference 2017, 4-5 September 2017: https://inspire.ec.europa.eu/conference2017/workshops#c_32_235  
(64)      Minghini, M., Cetl, V., Kotsev, A., Tomas, R., Lutz, M. (2021) INSPIRE: The Entry Point to Europe’s Big Geospatial Data Infrastructure, Chapter 24 in M. Werner, Y.-Y. Chiang (eds.), Handbook of Big Geospatial Data. Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2021.
(65)      Regulation (EU) No 377/2014 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 3 April 2014 establishing the Copernicus Programme and repealing Regulation (EU) No 911/2010. OJ L 122, 24.4.2014, p. 44–66. This Regulation was repealed by Regulation (EU) 2021/696. See footnote 188.
(66)      Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) No 1159/2013 of 12 July 2013 supplementing Regulation (EU) No 911/2010 of the European Parliament and of the Council on the European Earth monitoring programme (GMES) by establishing registration and licensing conditions for GMES users and defining criteria for restricting access to GMES dedicated data and GMES service information. OJ L 309, 19.11.2013, p. 1–6.
(67)      Facchini, M. (DG GROW, Copernicus Unit). Copernicus. Synergies between the EU Copernicus programme and INSPIRE. Presentation at the INSPIRE Conference 2016, 28/09/2016.
(68)      Regulation (EU) 2021/696 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 28 April 2021 establishing the Union Space Programme and the European Union Agency for the Space Programme and repealing Regulations (EU) No 912/2010, (EU) No 1285/2013 and (EU) No 377/2014 and Decision No 541/2014/EU. OJ L 170, 12.5.2021, p. 69–148.
(69)      Reitz, T., Roller J., Rip F., Bulens, J. (2018) INSPIRE Servicing Copernicus (INSCope). European Environmental Agency, EEA/ IDM/R0/16/010 - Annex 5.
(70)      Ibid. 
(71)      Cetl V., V. Nunes de Lima, R. Tomas, M. Lutz, J. D'Eugenio, A. Nagy, J. Robbrecht (2017), Summary Report on Status of implementation of the INSPIRE Directive in EU. EUR 28930 EN. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.
(72)      Cetl V., V. Nunes de Lima, R. Tomas, M. Lutz, J. D'Eugenio, A. Nagy, J. Robbrecht (2017), Summary Report on Status of implementation of the INSPIRE Directive in EU. EUR 28930 EN. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.
(73)  Minghini M., Cetl V., Ziemba L., Tomas R., Francioli D., Artasensi D., Epure E., Vinci F. - Establishing a new baseline for monitoring the status of EU Spatial Data Infrastructure, Experiences and conclusions from INSPIRE 2019 monitoring and reporting, EUR 30513 EN, Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg 2020, ISBN 978-92-76-27384-4, doi:10.2760/296219, JRC122351, https://publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/handle/JRC122351   
(74)      The indicators for availability of spatial data and services operate with absolute numbers and therefore cannot present any trends.
(75)      For the indicators, where the entry provided was #N/A, the value in the calculation was considered as an empty cell, which does not have an effect on the average performance results. In general, the entry #N/A means "not reported", which was mostly the case when it comes to the indicator NSi4.4 (conformity of transformation services). In 2020, this indicator was reported only by one country. For majority of the countries, it was reported either as #N/A, or 0%. It must be highlighted that the analysis related to the indicator NSi4.4 is not relevant due to such extremely low availability of transformation services across countries and was excluded from the scoring.
(76)      Cetl V., V. Nunes de Lima, R. Tomas, M. Lutz, J. D'Eugenio, A. Nagy, J. Robbrecht (2017), Summary Report on Status of implementation of the INSPIRE Directive in EU. EUR 28930 EN. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.
(77)      DSi1.1: number of spatial data sets for which metadata exist; DSi1.2: The number of spatial data services for which metadata exist; DSi1.3: The number of spatial data sets for which the metadata contains one or more keywords from a register provided by the Commission indicating that the spatial data set is used for reporting under the environmental legislation; DSi1.4: The number of spatial data sets for which the metadata contains a keyword from a register provided by the Commission indicating that the spatial data set covers regional territory; DSi1.5: The number of spatial data sets for which the metadata contains a keyword from a register provided by the Commission indicating that the spatial data set covers the national territory.
(78)      The indicator MDi1.1 denotes the percentage of metadata for spatial data sets conformant with Commission Regulation (EC) No 1205/2008 as regards metadata, while the indicator MDi1.2 presents the percentage of metadata for spatial data services conformant with Commission Regulation (EC) No 1205/2008 as regards metadata.
(79)      DSi2: Percentage of spatial data sets that are in conformity with Commission Regulation (EU) No 1089/2010 as regards interoperability of spatial data sets; DSi2.1: Percentage of spatial data sets, corresponding to the themes listed in Annex I, that are in conformity with Commission Regulation (EU) No 1089/2010 as regards interoperability of spatial data sets; DSi2.2: Percentage of spatial data sets, corresponding to the themes listed in Annex II, that are in conformity with Commission Regulation (EU) No 1089/2010 as regards interoperability of spatial data sets; DSi2.3: Percentage of spatial data sets, corresponding to the themes listed in Annex III, that are in conformity with Commission Regulation (EU) No 1089/2010 as regards interoperability of spatial data sets.
(80)      Minghini M., Cetl V., Ziemba L., Tomas R., Francioli D., Artasensi D., Epure E., Vinci F. - Establishing a new baseline for monitoring the status of EU Spatial Data Infrastructure, Experiences and conclusions from INSPIRE 2019 monitoring and reporting, EUR 30513 EN, Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg 2020, ISBN 978-92-76-27384-4, doi:10.2760/296219, JRC122351  
(81)      NSi2: The percentage of spatial data sets that are accessible through view and download services; NSi2.1: The percentage of spatial data sets that are accessible through view services; NSi2.2: The percentage of spatial data sets that are accessible through download services.
(82)      Minghini M., Cetl V., Ziemba L., Tomas R., Francioli D., Artasensi D., Epure E., Vinci F. - Establishing a new baseline for monitoring the status of EU Spatial Data Infrastructure, Experiences and conclusions from INSPIRE 2019 monitoring and reporting, EUR 30513 EN, Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg 2020, ISBN 978-92-76-27384-4, doi:10.2760/296219, JRC122351  
(83)      NSi4: The percentage of the network services that are in conformity with Commission Regulation (EC) No 976/2009 as regards the network services; NSi4.1: The percentage of the discovery services that are in conformity with Commission Regulation (EC) No 976/2009 as regards the network services; NSi4.2: The percentage of the view services that are in conformity with Commission Regulation (EC) No 976/2009 as regards the network services; NSi4.3: The percentage of the download services that are in conformity with Commission Regulation (EC) No 976/2009 as regards the network services; NSi4.4: The percentage of the transformation services that are in conformity with Commission Regulation (EC) No 976/2009 as regards the network services.