Choose the experimental features you want to try

This document is an excerpt from the EUR-Lex website

Document 32019D0949

    Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2019/949 of 5 June 2019 excluding from European Union financing certain expenditure incurred by the Member States under the European Agricultural Guarantee Fund (EAGF) and under the European Agricultural Fund for Rural Development (EAFRD) (notified under document C(2019) 3981)

    C/2019/3981

    IO L 152, 11.6.2019, p. 74–96 (BG, ES, CS, DA, DE, ET, EL, EN, FR, HR, IT, LV, LT, HU, MT, NL, PL, PT, RO, SK, SL, FI, SV)

    Legal status of the document In force

    ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/dec_impl/2019/949/oj

    11.6.2019   

    EN

    Official Journal of the European Union

    L 152/74


    COMMISSION IMPLEMENTING DECISION (EU) 2019/949

    of 5 June 2019

    excluding from European Union financing certain expenditure incurred by the Member States under the European Agricultural Guarantee Fund (EAGF) and under the European Agricultural Fund for Rural Development (EAFRD)

    (notified under document C(2019) 3981)

    (Only the Bulgarian, Czech, Danish, Dutch, French, German, Greek, Hungarian, Italian, Polish, Portuguese, Slovak and Spanish texts are authentic)

    THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION,

    Having regard to the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union,

    Having regard to to Regulation (EU) No 1306/2013 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 17 December 2013 on the financing, management and monitoring of the common agricultural policy and repealing Council Regulations (EEC) No 352/78, (EC) No 165/94, (EC) No 2799/98, (EC) No 814/2000, (EC) No 1290/2005 and (EC) No 485/2008 (1), and in particular Article 52 thereof,

    After consulting the Committee on the Agricultural Funds,

    Whereas:

    (1)

    In accordance with Article 52 of Regulation (EU) No 1306/2013 the Commission is to carry out the necessary verifications, communicate to the Member States the results of those verifications, take note of the comments of the Member States, initiate a bilateral discussion so that an agreement may be reached with the Member States in question, and formally communicate its conclusions to them.

    (2)

    The Member States have had an opportunity to request the launch of a conciliation procedure. That opportunity has been used in some cases and the reports issued on the outcome have been examined by the Commission.

    (3)

    In accordance with Regulation (EU) No 1306/2013, only agricultural expenditure which has been incurred in a way that has not infringed Union law may be financed.

    (4)

    In the light of the verifications carried out, the outcome of the bilateral discussions and the conciliation procedures, part of the expenditure declared by the Member States does not fulfil this requirement and cannot, therefore, be financed under the EAGF and the EAFRD.

    (5)

    The amounts that are not recognised as being chargeable to the EAGF and the EAFRD should be indicated. Those amounts do not relate to expenditure incurred more than 24 months before the Commission's written notification of the results of the verifications to the Member States.

    (6)

    The amounts excluded from Union financing by the present Decision should also take into account any reductions or suspensions in accordance with Article 41 of Regulation (EU) No 1306/2013 due to the fact that such reductions or suspensions are of a provisional nature and without prejudice to decisions taken pursuant to Articles 51 or 52 of that Regulation.

    (7)

    As regards the cases covered by this decision, the assessment of the amounts to be excluded on grounds of non-compliance with Union law was notified by the Commission to the Member States in a summary report on the subject (2).

    (8)

    This Decision is without prejudice to any financial conclusions that the Commission may draw from the judgments of the Court of Justice of the European Union in cases pending on 1 April 2019,

    HAS ADOPTED THIS DECISION:

    Article 1

    The amounts set out in the Annex and related to expenditure incurred by the Member States' accredited paying agencies and declared under the EAGF or the EAFRD shall be excluded from Union financing.

    Article 2

    This Decision is addressed to the Kingdom of Belgium, the Republic of Bulgaria, the Czech Republic, the Kingdom of Denmark, the Federal Republic of Germany, the Hellenic Republic, the Kingdom of Spain, the French Republic, the Italian Republic, Hungary, the Republic of Austria, the Republic of Poland, the Portuguese Republic and the Slovak Republic.

    Done at Brussels, 5 June 2019.

    For the Commission

    Phil HOGAN

    Member of the Commission


    (1)   OJ L 347, 20.12.2013, p. 549.

    (2)  Ares(2019)3170272


    ANNEX

    Decision: 60

    Budget Item: 050452

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    GR

    Rural Development EAGGF (2000-2006) - Improving the competitiveness

    2011

    Reimbursement following judgment in case C-670/17P

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    72 105 592,41

    0,00

    72 105 592,41

     

     

     

     

     

    Total GR:

    EUR

    72 105 592,41

    0,00

    72 105 592,41


    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    EUR

    72 105 592,41

    0,00

    72 105 592,41

    Budget Item: 05070107

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    FR

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2012

    Reimbursement following judgment in case T-156/15

    FLAT RATE

    100,00 %

    EUR

    9 630 390,11

    0,00

    9 630 390,11

     

    Other Direct Aid - Article 68-72 of Reg. 73/2009

    2012

    Reimbursement following judgment in case T-156/15

    FLAT RATE

    100,00 %

    EUR

    1 576 620,23

    0,00

    1 576 620,23

     

    Other Direct Aids

    2012

    Reimbursement following judgment in case T-156/15

    FLAT RATE

    100,00 %

    EUR

    968 446,88

    – 0,01

    968 446,89

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2013

    Reimbursement following judgment in case T-156/15

    FLAT RATE

    100,00 %

    EUR

    9 594 884,58

    0,00

    9 594 884,58

     

    Other Direct Aid - Article 68-72 of Reg. 73/2009

    2013

    Reimbursement following judgment in case T-156/15

    FLAT RATE

    100,00 %

    EUR

    1 651 565,64

    0,00

    1 651 565,64

     

    Other Direct Aids

    2013

    Reimbursement following judgment in case T-156/15

    FLAT RATE

    100,00 %

    EUR

    930 600,78

    0,00

    930 600,78

     

     

     

     

     

    Total FR:

    EUR

    24 352 508,22

    – 0,01

    24 352 508,23


    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    EUR

    24 352 508,22

    – 0,01

    24 352 508,23

    Budget Item: 6701

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    AT

    Certification

    2017

    CEB/2018/001/AT

    Errors in the EAGF population

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 244 593,89

    – 124,07

    – 244 469,82

     

     

     

     

     

    Total AT:

    EUR

    – 244 593,89

    – 124,07

    – 244 469,82

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    BE

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2017

    Weakness in administrative checks in respect of the aid claimed

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 12 999,05

    0,00

    – 12 999,05

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2016

    Weakness in administrative checks in respect of the aid claimed

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 27 973,79

    0,00

    – 27 973,79

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2016

    Weakness in the correct calculation of the aid including administrative reductions and penalties

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 14 715,59

    0,00

    – 14 715,59

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2017

    Weakness in the correct calculation of the aid including administrative reductions and penalties

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 12 418,85

    0,00

    – 12 418,85

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2016

    Weakness in the performance of OTSC of sufficient quality

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 29 289,00

    0,00

    – 29 289,00

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2016

    Weakness in the performance of crosschecks to establish eligibility of the parcel declared

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 2 191,26

    0,00

    – 2 191,26

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2018

    Weakness in the performance of OTSC of sufficient quality

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 37 795,75

    0,00

    – 37 795,75

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2017

    Weakness in the performance of OTSC of sufficient quality

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 39 280,16

    0,00

    – 39 280,16

     

     

     

     

     

    Total BE:

    EUR

    – 176 663,45

    0,00

    – 176 663,45

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    BG

    Promotion Measures

    2013

    competitive selection of implementing bodies

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 9 095,98

    0,00

    – 9 095,98

     

    Promotion Measures

    2014

    competitive selection of implementing bodies

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 59 411,71

    0,00

    – 59 411,71

     

    Promotion Measures

    2015

    competitive selection of implementing bodies

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 40 564,98

    0,00

    – 40 564,98

     

    Promotion Measures

    2016

    competitive selection of implementing bodies

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 33 543,97

    0,00

    – 33 543,97

     

    Promotion Measures

    2017

    competitive selection of implementing bodies

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 51 618,39

    0,00

    – 51 618,39

     

    Promotion Measures

    2018

    competitive selection of implementing bodies

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 28 896,31

    0,00

    – 28 896,31

     

     

     

     

     

    Total BG:

    EUR

    – 223 131,34

    0,00

    – 223 131,34

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    DE

    Certification

    2014

    financial errors detected by CB

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 2 044,54

    – 623,96

    – 1 420,58

     

    Certification

    2015

    financial errors detected by CB

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 49 706,62

    0,00

    – 49 706,62

     

    Certification

    2016

    financial errors detected by CB

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 7 164,69

    – 143,01

    – 7 021,68

     

     

     

     

     

    Total DE:

    EUR

    – 58 915,85

    – 766,97

    – 58 148,88

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    ES

    Clearance of Accounts - Financial Clearance

    2017

    1 error coming from substantive testing

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 54 828,84

    0,00

    – 54 828,84

     

    Clearance of Accounts - Financial Clearance

    2017

    2 errors coming from substantive testing

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 45 558,72

    0,00

    – 45 558,72

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2016

    Calculation of administrative reductions for late lodging

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 204,40

    0,00

    – 204,40

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2017

    Calculation of administrative reductions for late lodging

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 370,28

    0,00

    – 370,28

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2018

    Calculation of administrative reductions for late lodging

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 9,09

    0,00

    – 9,09

     

    Fruit and Vegetables - Operational programmes incl withdrawals

    2016

    Deficiencies in two key controls affecting certain actions OP 2015

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 321 760,21

    0,00

    – 321 760,21

     

    Fruit and Vegetables - Operational programmes incl withdrawals

    2017

    Deficiencies in two key controls affecting certain actions OP 2015

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 19 356,88

    0,00

    – 19 356,88

     

    Fruit and Vegetables - Operational programmes incl withdrawals

    2015

    Deficiencies in two key controls affecting several type of actions OP 2014

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 308 998,78

    0,00

    – 308 998,78

     

    Fruit and Vegetables - Operational programmes incl withdrawals

    2016

    Deficiencies in two key controls affecting several type of actions OP 2014

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 25 996,02

    0,00

    – 25 996,02

     

    Fruit and Vegetables - Operational programmes incl withdrawals

    2016

    Deficiencies in two key controls affecting several types of actions in OP 2016

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 12 943,95

    0,00

    – 12 943,95

     

    Fruit and Vegetables - Operational programmes incl withdrawals

    2017

    Deficiencies in two key controls affecting several types of actions in OP 2016

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 368 280,61

    0,00

    – 368 280,61

     

    Other Direct Aid - POSEI (2014+)

    2017

    Known errors EAGF population

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 14 613,06

    0,00

    – 14 613,06

     

    Clearance of Accounts - Financial Clearance

    2016

    MLE

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 71 516,80

    – 0,23

    – 71 516,57

     

    Fruit and Vegetables - Operational programmes incl withdrawals

    2017

    Non eligible cost for environmental action ES01 - OP 2016

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 269 821,58

    0,00

    – 269 821,58

     

    Fruit and Vegetables - Operational programmes incl withdrawals

    2017

    Non eligible cost for environmental action ES03 - OP 2016

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 98,45

    0,00

    – 98,45

     

    Fruit and Vegetables - Operational programmes incl withdrawals

    2016

    Non eligible cost for environmental action ES04 - OP 2016

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 14 818,73

    0,00

    – 14 818,73

     

    Fruit and Vegetables - Operational programmes incl withdrawals

    2016

    Non eligible cost for environmental action ES07 - OP 2016

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 1 368,84

    0,00

    – 1 368,84

     

    Fruit and Vegetables - Operational programmes incl withdrawals

    2017

    Non eligible cost for environmental action ES07 - OP 2016

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 2 530,89

    0,00

    – 2 530,89

     

    Fruit and Vegetables - Operational programmes incl withdrawals

    2017

    Non eligible cost for environmental action ES08 - OP 2016

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 1 579,72

    0,00

    – 1 579,72

     

    Fruit and Vegetables - Operational programmes incl withdrawals

    2017

    Non eligible cost for environmental action ES10 - OP 2016

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 29 651,25

    0,00

    – 29 651,25

     

    Fruit and Vegetables - Operational programmes incl withdrawals

    2016

    Non eligible cost for environmental action ES13 - OP 2016

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 10 261,27

    0,00

    – 10 261,27

     

    Fruit and Vegetables - Operational programmes incl withdrawals

    2017

    Non eligible cost for environmental action ES13 - OP 2016

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 291 953,22

    0,00

    – 291 953,22

     

    Fruit and Vegetables - Operational programmes incl withdrawals

    2016

    Non eligible cost for environmental action ES14 - OP 2016

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 430,01

    0,00

    – 430,01

     

    Fruit and Vegetables - Operational programmes incl withdrawals

    2017

    Non eligible cost for environmental action ES14 - OP 2016

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 57 303,49

    0,00

    – 57 303,49

     

    Fruit and Vegetables - Operational programmes incl withdrawals

    2017

    Non eligible cost for environmental action ES16 - OP 2016

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 10 206,61

    0,00

    – 10 206,61

     

    Fruit and Vegetables - Operational programmes incl withdrawals

    2016

    Non eligible cost for environmental action ES17 - OP 2016

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 29 177,46

    0,00

    – 29 177,46

     

    Fruit and Vegetables - Operational programmes incl withdrawals

    2017

    Non eligible cost for environmental action ES17 - OP 2016

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 462 341,09

    0,00

    – 462 341,09

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2016

    Quality of on-the-spot-checks

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 25 491,94

    0,00

    – 25 491,94

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2017

    Quality of on-the-spot-checks

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 51 397,83

    0,00

    – 51 397,83

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2018

    Quality of on-the-spot-checks

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 3 062,37

    0,00

    – 3 062,37

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2018

    SFS ES02

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 389 305,22

    0,00

    – 389 305,22

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2018

    SFS ES03

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 93 315,18

    0,00

    – 93 315,18

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2018

    SFS ES04

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 13 113,20

    0,00

    – 13 113,20

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2018

    SFS ES06

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 1 340,58

    0,00

    – 1 340,58

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2018

    SFS ES07

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 453 708,92

    0,00

    – 453 708,92

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2018

    SFS ES08

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 123 869,40

    0,00

    – 123 869,40

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2018

    SFS ES09

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 112 568,54

    0,00

    – 112 568,54

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2018

    SFS ES10

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 259 027,07

    0,00

    – 259 027,07

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2018

    SFS ES11

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 87 011,45

    0,00

    – 87 011,45

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2018

    SFS ES12

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 8 781,25

    0,00

    – 8 781,25

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2018

    SFS ES13

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 30 805,25

    0,00

    – 30 805,25

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2018

    SFS ES14

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 8 098,76

    0,00

    – 8 098,76

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2018

    SFS ES15

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 135 664,65

    0,00

    – 135 664,65

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2018

    SFS ES16

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 43 253,37

    0,00

    – 43 253,37

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2018

    SFS ES17

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 254 178,60

    0,00

    – 254 178,60

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2018

    Small Farmers Scheme ES01

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 1 594 286,40

    0,00

    – 1 594 286,40

     

     

     

     

     

    Total ES:

    EUR

    – 6 114 260,23

    – 0,23

    – 6 114 260,00

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    FR

    Wine - Investment

    2014

    administrative control weakness. Non application of Art. 19 of Reg. 555/2008

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 26 203,46

    0,00

    – 26 203,46

     

    Wine - Investment

    2015

    administrative control weakness. Non application of Art. 19 of Reg. 555/2008

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 53 953,04

    0,00

    – 53 953,04

     

    Wine - Investment

    2016

    administrative control weakness. Non application of Art. 19 of Reg. 555/2008

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 110 333,61

    – 41 120,58

    – 69 213,03

     

    Wine - Investment

    2017

    administrative control weakness. Non application of Art. 19 of Reg. 555/2008

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 234 535,04

    0,00

    – 234 535,04

     

    Cross-compliance

    2015

    DP - CY 2014 - Deficient scope of SMR 4 checks

    FLAT RATE

    2,00 %

    EUR

    – 4 735 519,50

    – 652 058,51

    – 4 083 460,99

     

    Cross-compliance

    2016

    DP - CY 2015 - Deficient scope of SMR 4 checks, GAEC not achieving objective

    FLAT RATE

    2,00 %

    EUR

    – 6 401 557,55

    – 12 509,90

    – 6 389 047,65

     

    Cross-compliance

    2017

    DP - CY 2016 - Deficient scope of SMR 4 checks, GAEC not achieving objective

    FLAT RATE

    2,00 %

    EUR

    – 6 130 471,10

    0,00

    – 6 130 471,10

     

    Certification

    2015

    Erreur connue sur les tests de créances - anomalie ou dossier non présenté

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 3 626,53

    0,00

    – 3 626,53

     

    Certification

    2015

    Erreurs tests de conformité créances

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 299 346,32

    0,00

    – 299 346,32

     

    Milk - Other

    2016

    Ineligible expenditure in the temporary exceptional aid under 1853/2015 for the measure to subsidize loan costs in the live sector

    ESTIMATED BY PERCENTAGE

    3,49 %

    EUR

    – 42 266,97

    – 22 568,21

    – 19 698,76

     

    Temporary and exceptional support measures

    2016

    Ineligible expenditure in the temporary exceptional aid under 1853/2015 for the measure to subsidize loan costs in the live sector

    ESTIMATED BY PERCENTAGE

    3,49 %

    EUR

    – 33 608,98

    – 13 573,20

    – 20 035,78

     

    Certification

    2016

    Known errors in EAGF Non-IACS

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 7 737,00

    0,00

    – 7 737,00

     

    Certification

    2016

    MLE EAGF for FY 2016

    ESTIMATED BY AMOUNT

     

    EUR

    – 2 427 577,79

    – 1 268 772,69

    – 1 158 805,10

     

    Certification

    2016

    MLE IN EAGF Non-IACS

    ESTIMATED BY AMOUNT

     

    EUR

    – 8 808 247,56

    – 1 834 453,27

    – 6 973 794,29

     

    Certification

    2016

    Payment delays and irregularities

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 4 827 821,58

    0,00

    – 4 827 821,58

     

     

     

     

     

    Total FR:

    EUR

    – 34 142 806,03

    – 3 845 056,36

    – 30 297 749,67

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    GR

    Certification

    2016

    financial errors resulting from compliance testing and from the substantive established for EAGF non-IACS

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 378 466,15

    – 125 695,79

    – 252 770,36

     

    Certification

    2016

    Known errors established for EAGF IACS

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 4 849,56

    – 285,01

    – 4 564,55

     

    Certification

    2016

    MLE for the EAGF non-IACS population

    ESTIMATED BY AMOUNT

     

    EUR

    – 1 231 590,15

    – 164 655,21

    – 1 066 934,94

     

    Certification

    2016

    Most Likely Error (MLE) for the EAGF IACS population.

    Financial errors resulting from the substantive testing of the EAGF IACS population, which are not accepted as ‘known errors’, as they do not meet all the conditions stipulated in Guideline No 2.

    ESTIMATED BY AMOUNT

     

    EUR

    – 9 191 375,64

    – 3 131 051,66

    – 6 060 323,98

     

    Voluntary Coupled Support

    2016

    VCS Measure 6 - CY 2015

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 1 106 829,36

    – 4 949,59

    – 1 101 879,77

     

    Voluntary Coupled Support

    2017

    VCS Measure 6 - CY 2016

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 620 098,02

    0,00

    – 620 098,02

     

     

     

     

     

    Total GR:

    EUR

    – 12 533 208,88

    – 3 426 637,26

    – 9 106 571,62

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    HU

    Certification

    2017

    Financial errors detected by the CB for the EAGF in the context of the certification audit for FY2017

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 174 675,42

    0,00

    – 174 675,42

     

    Financial audit - Overshooting

    2017

    Overrun of ceiling

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 155 193,34

    0,00

    – 155 193,34

     

     

     

     

     

    Total HU:

    EUR

    – 329 868,76

    0,00

    – 329 868,76

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

     

    Irregularities

    2016

    Negligence in the debt management for some irregularities

    ONE OFF

     

    HUF

    – 560 597 219,00

    0,00

    – 560 597 219,00

     

     

     

     

     

    Total HU:

    HUF

    – 560 597 219,00

    0,00

    – 560 597 219,00

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    IT

    Fruit and Vegetables - Operational programmes incl withdrawals

    2015

    OP 2015 - Weakness in key control ‘1.1 - Checks to establish the access to the aid claimed’ - Soundness of estimates and aid plan.

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 221 515,41

    0,00

    – 221 515,41

     

    Fruit and Vegetables - Operational programmes incl withdrawals

    2016

    OP 2015 - Weakness in key control ‘1.1 - Checks to establish the access to the aid claimed’ - Soundness of estimates and aid plan.

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 354 973,50

    0,00

    – 354 973,50

     

    Fruit and Vegetables - Operational programmes incl withdrawals

    2017

    OP 2016 - Weakness in key control ‘1.1 - Checks to establish the access to the aid claimed’ - Soundness of estimates and aid plan.

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 572 955,52

    0,00

    – 572 955,52

     

    Promotion Measures

    2011

    wide-spread irregularities affecting the competitive selection procedues

    FLAT RATE

    25,00 %

    EUR

    – 224 182,53

    0,00

    – 224 182,53

     

    Promotion Measures

    2012

    wide-spread irregularities affecting the competitive selection procedues

    FLAT RATE

    25,00 %

    EUR

    – 759 468,11

    0,00

    – 759 468,11

     

    Promotion Measures

    2013

    wide-spread irregularities affecting the competitive selection procedues

    FLAT RATE

    25,00 %

    EUR

    – 1 271 140,33

    0,00

    – 1 271 140,33

     

    Promotion Measures

    2014

    wide-spread irregularities affecting the competitive selection procedues

    FLAT RATE

    25,00 %

    EUR

    – 1 503 826,13

    0,00

    – 1 503 826,13

     

    Promotion Measures

    2015

    wide-spread irregularities affecting the competitive selection procedues

    FLAT RATE

    25,00 %

    EUR

    – 1 515 488,76

    0,00

    – 1 515 488,76

     

    Promotion Measures

    2016

    wide-spread irregularities affecting the competitive selection procedues

    FLAT RATE

    25,00 %

    EUR

    – 1 734 102,30

    0,00

    – 1 734 102,30

     

     

     

     

     

    Total IT:

    EUR

    – 8 157 652,59

    0,00

    – 8 157 652,59

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    PL

    Certification

    2017

    CEB/2018/073/PL - errors in the EAGF population

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 671 437,45

    0,00

    – 671 437,45

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2016

    effectiveness of the/absence of effective risk factors CY2015

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 2 113 458,68

    0,00

    – 2 113 458,68

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2017

    effectiveness of the/absence of effective risk factors CY2015

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 3 418,28

    0,00

    – 3 418,28

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2018

    effectiveness of the/absence of effective risk factors CY2015

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 642,19

    0,00

    – 642,19

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2017

    effectiveness of the/absence of effective risk factors CY2016

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 2 145 081,96

    0,00

    – 2 145 081,96

     

    Decoupled Direct Aids

    2018

    effectiveness of the/absence of effective risk factors CY2016

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 2 027,32

    0,00

    – 2 027,32

     

    Reimbursement of direct aids in relation to financial discipline

    2017

    effectiveness of the/absence of effective risk factors FD

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 62 762,45

    0,00

    – 62 762,45

     

    Reimbursement of direct aids in relation to financial discipline

    2018

    effectiveness of the/absence of effective risk factors FD

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 61 383,50

    0,00

    – 61 383,50

     

     

     

     

     

    Total PL:

    EUR

    – 5 060 211,83

    0,00

    – 5 060 211,83

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    SK

    Certification

    2016

    CEB/2017/080/SK - Known error in EAGF

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 19 782,57

    – 0,65

    – 19 781,92

     

     

     

     

     

    Total SK:

    EUR

    – 19 782,57

    – 0,65

    – 19 781,92


    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    EUR

    – 67 061 095,42

    – 7 272 585,54

    – 59 788 509,88

    HUF

    – 560 597 219,00

    0,00

    – 560 597 219,00

    Budget Item: 6711

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    AT

    Certification

    2017

    CEB/2018/001/AT

    Errors in the EAFRD population

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 47,27

    0,00

    – 47,27

     

     

     

     

     

    Total AT:

    EUR

    – 47,27

    0,00

    – 47,27

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    BE

    Rural Development EAFRD measures subject to IACS

    2015

    M10: Contrôles des critères d'admissibilité - année de demande 2015 - du 8.8.2015 au 31.12.2015

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 22 522,68

    0,00

    – 22 522,68

     

    Rural Development EAFRD measures subject to IACS

    2016

    M10: Contrôles des critères d'admissibilité - année de demande 2015 - du 8.8.2015 au 31.12.2015

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 6 053,91

    0,00

    – 6 053,91

     

    Rural Development EAFRD measures subject to IACS

    2018

    M10: Contrôles des critères d'admissibilité - année de demande 2017 - année financière 2018

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 200,25

    0,00

    – 200,25

     

    Rural Development EAFRD measures subject to IACS

    2016

    M10: Contrôles des critères d'admissibilité - années de demande 2015 et 2016 - années financières 2016 et 2017

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 2 445,12

    0,00

    – 2 445,12

     

    Rural Development EAFRD measures subject to IACS

    2017

    M10: Contrôles des critères d'admissibilité - années de demande 2015 et 2016 - années financières 2016 et 2017

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 862,56

    0,00

    – 862,56

     

    Rural Development EAFRD measures subject to IACS

    2018

    M10-M11: Qualité suffisante des contrôles sur place - année de demande 2017 - année financière 2018

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 656 898,08

    0,00

    – 656 898,08

     

    Rural Development EAFRD measures subject to IACS

    2016

    M10-M11: Qualité suffisante des contrôles sur place - années de demande 2015 et 2016 - années financières 2016 et 2017

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 501 261,87

    – 19 909,38

    – 481 352,49

     

    Rural Development EAFRD measures subject to IACS

    2017

    M10-M11: Qualité suffisante des contrôles sur place - années de demande 2015 et 2016 - années financières 2016 et 2017

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 591 934,60

    0,00

    – 591 934,60

     

    Rural Development EAFRD measures subject to IACS

    2016

    M11: Contrôles des critères d'admissibilité - années de demande 2015 et 2016 - années financières 2016 et 2017

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 19 091,54

    0,00

    – 19 091,54

     

    Rural Development EAFRD measures subject to IACS

    2017

    M11: Contrôles des critères d'admissibilité - années de demande 2015 et 2016 - années financières 2016 et 2017

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 1 981,00

    0,00

    – 1 981,00

     

     

     

     

     

    Total BE:

    EUR

    – 1 803 251,61

    – 19 909,38

    – 1 783 342,23

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    BG

    Certification

    2015

    Clearance of EAFRD accounts decision related to the last execution year (16.10.2014-31.12.2015) in respect of the 2007-2013 programming period – Paying Agency BG01 – State Fund Agriculture - Extrapolated correction

    ESTIMATED BY AMOUNT

     

    EUR

    – 4 884 875,78

    – 105 195,63

    – 4 779 680,15

     

    Certification

    2016

    Clearance of EAFRD accounts decision related to the last execution year (16.10.2014-31.12.2015) in respect of the 2007-2013 programming period – Paying Agency BG01 – State Fund Agriculture - Extrapolated correction

    ESTIMATED BY AMOUNT

     

    EUR

    – 8 519 759,96

    0,00

    – 8 519 759,96

     

     

     

     

     

    Total BG:

    EUR

    – 13 404 635,74

    – 105 195,63

    – 13 299 440,11

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    CZ

    Rural Development EAFRD Measures with flat-rate support

    2015

    M313: Deficiency in one key control - FY 2015

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 158 095,58

    0,00

    – 158 095,58

     

     

     

     

     

    Total CZ:

    EUR

    – 158 095,58

    0,00

    – 158 095,58

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    DE

    Certification

    2016

    financial errors detected by CB

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 48 037,60

    – 34 606,25

    – 13 431,35

     

     

     

     

     

    Total DE:

    EUR

    – 48 037,60

    – 34 606,25

    – 13 431,35

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    DK

    Rural Development EAFRD Leader

    2016

    Deficiencies in key controls and absences of ancillary controls - Continuation of Financial correction 3455 of audit RD3/2015/016/DK

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 29 636,79

    0,00

    – 29 636,79

     

    Rural Development EAFRD Leader

    2016

    Deficiencies in key controls and absences of ancillary controls - Continuation of Financial correction 3455 of audit RD3/2015/016/DK

    FLAT RATE

    10,00 %

    EUR

    – 18 068,66

    0,00

    – 18 068,66

     

    Rural Development EAFRD Leader

    2018

    Deficiencies in key controls and absences of ancillary controls - Continuation of Financial correction 3455 of audit RD3/2015/016/DK

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 26 643,18

    0,00

    – 26 643,18

     

     

     

     

     

    Total DK:

    EUR

    – 74 348,63

    0,00

    – 74 348,63

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    ES

    Rural Development EAFRD Knowledge and innovation

    2017

    known errors in EAFRD population

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 401 981,04

    0,00

    – 401 981,04

     

    Clearance of Accounts - Financial Clearance

    2016

    MLE

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 28 886,62

    0,00

    – 28 886,62

     

    Certification

    2017

    MLE in EAFRD population

    ESTIMATED BY AMOUNT

     

    EUR

    – 21 548,63

    0,00

    – 21 548,63

     

     

     

     

     

    Total ES:

    EUR

    – 452 416,29

    0,00

    – 452 416,29

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    FR

    Certification

    2015

    Erreur connue 5T adjacente HSIGC_32

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 3 516,32

    0,00

    – 3 516,32

     

    Certification

    2015

    Erreur connue - test HSIGC_107

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 22 243,89

    0,00

    – 22 243,89

     

    Certification

    2015

    Erreur connue - test HSIGC_111

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 11 776,80

    0,00

    – 11 776,80

     

    Certification

    2015

    Erreur connue - test HSIGC_114

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 9 277,33

    0,00

    – 9 277,33

     

    Certification

    2015

    Erreur connue - test HSIGC_117

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 2 595,00

    – 51,90

    – 2 543,10

     

    Certification

    2015

    Erreur connue - test HSIGC_125

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 3 110,00

    0,00

    – 3 110,00

     

    Certification

    2015

    Erreur connue - test HSIGC_96

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 5 667,02

    0,00

    – 5 667,02

     

    Certification

    2015

    Erreur connue - test HSIGC_97

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 110 670,00

    0,00

    – 110 670,00

     

    Certification

    2015

    Erreur connue - test SIGC_45

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 33,69

    0,00

    – 33,69

     

    Certification

    2015

    Erreur connue - test SIGC_48

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 85,08

    0,00

    – 85,08

     

    Certification

    2016

    Erreur extrapolée - 5eme trimestre de l'EF2015 - Agence de Services et de Paiement

    ESTIMATED BY AMOUNT

     

    EUR

    – 10 386 236,30

    – 4 267 954,16

    – 6 118 282,14

     

    Certification

    2015

    Erreur la plus probable – 16.10.2014-15.10.2015

    ESTIMATED BY AMOUNT

     

    EUR

    – 49 445 057,00

    – 13 827 302,63

    – 35 617 754,37

     

    Certification

    2015

    Erreur test de conformité avance no 3

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 10 666,80

    0,00

    – 10 666,80

     

    Certification

    2015

    Erreur test de conformité no 21

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 60 000,00

    0,00

    – 60 000,00

     

    Rural Development EAFRD Technical Assistance (2007-2013)

    2014

    Projets assujettis aux règles des marchés publics - Assistance Technique - année 2014

    FLAT RATE

    7,00 %

    EUR

    – 20 326,87

    – 3,61

    – 20 323,26

     

    Rural Development EAFRD investment - public beneficiaries

    2015

    Projets assujettis aux règles des marchés publics - Assistance Technique - années 2015 et 2016

    FLAT RATE

    7,00 %

    EUR

    – 162 511,43

    0,00

    – 162 511,43

     

    Rural Development EAFRD investment - public beneficiaries

    2016

    Projets assujettis aux règles des marchés publics - Assistance Technique - années 2015 et 2016

    FLAT RATE

    7,00 %

    EUR

    – 461 686,57

    0,00

    – 461 686,57

     

    Rural Development EAFRD Technical Assistance (2007-2013)

    2014

    Projets non assujettis aux règles des marchés publics - Assistance Technique - année 2014

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 35 958,05

    – 6,38

    – 35 951,67

     

    Rural Development EAFRD investment - public beneficiaries

    2015

    Projets non assujettis aux règles des marchés publics - Assistance Technique - années 2015 et 2016

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 143 907,17

    0,00

    – 143 907,17

     

    Rural Development EAFRD investment - public beneficiaries

    2016

    Projets non assujettis aux règles des marchés publics - Assistance Technique - années 2015 et 2016

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 68 193,15

    0,00

    – 68 193,15

     

     

     

     

     

    Total FR:

    EUR

    – 60 963 518,47

    – 18 095 318,68

    – 42 868 199,79

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    HU

    Rural Development EAFRD investment - private beneficiaries

    2016

    Deficiencies in key control ‘verification that public procurement procedures are in compliance with relevant procurement rules’

    FLAT RATE

    3,00 %

    EUR

    – 260,01

    – 8,67

    – 251,34

     

    Rural Development EAFRD investment - public beneficiaries

    2016

    Deficiencies in key control ‘verification that public procurement procedures are in compliance with relevant procurement rules’

    FLAT RATE

    3,00 %

    EUR

    – 1 532 196,09

    – 51 073,21

    – 1 481 122,88

     

    Rural Development EAFRD Measures with flat-rate support

    2016

    Deficiencies in key control ‘verification that public procurement procedures are in compliance with relevant procurement rules’

    FLAT RATE

    3,00 %

    EUR

    – 348 959,87

    – 11 632,00

    – 337 327,87

     

    Rural Development EAFRD investment - private beneficiaries

    2017

    Deficiencies in key control ‘verification that public procurement procedures are in compliance with relevant procurement rules’

    FLAT RATE

    3,00 %

    EUR

    – 5 380,04

    – 179,34

    – 5 200,70

     

    Rural Development EAFRD investment - public beneficiaries

    2017

    Deficiencies in key control ‘verification that public procurement procedures are in compliance with relevant procurement rules’

    FLAT RATE

    3,00 %

    EUR

    – 7 499,04

    – 249,97

    – 7 249,07

     

    Rural Development EAFRD Measures with flat-rate support

    2017

    Deficiencies in key control ‘verification that public procurement procedures are in compliance with relevant procurement rules’

    FLAT RATE

    3,00 %

    EUR

    – 682,47

    – 22,75

    – 659,72

     

    Certification

    2017

    Financial errors detected for the EAFRD during the certification of EAFRD FY2017

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 3 291,78

    0,00

    – 3 291,78

     

     

     

     

     

    Total HU:

    EUR

    – 1 898 269,30

    – 63 165,94

    – 1 835 103,36

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    PL

    Certification

    2017

    CEB/2018/073/PL - errors in the EAFRD population

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 51 877,48

    0,00

    – 51 877,48

     

     

     

     

     

    Total PL:

    EUR

    – 51 877,48

    0,00

    – 51 877,48

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    PT

    Rural Development EAFRD investment - private beneficiaries

    2015

    The reasonableness of the costs is not properly assessed

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 219 054,43

    – 17 662,44

    – 201 391,99

     

    Rural Development EAFRD investment - private beneficiaries

    2016

    The reasonableness of the costs is not properly assessed

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 88 055,91

    – 5 225,71

    – 82 830,20

     

    Rural Development EAFRD investment - private beneficiaries

    2017

    The reasonableness of the costs is not properly assessed

    FLAT RATE

    5,00 %

    EUR

    – 20 221,69

    0,00

    – 20 221,69

     

     

     

     

     

    Total PT:

    EUR

    – 327 332,03

    – 22 888,15

    – 304 443,88

    Member State

    Measure

    FY

    Reason

    Type

    Correction %

    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    SK

    Certification

    2016

    CEB/2017/080/SK - MLE in EAFRD

    ESTIMATED BY AMOUNT

     

    EUR

    – 4 112 948,58

    0,00

    – 4 112 948,58

     

    Rural Development EAFRD investment - private beneficiaries

    2015

    FY 2015 one-off SME criterea

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 739 799,46

    0,00

    – 739 799,46

     

    Rural Development EAFRD investment - private beneficiaries

    2017

    FY 2017 one-off SME criterea

    ONE OFF

     

    EUR

    – 177 375,00

    0,00

    – 177 375,00

     

     

     

     

     

    Total SK:

    EUR

    – 5 030 123,04

    0,00

    – 5 030 123,04


    Currency

    Amount

    Deductions

    Financial Impact

    EUR

    – 84 211 953,04

    – 18 341 084,03

    – 65 870 869,01


    Top