This site is a part of

Access to European Union law

| EUROPA > EUR-Lex Home > ID celex

62010CC0577

Title and reference

Opinion of Mr Advocate General Cruz Villalón delivered on 19 July 2012.

European Commission v Kingdom of Belgium.

Failure of a Member State to fulfil obligations - Article 56 TFEU - Freedom to provide services - National legislation which imposes a prior declaration requirement on self-employed service providers established in other Member States - Criminal penalties - Obstacle to freedom to provide services - Objectively justified distinction - Overriding requirements in the public interest - Prevention of fraud - Protection against unfair competition - Protection of self-employed workers - Proportionality.

Case C-577/10.

European Court Reports 2012 Page 00000

Text

Authentic language

French

Dates

Classifications

Subject matter:
freedom of establishment and freedom to provide services, Right of establishment

Miscellaneous information

Author:
Court of Justice of the European Union
Form:
Advocate General's Opinion

Procedure

Type of procedure:
Action for failure to fulfil obligations - successful
Applicant:
Commission, Institutions
Defendant:
Belgium , Member States
Observations:
...........................................................
Nationality of parties:
Belgium
Judge-Rapporteur:
Jarašiūnas
Advocate General:
Cruz Villalón

Relationship between documents

Treaty:
Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union

Instruments cited in case law:
11997E046 : N 44

12007P031 : N 45

12008E009 : N 45

12008E052 : N 1 28

12008E056 : N 1 25 28 32

12008M003-P3 : N 45

31996L0071 : N 25 26 31 49 57

32006L0123 : N 53 54

61974CJ0033 : N 32

61975CJ0039 : N 32

61984CJ0205 : N 32

61988CJ0130 : N 32

61989CJ0113 : N 30

61989CJ0180 : N 40

61991CJ0106 : N 40

61991CJ0211 : N 32

61995CJ0398 : N 25

61996CJ0369 : N 25 30

61997CC0124 : N 58

61998CJ0049 : N 25 33

61998CJ0067 : N 58

61998CJ0165 : N 25 49

61999CJ0164 : N 25 49

61999CJ0309 : N 25

61999CJ0493 : N 30

62001CJ0243 : N 58

62001CJ0256 : N 46

62002CJ0341 : N 25 30 31 39 40 56

62003CJ0060 : N 25 42 50

62003CJ0445 : N 56

62004CJ0168 : N 25 30

62004CJ0490 : N 25

62005CJ0002 : N 25

62005CJ0341 : N 25 31 42

62006CJ0319 : N 25 40 58

62006CJ0500 : N 58

62007CJ0161 : N 48

62007CJ0169 : N 58

62007CJ0171 : N 58

62008CJ0046 : N 30 31

62008CO0104 : N 25

62008CJ0219 : N 25 56

62008CJ0341 : N 58

62008CJ0515 : N 25 30

62009CJ0028 : N 58

62009CJ0255 : N 40

62009CJ0298 : N 25

62009CJ0307 : N 25

62010CJ0159 : N 58

62010CJ0357 : N 58
Select all documents mentioning this document

Top

Managed by the Publications Office